Multi-principal element alloy materials and method of use
The MPEA filler material addresses cost and phase issues in existing fillers by providing a disordered face-centered cubic structure with specific elements, improving tensile strength and oxidation resistance for wider gaps, thus enhancing metallurgical joins in industrial applications.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/US2026/027180
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2025-05-08
- Filing Date
- 2026-05-07
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-12
AI Technical Summary
Existing filler materials for metallurgical joining, particularly in industries like gas turbine engines and concentrated solar power, face challenges with high noble metal content leading to cost inefficiencies and undesirable phases, and struggle with gaps wider than 100 microns, promoting boride, silicide, or phosphide phases that reduce component lifetime.
A multi-principal element alloy (MPEA) filler material with an entropically-stabilized disordered face-centered cubic structure, free of boron, silicon, and phosphorous, and containing elements like chromium, iron, and copper, which maintains oxidation resistance and flow characteristics while avoiding large precious metal concentrations.
The MPEA filler material demonstrates superior tensile strength, oxidation resistance, and ability to fill wider gaps, with joints exhibiting higher tensile stress and deformation resistance compared to traditional Ni-Cr-Si fillers, enhancing the durability and effectiveness of metallurgical joins.
Smart Images

Figure US2026027180_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
INTERNATIONAL PATENT APPLICATIONMULTI-PRINCIPAL ELEMENT ALLOY MATERIALSAND METHOD OF USECROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0001] This application claims priority to and the benefit of the filing of U.S.Provisional Patent Application No. 63 / 802,401, entitled “MULTI-PRINCIPAL ELEMENT ALLOY MATERIALS WITH OXIDATION RESISTANT CONSTITUENTS AND METHOD OF USE,” filed May 8, 2025.STATEMENT REGARDING FEDERALLY SPONSORED RESEARCH OR DEVELOPMENT
[0002] This invention was made with government support by the Colorado Office of Economic Development and International Trade and under Grant Nos. 1847630, 2208777, and 2449209 by the National Science Foundation. The government has certain rights to this invention.BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTIONField of the Invention (Technical Field):
[0003] The present invention relates to the field of materials joining through metallurgical or chemical means (“metallurgical joining”).Background:
[0004] Metallurgical joining may be accomplished through one of several processes including but not limited to, fusion welding, in which the material workpieces are appreciably melted; brazing, in which only a filler material is melted at temperatures exceeding 450 degrees Celsius; soldering, in which only a filler material is melted at temperatures not exceeding 450 degrees Celsius; and diffusion bonding, in which no material is melted and joining is effectuated through the transport of atoms in the solid state. Among these processes, brazing and soldering require the use of a filler material,fusion welding may employ a filler material which is incorporated into the molten material pool, and diffusion bonding may employ a filler material as a solid-state interlayer. The filler materials of this invention could be employed in any of these capacities in conjunction with the relevant joining process(es).
[0005] Across an array of industries, joining and repair of advanced metallic or ceramic components have been limited in filler material development. Some examples include assembly of stainless-steel fuel nozzle components for gas turbine engines, repair of cracked or damaged Ni-base superalloy blades for the same engines and joining of engineering ceramics to metallic materials in the construction of advanced heat flow pathways in applications such as concentrated solar power. Current filler materials include those fillers with a high noble metal content, which may have limitations in costeffectiveness and, in some cases, working temperature.
[0006] Another category of filler materials are those fillers that contain at least one of boron, silicon, or phosphorus in the role of melting-point-depressant, which frequently introduce undesirable boride, silicide, or phosphide phases to the region where the filler material is applied. These undesirable phases may shorten the lifetime of the repaired region in cases of repair, or they may result in high rates of sub-assembly rejection in cases of assembly. In many examples, the fillers containing at least one of boron, silicon, or phosphorus in the role of melting-point-depressant cannot be realistically employed to fill gaps exceeding approximately 100 microns (0.004 inches), because wider gaps promote more extensive introduction of undesirable phases, as the boron, silicon, or phosphorus atoms must diffuse over larger distances to maintain concentrations below the thermodynamic solubility limits.
[0007] Existing categories of filler materials may exhibit desirable properties such as oxidation resistance and good flow characteristics that partly drive their continued use, despite their undesirable characteristics including poor cost-effectiveness and / or undesirable phases.
[0008] What is needed is an MPEA filler that retains beneficial mechanical properties when applied as filler material, while still avoiding large concentrations of precious metals to promote cost effectiveness, while still having satisfactory oxidation resistance and flow characteristics for use in industrial applications. The requisite combination of properties is likely to be application-specific.BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0009] Embodiments of the present invention relate to a multi-principal element alloy (“MPEA”) filler material comprising: an entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase; the solid phase comprising a single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure comprising a crystal lattice; and the crystal lattice comprising a plurality of lattice sites; a random arrangement of atoms occupying the plurality of crystal lattice sites; and an oxidationresistant element.
[0010] In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises chromium. In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises iron. In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises cobalt. In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises nickel. In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises copper. In another embodiment, the oxidation-resistant element comprises aluminum. In another embodiment, the oxidation- resista nt element comprises titanium. In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises oxygen. In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises carbon.
[0011] In another embodiment, the single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure is substantially free of ordered, non-face-centered-cubic phases containing boron. In another embodiment, the single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure is substantially free of phosphorous. In another embodiment, the single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure is substantially free of secondary phases of silicon.
[0012] Embodiments of the present invention also relate to a multi-principal element alloy (“MPEA”) filler material comprising: an entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase; the solid phase comprising a single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure comprising a crystal lattice; and the crystal lattice comprising a plurality of lattice sites; arandom arrangement of atoms occupying the plurality of crystal lattice sites; and the entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase comprising a liquidus temperature of less than 1050 °C.
[0013] In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises chromium at an atomic percentage of 0.1% to 0.5%. In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises nickel at an atomic percentage of 0.1% to 19.5%. In another embodiment, the MPEA filler material further comprises copper at an atomic percentage of 0.1% to 28%.
[0014] In another embodiment, the single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure is substantially free of ordered, non-face-centered-cubic phases containing boron. In another embodiment, the single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure is substantially free of phosphorous. In another embodiment, the single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure is substantially free of secondary phases of silicon.
