High temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating and preparation method thereof
By using laser cladding technology to form a composite coating of tungsten carbide calcium fluoride cobalt-based alloy on the 316 stainless steel matrix of the lead-based reactor heat transfer pipeline, the problem of high temperature micro-wear is solved, and the high wear resistance and self-purpose coating is achieved Lubricating performance extends the service life of the equipment.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202310153195.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-02-22
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-02-22
AI Technical Summary
The heat transfer pipes of lead-based reactors are susceptible to micro-wearing under high temperature environments, and the prior art is difficult to effectively improve their wear resistance and self-lubricating properties.
The composite coating of tungsten carbide calcium fluoride cobalt-based alloy is formed on the surface of the 316 stainless steel matrix by using laser cladding technology. By uniformly mixing the cobalt-based alloy, WC ceramic reinforced phase and CaF2 self-lubricating phase, a self-lubricating coating with high temperature micro-wear is formed. , the laser cladding process is used to control the component proportions and process parameters to ensure the tight bonding of the coating and high-temperature performance.
It significantly improves the hardness and wear resistance of the substrate, and the coating exhibits good wear resistance and self-lubricating properties at 500 degrees Celsius, extends the service life of the heat transfer pipe and reduces the friction coefficient.
Smart Images

Figure CN116254529B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of nuclear power plants, and in particular relates to a high-temperature fretting-resistant self-lubricating coating and a preparation method thereof. Background Art
[0002] Lead-based reactors are reactors that use lead-based materials (lead or lead alloys) as the primary system coolant. As one of the six reactor types in the fourth-generation nuclear energy system, lead-based reactors are an advanced nuclear energy system that can achieve multiple applications and sustainable development.
[0003] Lead-based materials have important application value in both fission reactors and fusion reactors, critical reactors and subcritical reactors: in the fourth generation nuclear energy system, lead-based reactors are one of the six reference reactor types; in subcritical reactors, lead-based materials are important coolant candidate materials; the commonly used lead alloys in the nuclear energy field are lead-bismuth alloys or lead-lithium alloys. In fission lead-based reactors, in addition to lead, lead-bismuth eutectic alloys are also widely used as coolants, and lead-lithium eutectic alloys are used as coolants in fusion lead-based reactors. Lead-based materials have low neutron moderation ability and small capture cross-section, high thermal conductivity, low melting point, high boiling point and other thermal properties, as well as chemical inertness that almost does not react with water or air. Therefore, lead-based reactors using lead-based materials as coolants have good neutron economy, thermal safety characteristics and chemical safety characteristics. The heat transfer pipeline of the steam generator is the hub connecting the primary and secondary circuits, and plays a key role in transporting high-temperature liquids, while also having to withstand certain micro-motion wear.
[0004] Laser cladding technology refers to a modification technology that uses laser to process the surface of materials. It is suitable for surface damage repair and strengthening remanufacturing of various metals. With the development of laser cladding technology, it is now possible to clad the surface of some cheap substrates to form a cladding layer that is completely different from the composition, organization, and performance of the substrate to improve the hardness, corrosion resistance, wear resistance and other properties of the material. High-quality cladding layer is the core of laser cladding technology. Its characteristics are low dilution rate, good bonding with the substrate, small heat-affected zone, and small deformation of the substrate. With the development of laser cladding technology, laser cladding has moved from the field of scientific research to engineering practice, and is gradually playing an irreplaceable role.
[0005] In terms of material selection, cobalt-based alloys have been widely used since their development due to their excellent properties. The room temperature tensile strength of pure cobalt is 800MPa, with strong ductility and excellent high temperature performance. Cobalt-based alloys have good wear resistance, strong high temperature resistance and corrosion resistance. Due to the rise and development of laser cladding technology, more and more people are using cobalt-based alloy powders for laser cladding. Tungsten carbide has high hardness, high melting point and stable chemical properties. It is due to its own non-centrosymmetric simple hexagonal crystal structure. As a ceramic phase with a hardness close to that of diamond, tungsten carbide is most suitable for improving the surface hardness and wear resistance of workpieces. It is often used to make cutting tools, surface strengthening of mining machinery, molds, jet engines, gas turbines, etc. Calcium fluoride belongs to the equiaxed crystal system, and only a very low shear force is required to cause relative sliding between layers. At 600°C, calcium fluoride changes from brittle to tough, showing excellent self-lubricating properties. Studies have shown that at a temperature of 400°C, whether it is adhered to the friction surface as a solid lubricating film or exists in the composite coating as a lubricating phase, it can also exhibit lubricating properties and is a high-temperature lubricant.