[0015] Further scope of applicability of the present invention will be set forth in part in the detailed description to follow, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, and in part will become apparent to those skilled in the art upon examination of the following, or may be learned by practice of the invention. The objects and advantages of the invention may be realized and attained by means of the instrumentalities and combinations particularly pointed out in the appended claims.BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS
[0016] The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated into and form a part of the specification, illustrate one or more embodiments of the present invention and, together with the description, serve to explain the principles of the invention. The drawings are only for the purpose of illustrating one or more embodiments of the invention and are not to be construed as limiting the invention. In the drawings:
[0017] Fig. 1A is an image showing an example of the MPEA filler material applied to a Ni-Co-Cr-Mo-AI alloy using furnace brazing as the joining process, according to an embodiment of the invention;
[0018] Fig. 1B is an image showing an example of the MPEA filler material applied to a vacuum melted, vacuum cast, precipitation hardenable nickel-based alloy substrate using furnace brazing as the joining process, according to an embodiment of the invention; and
[0019] Fig. 2 is a graph showing the change in mass of samples of an MPEA filler material, according to an embodiment of the invention;
[0020] Fig. 3 is a plot showing tensile stress experienced by joints formed by MPEA filler material applied to a stainless steel substrate vs. tensile stress experienced by joints formed by Ni-Cr-Si filler material applied to a stainless steel substrate, according to an embodiment of the invention;.
[0021] Figs. 4A, 4B, and 4C are diagrams showing an example of an MPEA filler material’s disordered face-centered cubic solid solution crystal structure before mixing with a substrate, after mixing with a nickel-based substrate, and after mixing with an iron-based substrate, respectively, according to an embodiment of the invention;
[0022] Fig. 5 is a diagram showing an example of a face-centered cubic solid solution crystal structure from a non-MPEA filler material, according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0023] Fig. 6 is a diagram showing an example of an ordered, non-face-centered-cubic crystal structure from a non-MPEA filler material containing chromium and boron, according to an embodiment of the present invention.DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0024] Embodiments of the present invention relate to a multi-principal element alloy (“MPEA”) filler material comprising: an entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase; the solid phase comprising a single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure comprising a crystal lattice; and the crystal lattice comprising a plurality of lattice sites; and a randomarrangement of atoms occupying the plurality of crystal lattice sites. The entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase may comprise an oxidation- resista nt element or comprise a liquidus temperature below about 1050 °C.
[0025] Embodiments of the present invention relate to a multi-principal element alloy (“MPEA”) filler material comprising: at least one or more of the following: aluminum, titanium, chromium, manganese, iron, cobalt, nickel and copper. The MPEA material may further comprise silicon, boron, and / or other elements. The MPEA material filler material may comprise an oxidation-resistant element.
[0026] Embodiments of the present invention relate to a method of metallurgical joining, the method comprising: contacting a substrate with an MPEA filler material. The embodiments may comprise a microstructure substantially free of secondary phases of boron; and forming a continuous material piece comprising the substrate and the MPEA filler material.
[0027] The method may further comprise contacting the MPEA filler material with a gap in the substrate. The method may further comprise contacting the MPEA filler material with a crack in the substrate. The method may further comprise contacting the MPEA filler material with a cavity in the substrate. The method may further comprise joining a first substrate with a second substrate.
[0028] The first substrate may comprise the same material as the second substrate. The first substrate may comprise a different material than the second substrate. The substrate may comprise a partially discontinuous structure. The substrate may comprise a continuous structure. The substrate may comprise a powder. The substrate may comprise a liquid.
[0029] The MPEA filler material may comprise a powder. The MPEA filler material may comprise a foil or other thin surface. The MPEA filler material may comprise a wire. The MPEA filler material may comprise a ring. The MPEA filler material may comprise a high-density structure of powder particles. The MPEA filler material may comprise a liquid.
[0030] The method may further comprise contacting the MPEA filler material with a heat source. The method may further comprise mixing the MPEA filler material with thesubstrate to form a third material. Mixing the MPEA filler material with the substrate may change the elemental composition of the MPEA filler material relative to the elemental composition of the MPEA material prior to mixing. Mixing the MPEA filler material with the substrate may change the elemental composition of the substrate relative to the elemental composition of the substrate prior to mixing. Mixing the MPEA filler material with the substrate may increase the oxidation resistance of the MPEA filler material relative to the MPEA filler material prior to mixing.
[0031] The method may further comprise pre-processing the MPEA filler material prior to contacting the MPEA filler material with the substrate. The pre-processing may comprise powder annealing. The pre-processing may comprise mixing the MPEA filler material with a binder (e.g., a polymer based binder) to form a paste. The pre-processing may comprise pressing of the past into a flexible structure. The pre-processing may comprise sintering the MPEA filler material.
[0032] The term “substantially free” as used herein means a reasonable amount of deviation of the modified term such that the end result is not changed. These terms of degree should be construed as including a deviation of ± 5% of the modified term if this deviation would not negate the meaning of the term it modifies, e.g., within ± 5% of zero.
[0033] The term “oxidation-resistant element” as used herein means any element or combination of elements capable of increasing the ability of a material to withstand degradation or damage caused by the reaction of the material with oxygen relative to that of a material that does not comprise the element or combination of elements.
[0034] The term “strengthening phase” as used herein means a microstructure that increases the resistance of a material to deformation, dislocation, and / or distortion relative to a material that does not comprise the microstructure.
[0035] The term “working temperature” as used herein means a temperature at which the MPEA filler material can be used for a specific application while resisting deleterious effects including but not limited to, degradation, oxidation, corrosion, deformation, or a combination thereof.
[0036] The term “joining process” as used herein means any method which may combine and / or mix two materials through metallurgical or chemical means. The two materials may be discontinuous or partially continuous with each other. A joining process may be applied to fill a gap, cavity, crack, or other local discontinuity in an otherwise continuous material piece, or to restore dimensional integrity at material edges.
[0037] The term “filler material” as used herein means a material that, when contacted with a gap, void, or cavity in a substrate, or when contacted with a joining surface between substrates, causes the coalescence of the materials to form a continuous whole, in which the previously empty volume is partly or fully occupied by material.
[0038] The term “MPEA filler material” as used herein means a filler material that has substantially different atomic percentages of constituent elements from any substrate with which it is contacted, that possesses a disordered solid solution crystal structure with random atomic arrangement as its majority phase, and for which these characteristics are retained after it is contacted with a substrate in a joining process.
[0039] Turning now to the figures, Fig. 1A shows an optical micrograph of an example of the MPEA filler material applied to a Ni-Co-Cr-Mo-AI alloy substrate using furnace brazing as the joining process. No intermetallic phases are visible in the region where the MPEA filler material was applied, although some minor segregation is faintly visible along the centerline of the braze.
[0040] Fig. 1 B shows an optical micrograph of an example of the MPEA filler material applied to a vacuum melted, vacuum cast, precipitation hardenable nickel-based alloy substrate using furnace brazing as the joining process. No intermetallic phases are visible in the region where the MPEA filler material was applied, although some minor segregation is faintly visible along the centerline of the braze. Carbide phases present in the substrate material are visible throughout the microstructure. Carbide particles may be incorporated into the MPEA filler material region, which may serve to strengthen the MPEA filler material region.
[0041] Fig. 2 shows a plot of the change in mass of samples of an example of the MPEA filler material when exposed to furnace air at a temperature of 650°C for approximately 600 hours. The mass gain resulting from reaction between the MPEA fillermaterial and oxygen in the air is limited to less than about 3 mg per square centimeter of the MPEA filler material’s surface area after 600 hours exposure to air at 650°C. No oxide spallation occurred, so the mass change of the MPEA filler material is not convoluted by spallation and it is representative of the MPEA filler material’s parabolic oxidation rate.
[0042] Fig. 3 shows a plot of tensile stress experienced by joints formed by MPEA filler material applied to a stainless steel substrate, alongside tensile stress experienced by joints formed by a Ni-Cr-Si filler material applied to a stainless steel substrate. The tensile stress is plotted as a function of the displacement ( / .e., deformation) experienced by the joints prior to failure. The gap between the overlapping surfaces of a single lap test specimen filled by the MPEA filler material or the Ni-Cr-Si filler material is controlled to be either 50 microns or 100 microns. On average, when the gap is controlled to 50 pm, the peak tensile stress experienced by joints formed by the MPEA filler material is about 82% higher than the tensile stress experienced by joints formed by the Ni-Cr-Si filler. On average, when the gap was controlled to 100 pm, the peak tensile stress experienced by joints formed by the MPEA filler material is about 86% higher than the tensile stress experienced by joints formed by the Ni-Cr-Si filler. On average, when the gap is controlled to 50 pm, joints formed by the MPEA filler material withstand greater than about four times as much deformation than by joints formed by the Ni-Cr-Si filler. On average, when the gap is controlled to 100 pm, joints formed by the MPEA filler material withstand greater than about six times as much deformation than by joints formed by the Ni-Cr-Si filler.
[0043] Figs. 4A, 4B, and 4C show an example of an MPEA filler material’s disordered face-centered cubic solid solution crystal structure before mixing with a substrate, after mixing with a nickel-based substrate, and after mixing with an iron-based substrate, respectively. Before mixing with a substrate, the MPEA filler comprises a disordered, facecentered cubic solid solution crystal structure as its sole or predominant phase. The disordered face-centered cubic solid solution has a random arrangement of atoms at its crystal lattice sites. After mixing with a nickel-based substrate or an iron-based substrate, the MPEA filler material demonstrates stability of the disordered, face-centered cubic solid solution crystal structure even if the overall atomic percentages of the constituent elements change significantly. Such change of the overall atomic percentages of the elements of the MPEA filler material may occur as the result of contacting the filler material with one or more substrates. For example, the atomic percentage of nickel may substantially increaseif the MPEA filler material is contacted with a nickel-based alloy substrate, or the atomic percentage of iron may substantially increase if the MPEA filler material is contacted with an iron-based alloy substrate. In these examples, while the atom occupying a lattice site may change, the overall crystallographic structure remains constant.
[0044] Fig. 5 shows an example of a face-centered cubic solid solution crystal structure from a non-MPEA filler material. The crystal structure of the non-MPEA filler material has less variety in the atoms occupying its lattice sites than a typical example of the MPEA filler material. In contrast, the disordered, face-centered cubic solid solution crystal structure of an MPEA filler may comprise a greater amount of variety in the atoms occupying its lattice sites than a non-MPEA filler material. The variety in the atoms occupying the lattice sites is one feature that may contribute to strengthening the MPEA filler material by causing it to have a high strain-hardening rate. In examples where the overall atomic percentages of the constituent elements change significantly through contacting the MPEA filler material with one or more substrates, the variety in the atoms occupying the lattice sites of the MPEA filler material may comprise a greater amount of variety in the atoms occupying its lattice sites than a non-MPEA filler material.
[0045] Fig. 6 shows an example of an ordered, non-face-centered-cubic crystal structure from a non-MPEA filler material containing chromium and boron. In contrast, the MPEA filler material is substantially free of ordered, non-face-centered-cubic phases containing boron, which are prevalent in many other classes of filler material. The MPEA filler is substantially free of phases containing boron both before and after mixing with a substrate.
[0046] The MPEA filler may comprise an entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase. The MPEA filler may comprise an oxidation-resistant element. The oxidationresistant element may comprise, but is not limited to, chromium, aluminum, hafnium, silicon, or a combination thereof.
[0047] The MPEA may comprise chromium. The MPEA filler material may comprise greater than zero atomic percent chromium, from greater than zero atomic percent to about 35 atomic percent chromium, about 0.1 atomic percent to about 20 atomic percent chromium, about 0.2 atomic percent to about 15 atomic percent chromium, about 0.25 atomic percent to about 13 atomic percent chromium, about 0.5 atomic percent to about 12atomic percent chromium, about 0.75 atomic percent to about 11 atomic percent chromium, about 1 atomic percent to about 10 atomic percent chromium, about 2 atomic percent to about 9 atomic percent chromium, about 3 atomic percent to about 8 atomic percent chromium, or about 4 atomic percent to about 7 atomic percent chromium.
[0048] The atomic percent of the oxidation- resista nt element in the MPEA filler material may be selected based on the desired oxidation resistance of the MPEA filler material at the working temperature of the filler material. For example, the atomic percentage of the oxidation-resistant element may be selected based on the desired oxidation resistance for the MPEA filler material at 300°C, about 300°C to about 1000°C, about 350°C to about 950°C, about 400°C to about 900°C, about 450°C to about 850°C, about 500°C to about 800°C, about 550°C to about 850°C, about 600°C to about 800°C, or about 1000°C. The desired oxidation resistance of the MPEA filler material at a working temperature may be characterized by a change in the MPEA filler material mass over time, the dimensional change of the MPEA filler material overtime, characterization of the MPEA filler material surface via microscopy or diffraction-based techniques, or a combination thereof.
[0049] The MPEA filler material may comprise manganese. The MPEA filler material may comprise greater than about 0 atomic percent manganese, about 10 atomic percent to about 65 atomic percent manganese, about 15 atomic percent to about 60 atomic percent manganese, about 20 atomic percent to about 55 atomic percent manganese, about 25 atomic percent to about 50 atomic percent manganese, about 30 atomic percent to about 45 atomic percent manganese, or about 35 atomic percent to about 40 atomic percent manganese.
[0050] The MPEA filler material may comprise iron. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent iron, about 0 atomic percent to about 10 atomic percent iron, about 1 atomic percent to about 9 atomic percent iron, about 2 atomic percent to about 8 atomic percent iron, about 2.5 atomic percent to about 7 atomic percent iron, or about 3 atomic percent to about 6 atomic percent iron.
[0051] The MPEA filler material may comprise cobalt. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent cobalt, about 0 atomic percent to about 25 atomic percent cobalt, or about 1 atomic percent to about 20 atomic percent cobalt.
[0052] The MPEA filler material may comprise nickel. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent nickel, about 5 atomic percent to about 55 atomic percent nickel, about 7 atomic percent to about 50 atomic percent nickel, about 10 atomic percent to about 45 atomic percent nickel, about 12 atomic percent to about 45 atomic percent nickel, or about 15 atomic percent to about 40 atomic percent nickel.
[0053] The MPEA filler material may comprise copper. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent copper, about 0 atomic percent to about 35 atomic percent copper, about 5 atomic percent to about 33 atomic percent copper, about 10 atomic percent to about 30 atomic percent copper, or about 15 atomic percent to about 25 atomic percent copper.
[0054] The atomic percent of chromium, manganese, iron, cobalt, nickel, and / or copper in the MPEA filler material may be selected based on a number of factors including but not limited to, the desired melting temperature of the MPEA filler material. For example, the atomic percent of copper in the MPEA filler material may be selected based on the desired melting temperature ( / .e., at least one of the liquidus or solidus temperature) of the MPEA filler material, since increasing the atomic percentage of copper in the MPEA filler material generally decreases the melting temperature of the MPEA filler material and vice versa. The other constituent elements may also affect the melting temperature of the MPEA filler material, and as such, the atomic percent of copper in the MPEA filler material may be selected based on the atomic percent of the other constituents in the MPEA filler material.
[0055] The MPEA filler material may comprise aluminum. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent aluminum, about 0 atomic percent to about 10 atomic percent aluminum, about 0.5 atomic percent to about 8 atomic percent aluminum, about 0.5 atomic percent to about 6 atomic percent aluminum, about 0.75 atomic percent to about 5 atomic percent aluminum, or about 1 atomic percent to about 3 atomic percent aluminum.
[0056] Aluminum may promote the formation of one or more strengthening phases in the MPEA filler material. The atomic percent of aluminum may be selected based on the desired volume fraction of the one or more strengthening phases in the MPEA filler material before it is applied in a joining process, and / or the desired volume fraction of the one or more strengthening phases in the MPEA filler material after it is applied in a joining process.
[0057] The MPEA filler material may comprise silicon. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent silicon, about 0 atomic percent to about 10 atomic percent silicon, about 1 atomic percent to about 9 atomic percent silicon, about 2 atomic percent to about 8 atomic percent silicon, about 3 atomic percent to about 7 atomic percent silicon, about 4 atomic percent to about 6 atomic percent silicon, or about 10 atomic percent silicon.
[0058] The MPEA filler material may comprise hafnium. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent hafnium, about 0 atomic percent to about 10 atomic percent hafnium, about 1 atomic percent to about 9 atomic percent hafnium, about 2 atomic percent to about 8 atomic percent hafnium, about 3 atomic percent to about 7 atomic percent hafnium, about 4 atomic percent to about 6 atomic percent hafnium.
[0059] The MPEA filler material may comprise titanium. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent titanium, about 0 atomic percent to about 10 atomic percent titanium, about 1 atomic percent to about 8 atomic percent titanium, or about 1.5 atomic percent to about 5 atomic percent titanium.
[0060] Titanium may promote the formation of one or more strengthening phases in the MPEA filler material. The atomic percent of titanium may be selected based on the desired volume fraction of the one or more strengthening phases in the MPEA filler material before it is applied in a joining process, and / or the desired volume fraction of the one or more strengthening phases in the MPEA filler material after it is applied in a joining process.
[0061] The MPEA filler material may further comprise one or more additional elements. Examples of additional elements that may be included in the MPEA filler material include but are not limited to, carbon, molybdenum, niobium, tantalum, tungsten, or a combination thereof. Each of the additional elements may affect the melting temperature of the MPEA filler material and / or promote the formation of microstructurally stabilizing carbide phases in the MPEA filler material before or after the MPEA filler material is applied in a joining process.
[0062] The MPEA filler material may further comprise carbon. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent carbon, about 0 atomic percent to about 5 atomic percent carbon, or about 1 atomic percent to about 3 atomic percent carbon.
[0063] The MPEA filler material may further comprise molybdenum. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent molybdenum, about 0 atomic percent to about 35 atomic percent molybdenum, about 1 atomic percent to about 33 atomic percent molybdenum, about 2 atomic percent to about 31 atomic percent molybdenum, about 3 atomic percent to about 29 atomic percent molybdenum, about 4 atomic percent to about 27 atomic percent molybdenum, about 5 atomic percent to about 25 atomic percent molybdenum, about 6 atomic percent to about 23 atomic percent molybdenum, about 7 atomic percent to about 21 atomic percent molybdenum, about 8 atomic percent to about 19 atomic percent molybdenum, about 9 atomic percent to about 17 atomic percent molybdenum, about 10 atomic percent to about 15 atomic percent molybdenum, or about 11 atomic percent to about 13 atomic percent molybdenum.
[0064] The MPEA filler material may further comprise tantalum. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent tantalum, about 0 atomic percent to about 35 atomic percent tantalum, about 1 atomic percent to about 33 atomic percent tantalum, about 2 atomic percent to about 31 atomic percent tantalum, about 3 atomic percent to about 29 atomic percent tantalum, about 4 atomic percent to about 27 atomic percent tantalum, about 5 atomic percent to about 25 atomic percent tantalum, about 6 atomic percent to about 23 atomic percent tantalum, about 7 atomic percent to about 21 atomic percent tantalum, about 8 atomic percent to about 19 atomic percent tantalum, about 9 atomic percent to about 17 atomic percent tantalum, about 10 atomicpercent to about 15 atomic percent tantalum, or about 11 atomic percent to about 13 atomic percent tantalum.
[0065] The MPEA filler material may further comprise tungsten. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent tungsten, about 0 atomic percent to about 10 atomic percent tungsten, about 1 atomic percent to about 9 atomic percent tungsten, about 2 atomic percent to about 8 atomic percent tungsten, about 3 atomic percent to about 7 atomic percent tungsten, or about 4 atomic percent to about 6 atomic percent tungsten.
[0066] The MPEA filler material may further comprise rhenium. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent rhenium, about 0 atomic percent to about 5 atomic percent rhenium, or about 1 atomic percent to about 3 atomic percent rhenium.
[0067] The MPEA filler material may further comprise zirconium. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent zirconium, about 0 atomic percent to about 15 atomic percent zirconium, about 1 atomic percent to about 14 atomic percent zirconium, about 2 atomic percent to about 13 atomic percent zirconium, about 3 atomic percent to about 12 atomic percent zirconium, about 4 atomic percent to about 11 atomic percent zirconium, about 5 atomic percent to about 10 atomic percent zirconium, about 6 atomic percent to about 9 atomic percent zirconium, or about 7 atomic percent to about 8 atomic percent zirconium.
[0068] The MPEA filler material may further comprise niobium. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent niobium, about 0 atomic percent to about 10 atomic percent niobium, about 1 atomic percent to about 9 atomic percent niobium, about 2 atomic percent to about 8 atomic percent niobium, about 3 atomic percent to about 7 atomic percent niobium, or about 4 atomic percent to about 6 atomic percent niobium.
[0069] The MPEA filler material may further comprise yttrium oxide (Y2O3). The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent yttrium oxide, about 0 atomic percent to about 2 atomic percent yttrium oxide, about 0.25 atomic percentto about 1.75 atomic percent yttrium oxide, about 0.5 atomic percent to about 1.5 atomic percent yttrium oxide, about 0.75 atomic percent to about 1.25 atomic percent yttrium oxide, or about 2 atomic percent yttrium oxide.
[0070] An oxide and / or carbide may be present due to an element reacting with oxygen or carbon within the MPEA filler material, respectively. Oxides and / or carbides may prevent the MPEA filler material from exhibiting a single phase. The MPEA filler material may comprise oxides and / or carbides due to impurities present in the starting material, impurities introduced during manufacturing of the MPEA filler material, and / or due to impurities in the MPEA filler material being exposed to the environment. To limit the effect that the oxides and / or carbides may have on the MPEA filler material, the atomic percent of oxygen and / or carbon may be about 1 atomic percent or less. An exterior surface of the MPEA filler material may be removed (e.g., grinding) periodically to remove a surface oxide layer to keep the oxygen in the MPEA filler material below about 1 atomic percent.
[0071] The oxidation- resista nt element may comprise aluminum. The oxidationresistant element may comprise hafnium. The oxidation-resistant element may comprise chromium. The MPEA filler material may be substantially free of phosphorous.
[0072] The MPEA filler may comprise boron and the oxidation-resistant element comprising a microstructure substantially free of secondary phases of boron. Boron may lower the viscosity of the MPEA filler material in the liquid state and / or improve liquid flow. Boron may promote minor volume fractions of borides along grain boundaries. The MPEA filler material may comprise about greater than 0 atomic percent boron, about 0 atomic percent to about 1.0 atomic percent boron, about 0.1 atomic percent to about 0.9 atomic percent boron, about 0.2 atomic percent to about 0.8 atomic percent boron, about 0.3 atomic percent to about 0.7 atomic percent boron, about 0.4 atomic percent to about 0.6 atomic percent boron, or about 1.0 atomic percent boron.
[0073] The MPEA filler material may further comprise silicon or may not comprise silicon. The oxidation- resista nt element may comprise silicon. The MPEA filler material may be substantially free of secondary phases of silicon.
[0074] The cumulative atomic percent of boron and silicon in the MPEA filler material may be less than the amount that, when added to pure nickel, would depress the melting point of the nickel to a range that permits brazing to be used as the joining process. The microstructure of the MPEA filler material may be substantially free of significant secondary phases containing boron and / or silicon before the MPEA filler material is applied in a joining process and / or after the MPEA filler material is applied in a joining process.
[0075] The MPEA filler material may be substantially free of phosphorus, which may prevent the formation of phosphide phases in the material. Phosphorus may be present in the MPEA filler material as an impurity. The MPEA filler material is considered to comprise negligible amounts of phosphorus when the MPEA filler material comprises 0.5 atomic percent of phosphorus or less.
[0076] The MPEA filler material may comprise an impurity. The impurity may comprise, but is not limited to, phosphorous, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, sulfur, chlorine, zinc, gallium, germanium, gold, silver, palladium, indium, tin, platinum, lead, any other element, or a combination thereof. The impurity may be present in the MPEA filler material at about 0.5 atomic percent or less, such as about 0.4 atomic percent or less, about 0.3 atomic percent or less, about 0.2 atomic percent or less, about 0.15 atomic percent or less, about 0.1 atomic percent or less, or about 0.05 atomic percent or less. Collectively, the impurities may be present in the MPEA filler material at about 2 atomic percent or less, about 2 atomic percent or less, about 1.75 atomic percent or less, about 1.5 atomic percent or less, about 1.25 atomic percent or less, about 1 atomic percent or less, about 0.8 atomic percent or less, about 0.6 atomic percent or less, or about 0.5 atomic percent or less.
[0077] The MPEA filler material may comprise a powder. The powder may have a particle size distribution defined by the diameter of at least one of the 10th, 50th, or 90th percentile particle in size. At least one of the 10th, 50th, or 90th percentile particle diameter may be limited to a certain size. For example, at least one of the 10th, 50th, or 90th percentile particle diameter may be limited to about 750 microns or less, about 500 microns or less, about 400 microns or less, about 300 microns or less, about 200 microns or less, about 150 microns or less, about 100 microns or less, about 75 microns or less, or about 50 microns or less. The powder may have a particle size distribution characterized by the size of the sieve through which the largest particles in the distribution are able topass. For example, the powder may pass through a 25-mesh sieve, a 35-mesh sieve, a 45-mesh sieve, a 60-mesh sieve, an 80-mesh sieve, a 120-mesh sieve, a 140-mesh sieve, a 170-mesh sieve, a 200-mesh sieve, a 230-mesh sieve, a 270-mesh sieve, or a 325-mesh sieve. The MPEA filler material may be manufactured into powder form through at least one of several powder manufacturing processes including but not limited to, gas atomization, ultrasonic atomization, ball milling, grinding, or a combination thereof.
[0078] The MPEA filler material in powder form may undergo a pre-processing step prior to it being applied in a joining process. The pre-processing step may include but is not limited to, powder annealing, mixture with a polymer-based binder to create a paste, pressing of the paste into a flexible structure, sintering of the powder or paste to create a high-density structure of powder particles, or a combination thereof. The pre-processing step may be determined by the geometry of the assembly and / or repaired region within which the MPEA filler material is to be applied in a joining process.
[0079] The MPEA filler material in powder form may be mixed with the powder form of a substrate. For example, the MPEA filler material in powder form may be mixed with the powder form of a nickel-based superalloy substrate. As another example, the MPEA filler material in powder form may be mixed with the powder form of a cobalt-based substrate. As another example, the MPEA filler material in powder form may be mixed with the powder form of an iron-based substrate. The proportion of the MPEA filler material in the powder mixture may range from between about greater than 0 to about 100 percent, about 5 percent to about 95 percent, about 10 percent to about 90 percent, about 15 percent to about 85 percent, about 20 percent to about 80 percent, about 25 percent to about 75 percent, about 30 percent to about 70 percent, about 35 percent to about 65 percent, about 40 percent to about 60 percent, about 45 percent to about 55 percent.
[0080] The percentage of MPEA filler material in powder form in the powder mixture may be determined based on the joining parameters in the joining process in which the MPEA filler material is to be applied. The MPEA filler material in powder form may be mixed with the powder form of a substrate to fill a wider gap than would be possible if the MPEA filler material was not mixed with the powder form of the substrate. The MPEA filler material in powder form may be mixed with the powder form of a substrate to increase theconcentration of an oxidation-resistant element of the MPEA filler after it is applied in a joining process.
[0081] The MPEA filler material in powder form may be mixed with the powder form of a substrate to form a powder mixture. The powder mixture may undergo a preprocessing step prior to it being applied in a joining process. The pre-processing step may include, but is not limited to, powder annealing, mixture with a binder (e.g. a polymer-based binder) to create a paste, pressing of the paste into a flexible structure, sintering of the powder mixture or paste to create a high-density structure of powder particles, or a combination thereof. The pre-processing step may be determined by the geometry of the assembly and / or repaired region within which the MPEA filler material is to be applied in a joining process.
[0082] The MPEA filler material may comprise a foil or other thin material (also referred to herein as “foil”). The foil may have a thickness of about 400 microns or less, about 300 microns or less, about 250 microns or less, about 200 microns or less, about 150 microns or less, about 100 microns or less, about 75 microns or less, or about 50 microns or less, or about 25 microns or less. The MPEA filler material may be manufactured into foil form through at least one of several foil manufacturing processes, including but not limited to, melt-spinning, cold rolling, warm rolling, hot rolling, grinding, polishing, forging, spin casting, or a combination thereof.
[0083] The MPEA filler material may comprise a wire. The wire may have a diameter of about 0.020 inches, between about 0.020 inches to about 0.100 inches, about 0.025 inches to about 0.095 inches, about 0.030 inches to about 0.090 inches, about 0.035 inches to about 0.085 inches, about 0.040 inches to about 0.080 inches, about 0.045 inches to about 0.075 inches, about 0.050 inches to about 0.070 inches, about 0.055 inches to about 0.065 inches, or about 0.100 inches. The MPEA filler material may be manufactured into foil form through a wire manufacturing process including but not limited to, casting, rolling, extrusion, or a combination thereof.
[0084] The MPEA filler material in wire form may further comprise a ring shape. The ring shape may have a radius of about 0.1 inches, about 0.1 inches to about 6 inches, about 0.2 inches to about 5 inches, about 0.3 inches to about 4 inches, about 0.4 inches toabout 3 inches, about 0.5 inches to about 2 inches, about 0.6 inches to about 1 inch, about 0.7 inches to about 0.9 inches, or about 6 inches. The MPEA filler material in wire form into a ring may be applied in joining assemblies that include axially symmetric components.
[0085] The MPEA filler material in any form may be applied in a joining process, including but not limited to those described herein. The MPEA filler material may be applied in a brazing process. The MPEA filler material may be applied in a welding process. The MPEA filler material may be applied in a diffusion bonding process. The joining process may use one of many types of heat source. The heat sources may include but are not limited to, a laser, an electric arc, Joule heating through electrical resistance, electromagnetic induction, radiative or conductive heat transfer from a heating element, an oxy-fuel torch, or a combination thereof. The temperature experienced by the MPEA filler material and the substrate may be controlled to a fixed value. The MPEA filler material may be melted in the presence of an inert gas including, but not limited to, argon, helium, nitrogen, carbon dioxide, or a combination thereof. The MPEA filler material may be melted in an inert environment ( / .e., a vacuum). The quality of the vacuum may be determined by the absolute pressure of the vessel in which the vacuum is created. The pressure of the vessel in which the vacuum is created may be about 10'2torr, about 10'3torr, about 10'4torr, about 10'5torr, or about 10'6torr, or another pressure determined to be sufficient to limit the reaction of the MPEA filler material and the one or more substrates with naturally occurring atmospheric gases. External pressure different from pressure exerted by gaseous species may be applied using a hydraulic ram and / or deadweight.
[0086] The MPEA filler material may be melted in a partial pressure inert environment. The inert environment may comprise, but is not limited to, argon, helium, nitrogen, carbon dioxide, and / or another inert gas. The partial pressure inert environment may increase the chemical stability of the MPEA filler by limiting the degree of evaporation of volatile constituents relative to a vacuum environment. The pressure of the vessel in which the MPEA filler material is melted may be about 0.6 torr, between about 0.6 torr to about 2.0 torr, about 0.8 torr to about 1.8 torr, about 1.0 torr to about 1.6 torr, about 1.2 torr to about 1.4 torr, or about 2.0 torr.
[0087] The MPEA filler material may be used in an additive manufacturing process. The MPEA filler material in powder form may be mixed with the powder form of one ormore base materials prior to application in an additive manufacturing process. A heat source capable of complex travel patterns to melt the MPEA filler material may be applied to the MPEA filler material. The MPEA filler material may bind particles of a partially melted base material. The application of the MPEA filler material to a partially melted base material may reduce the likelihood of solidification cracking in the base material in the additive manufacturing process. A part manufactured using an additive manufacturing process in conjunction with the MPEA filler material may require subsequent processing for enhanced densification. A part manufactured using an additive manufacturing process in conjunction with the MPEA filler material may undergo hot isostatic pressing at a particular temperature and / or pressure.
[0088] Mixing between the MPEA filler material and the substrate may occur. This mixing may occur in either the liquid state (dilution) and / or in the solid state (diffusion). Mixing between the MPEA filler material and the substrate may cause the concentration of the elements in the MPEA filler material after it is applied in a joining process to differ substantially from the concentration of the elements in the MPEA filler material before it is applied in a joining process. The elemental composition of the MPEA filler material may change following mixing relative to the elemental composition of the MPEA filler material prior to mixing. The specified atomic percentages of the MPEA filler material are those present in the MPEA filler material before mixing between the MPEA filler material and substrate.
[0089] Flow of the MPEA filler material in the liquid state may occur between and / or along surfaces of the substrate. The extent of flow along and / or between surfaces of the substrate may depend on a number of factors, including but not limited to, the surface chemistry of the substrate; the gap width between substrate surfaces; the manner in which the filler and substrate are exposed to the heat sources; the atomic percent of the elements in the MPEA filler material; or a combination thereof. Mixing between the MPEA filler material and the substrate may influence the extent of flow of the MPEA filler material in the liquid state.
[0090] The atomic percent of the elements in the MPEA filler material may be selected based on a number of factors including, but not limited to, the desired flow distance of the MPEA in the liquid state along and / or between surfaces of the substrate. For example, the atomic percent of silicon in the MPEA filler material may be selectedbased on the desired flow distance of the MPEA filler material, since increasing the atomic percentage of silicon in the MPEA filler material may increase the extent of flow of the MPEA filler material and vice versa.
[0091] Mixing between the MPEA filler material and the substrate may increase the oxidation resistance of the MPEA filler material after it is applied in a joining process relative to the oxidation resistance of the MPEA filler material before it is applied in a joining process. This improvement in oxidation resistance may be due to an increase in the concentration of an oxidation-resistant element in the MPEA filler material following mixing between the MPEA filler material and the substrate. The substrate may comprise a greater concentration of an oxidation-resistant element relative to the MPEA filler material before mixing between the MPEA filler material and the substrate. Mixing between the MPEA filler material and the substrate may cause a decrease in the concentration of an oxidation-resistant element in the substrate material relative to the concentration of the oxidation-resistant element in the substrate prior to mixing. Mixing between the MPEA filler material and the substrate may cause an increase in the concentration of an oxidationresistant element in the MPEA filler material relative to the concentration of the oxidationresistant element in the MPEA filler material prior to mixing.
[0092] The oxidation resistance of the MPEA filler before and / or after mixing with the substrate may be measured by the change in mass of samples exposed to high temperature air in either a single, long duration and / or a series of shorter durations with cooling to room temperature in between. The mass of samples may increase due to reaction with the oxygen in air, and / or the mass may decrease due to spallation ( / .e., shedding) of the oxide layer. The oxidation resistance of the MPEA filler before and / or after mixing with the substrate may be measured by examining cross sections of the surface of samples exposed to high temperature air using a microscope.
[0093] The MPEA filler material may exhibit an entropy of about 10 J / mol*K, about 10 J / mol*K to about 20 J / mol*K, about 11 J / mol*K to about 19 J / mol*K, about 12 J / mol*K to about 18 J / mol*K , about 13 J / mol*K to about 17 J / mol*K, about 14 J / mol*K to about 16 J / mol*K, or about 20 J / mol*K. The entropy of the MPEA filler material may stabilize substantially a disordered solid solution phase in the MPEA filler material as the majorconstituent phase of the material, which may result in an increase in the ductility and toughness of the MPEA filler material relative to a filler material with a lower entropy.
[0094] The MPEA filler material and / or entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase may exhibit a melting temperature that is about 850°C or greater, about 850°C to about 1400°C, about 900°C to about 1400°C, about 950°C to about 1350°C, about 1000°C to about 1300 °C, about 1050°C to about 1250°C, about 1100°C to about 1200°C, or about 1400 °C. The MPEA filler material and / or entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase may exhibit a liquidus temperature that is about 850°C or greater, about 850°C to about 1400°C, about 900°C to about 1400°C, about 950°C to about 1350°C, about 1000°C to about 1300 °C, about 1050°C to about 1250°C, about 1100°C to about 1200°C, or about 1400 °C. The melting temperature and / or liquidus temperature of the MPEA filler material and / or entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase may be selected to be less than the melting temperature of the substrate, and / or it may be selected to approximately match the melting temperature of the substrate. The MPEA filler material and / or entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase may comprise a liquidus temperature between 100 °C -200 °C lower than the solidus temperature of the substrate. The melting temperature of the MPEA filler material may be adjusted by adjusting the atomic percentages of elements in the MPEA filler material. Because the MPEA filler material demonstrates stability of the disordered, face-centered cubic solid solution crystal structure even if the overall atomic percentages of the constituent elements change significantly, it may be possible to control the melting temperature of the MPEA filler material while the overall crystallographic structure remains constant.
[0095] The MPEA filler material may comprise a disordered, face-centered cubic solid solution crystal structure as its sole or predominant phase. The disordered, facecentered cubic solid solution crystal structure may comprise a random arrangement of atoms occupying a plurality of crystal lattice sites. Before mixing with a substrate, the MPEA filler material may comprise a lattice parameter (e.g., the length of an edge of a single crystallographic unit cell) of about 3.50 angstroms, between about 3.5 angstroms to about 3.7 angstroms, about 3.25 angstroms to about 3.68 angstroms, about 3.35 angstroms to about 3.65 angstroms, about 3.45 angstroms to about 3.55 angstroms, or about 3.7 angstroms.
[0096] The MPEA filler material may maintain a disordered, face-centered cubic solid solution crystal structure as its sole or predominant phase after mixing with a substrate. The atomic percentages of the MPEA filler material may change after contacting the MPEA filler material with a substrate. The MPEA filler material may maintain a disordered, facecentered cubic solid solution crystal structure as its sole or predominant phase after alteration of the atomic percentages of the MPEA filler material. For example, the atomic percentage of nickel may substantially increase if the MPEA filler material is contacted with a nickel-based alloy substrate, or the atomic percentage of iron may substantially increase if the MPEA filler material is contacted with an iron-based alloy substrate. In these examples, while the atom occupying a lattice site may change, the overall crystallographic structure of the MPEA filler material remains constant.
[0097] The MPEA filler material may comprise a greater diversity of atoms occupying crystal lattice sites in comparison to a non-MPEA filler material. The greater diversity of atoms occupying crystal lattice sites may strengthen the MPEA filler material in comparison to a non-MPEA filler material. The MPEA filler material may comprise a higher strainhardening rate than a non-MPEA filler material. The MPEA filler material may maintain a greater diversity of atoms occupying crystal lattice sites in comparison to a non-MPEA filler material after contacting the MPEA filler material with a substrate.
[0098] The MPEA filler material may comprise a crystal lattice structure that is substantially free of ordered, non-face-centered-cubic phases containing boron. The MPEA filler material may maintain a crystal lattice structure that is substantially free of ordered, non-face-centered-cubic phases containing boron after contacting the MPEA filler material with a substrate.
[0099] Embodiments of the present invention provide a technology-based solution that overcomes existing problems with the current state of the art in a technical way to satisfy an existing problem for consumers of filler materials in manufacturing-based industries. Embodiments of the present invention achieve important benefits over the current state of the art, such as increased toughness of the joined or repaired region, increased flexibility in the gap widths able to be filled, increased cost-effectiveness, and an MPEA filler that is resistant to oxidation. Some of the unconventional features of embodiments of the present invention include an MPEA filler comprising an oxidation-resistant element that is substantially free of secondary phases of boron, secondary phases of silicon, and / or phosphorus.Industrial Applicability:
[0100] The invention is further illustrated by the following non-limiting examples.Example 1
[0101] A Mn-Co-Ni-Cu-Fe-Cr MPEA filler material was applied to several nickel-based alloy substrates using furnace brazing as a joining process. For some of the nickel-based alloy substrates, mechanical testing was performed in the single lap joint configuration. Greater peak loads were required to break the joints using the example Cr-Mn-Fe-Co-Ni-Cu MPEA filler material than joints using a Ni-Cr-Si filler material containing secondary phases of silicon. The nickel-based alloy substrates withstood significantly more deformation during mechanical testing when using the example Cr-Mn-Fe-Co-Ni-Cu MPEA filler material compared to when using the Ni-Cr-Si filler material.Example 2
[0102] A Mn-Cu-Ni-Cr MPEA filler material was applied to a stainless-steel substrate using furnace brazing as a joining process. Using this filler material allowed the joining process to be performed synchronously with standard practice annealing treatments for the stainless-steel substrates. Mechanical testing in the single lap joint configuration demonstrated that the structure could fail in the base material (i.e., not in the joint) if the overlap distance between the members was three times the member thickness or greater.Example 3
[0103] A Ni-Mn-Cu-Cr-Fe-Ti-AI-Co MPEA filler material was applied to several nickel-based alloy substrates using furnace brazing as a joining process. In preliminary mechanical testing performed in the single lap joint configuration, greater peak loads were required to break the joints using the example Ni-Mn-Cu-Cr-Fe-Ti-AI-Co MPEA filler material than joints using a Ni-Cr-Si filler material containing secondary phases of silicon.Example 4
[0104] An MPEA filler material was provided as foil with a thickness of less than 400 microns and applied to a Ni-Co-Cr-Mo-AI substrate alloy using furnace brazing as a joining process. An optical micrograph was taken and no intermetallic phases were observed in the region where the MPEA filler material was applied, although some minor segregation was faintly observable along the centerline of the braze. Ni-Co-Cr-Mo-AI substrate alloys are used in the manufacture of honeycomb labyrinth seals for gas turbine engines.Example 5
[0105] An MPEA filler material was provided as foil with a thickness of less than 400 microns and applied to a nickel-based substrate alloy using furnace brazing as a joining process. An optical micrograph was taken and no intermetallic phases were observed in the region where the MPEA filler material was applied, although some minor segregation was faintly observable along the centerline of the braze. Carbide phases that are present in the substrate material were observable throughout the microstructure. Some amount of these carbide particles may be incorporated into the MPEA filler material region, which may serve to strengthen the MPEA filler material region. Nickel-based alloys are used in the repair or dimensional restoration of turbine blades for gas turbine engines.Example 6
[0106] An MPEA filler material was exposed to furnace air at a temperature of 650°C for approximately 600 hours. The mass gain resulting from reaction between the MPEA filler material and oxygen in the air was limited to less than about 3 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface area after 600 hours exposure to air at 650°C. No significant oxide spallation occurred, so the mass change of the MPEA filler material was not convoluted by spallation and it was representative of the material’s parabolic oxidation rate. The MPEA filler material was in bulk form and it was not mixed with any substrate material. Mixing of the MPEA filler material with one or more substrate materials may be performed intentionally prior to the MPEA filler material being applied in a joining process, or mixing of the MPEA filler material with one or more substrate materials may occur as a natural result of the joining process itself. In either case, the mixing between the MPEAfiller material and one or more substrate materials may influence the oxidation rate of the MPEA filler material. The mixing of the MPEA filler material with one or more substrate materials may lower the oxidation rate, such that the change in mass due to oxidation would be expected to be lower than about 3 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface area after 600 hours exposure to air at 650°C.
[0107] It should not be construed that the MPEA filler material will always gain less than about 3 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface area after 600 hours exposure to air at 650°C. For example, after 600 hours exposure to air at 650°C, the MPEA filler material may gain less than about 4 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface, less than about 5 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface, less than about 6 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface, less than about 8 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface, less than about 10 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface, less than about 12.5 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface or less than about 15 mg per square centimeter of the material’s surface.Example 7
[0108] A Ni-Mn-Cu-Cr-Fe-Ti-AI-Co MPEA filler material was applied to stainless steel substrates using furnace brazing as a joining process. The gap between the substrate surfaces was controlled to be either 50 microns or 100 microns. In mechanical testing performed in the single-lap joint configuration, up to approximately two (2) times greater peak loads were required to break the joints using the example Ni-Mn-Cu-Cr-Fe-Ti-AI-Co MPEA filler material than joints using a Ni-Cr-Si filler material containing secondary phases of silicon. The joints using the example Ni-Mn-Cu-Cr-Fe-Ti-AI-Co MPEA filler material withstood up to approximately five (5) times more displacement ( / .e., deformation) than joints using a Ni-Cr-Si filler material containing secondary phases of silicon.
[0109] The preceding examples can be repeated with similar success by substituting the generically or specifically described reactants and / or operating conditions of this invention for those used in the preceding examples.
[0110] Note that in the specification and claims, “about” or “approximately” means within twenty percent (20%) of the numerical amount cited. The terms, “a”, “an”, “the”, and “said” mean “one or more” unless context explicitly dictates otherwise.
[0111] Although the invention has been described in detail with particular reference to these embodiments, other embodiments can achieve the same results. Variations and modifications of the present invention will be obvious to those skilled in the art and it is intended to cover in the appended claims all such modifications and equivalents. The entire disclosures of all references, applications, patents, and publications cited above are hereby incorporated by reference.
Claims
CLAIMSWhat is claimed is:
1. A multi-principal element alloy (“MPEA”) filler material comprising:an entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase;the solid phase comprising a single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure comprising a crystal lattice; andthe crystal lattice comprising a plurality of lattice sites;a random arrangement of atoms occupying the plurality of crystal lattice sites; and an oxidation- resista nt element.
2. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 further comprising chromium.
3. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 further comprising iron.
4. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 further comprising cobalt.
5. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 further comprising nickel.
6. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 further comprising copper.
7. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 wherein the oxidation-resistant element comprises aluminum.
8. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 wherein the oxidation-resistant element comprises titanium.
9. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 further comprising oxygen.
10. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 further comprising carbon.
11. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 wherein the single phase disordered facecentered cubic structure is substantially free of ordered, non-face-centered-cubic phases containing boron.
12. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 wherein the single phase disordered facecentered cubic structure is substantially free of phosphorous.
13. The MPEA filler material of claim 1 wherein the single phase disordered facecentered cubic structure is substantially free of secondary phases of silicon.
14. A multi-principal element alloy (“MPEA”) filler material comprising:an entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase;the solid phase comprising a single phase disordered face-centered cubic structure comprising a crystal lattice; andthe crystal lattice comprising a plurality of lattice sites;a random arrangement of atoms occupying the plurality of crystal lattice sites; and the entropically-stabilized disordered solid phase comprising a liquidus temperature of less than 1050 °C.
15. The MPEA filler material of claim 14 further comprising chromium at an atomic percentage of 0.1% to 0.5%.
16. The MPEA filler material of claim 14 further comprising nickel at an atomic percentage of 0.1% to 19.5%.
17. The MPEA filler material of claim 14 further comprising copper at an atomic percentage of 0.1% to 28%.
18. The MPEA filler material of claim 14 wherein the single phase disordered facecentered cubic structure is substantially free of ordered, non-face-centered-cubic phases containing boron.
19. The MPEA filler material of claim 14 wherein the single phase disordered facecentered cubic structure is substantially free of phosphorous.
20. The MPEA filler material of claim 14 wherein the single phase disordered facecentered cubic structure is substantially free of secondary phases of silicon.