[0006] Therefore, the coating prepared by the present invention is simple and low in cost, and the prepared coating has high hardness, excellent wear resistance, good corrosion resistance, good high temperature resistance, long service life and easy access to the substrate, which can meet the harsh service conditions of the internal heat transfer tube of the lead-based reactor. Therefore, we are committed to inventing a tungsten carbide calcium fluoride reinforced cobalt-based composite coating for laser cladding. Summary of the invention
[0007] The purpose of the present invention is to compare the materials of the tungsten carbide calcium fluoride cobalt-based alloy composite coating prepared on the surface of the 316 stainless steel substrate with the substrate without coating prepared on the surface of the 316 stainless steel substrate by comparative experimental analysis, and to select a certain proportion of mixed powder for laser cladding. The mixed powder prepared by this method can be used for laser cladding to prepare protective coatings and improve the high temperature fretting wear resistance of the surface of the 316 stainless steel substrate.
[0008] The present invention is a tungsten carbide calcium fluoride cobalt-based alloy composite material coating for laser cladding of 316 substrates. 316 stainless steel is used as the substrate, and a composite powder of a uniformly mixed cobalt-based alloy and tungsten carbide calcium fluoride is used as the powder for laser cladding. Laser cladding is performed on the surface of the 316 stainless steel substrate to obtain a layer of tungsten carbide calcium fluoride cobalt-based alloy composite coating whose main properties such as strength, hardness, and wear resistance are much higher than those of the 316 stainless steel substrate. In order to stabilize the morphology of the cladding layer, to make the cladding layer and the 316 stainless steel substrate closely combined, and to reduce the generation of pores, it is necessary to strictly control the process parameters and the proportion of each component in the entire cladding process.
[0009] The present invention is specifically implemented by the following technical solutions:
[0010] The first aspect of the present invention provides a high-temperature micro-motion wear resistant self-lubricating coating, comprising a cobalt-based alloy, a WC ceramic strengthening phase and a CaF2 self-lubricating phase. The contents of each component are as follows, in terms of mass percentage: WC: 10-30%, CaF2: 5-15%, and cobalt-based alloy: the remainder. WC has a hard reinforcing effect, and the effect is not obvious when the mass percentage is lower than 10%. CaF2 has a high-temperature self-lubricating effect, and the mass percentage should be not less than 5%. If the content is too little, the self-lubricating effect cannot be exerted during high-temperature operation. In order to ensure the synergistic effect between the components, the mass percentage of WC needs to be twice that of CaF2, so that the various performance requirements for the material's micro-motion wear resistance and high-temperature self-lubrication are achieved through this constraint relationship.
[0011] As a further illustration of the present invention, the content of components in the cobalt-based alloy, in terms of mass percentage, includes the following components: Cr: 28-29%, W: 4-5%, C: 1-1.5%, Si: 1-1.5%, Fe: 1-1.5%, Ni: 2-3%, Mn: 0-1%, and Mo: 0-1%.
[0012] As a further illustration of the present invention, a composite powder of a cobalt-based alloy and tungsten carbide and calcium fluoride is used as the powder for laser cladding, and laser cladding is performed on the surface of a 316 stainless steel substrate to form the high-temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating.
[0013] As a further illustration of the present invention, the particle size of each component powder in the coating is 50 μm-150 μm.
[0014] Another aspect of the present invention provides a method for preparing the high temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating described above, comprising the following steps:
[0015] Step 1: Weigh the coating components and proportions mentioned above to prepare laser cladding powder;
[0016] Step 2: ball-milling the prepared laser cladding powder to mix well, and then sieving the mixed powder with the required particle size;
[0017] Step 3: preheating the laser cladding substrate;
[0018] Step 4: Under a protective gas, a synchronous powder feeding method is adopted to use the dried mixed powder to laser clad the laser cladding substrate to form a cladding layer.
[0019] As a further illustration of the present invention, the weighing operation in step 1 is carried out in a glove box with an argon protective atmosphere.
[0020] As a further illustration of the present invention, the grinding balls used in step 2 are 316 stainless steel balls with a diameter of 3-10 mm and a ball-to-material ratio of 5:1;
[0021] The ball mill parameters are set as follows: the forward rotation time of the ball mill is 10-25 minutes, the reverse rotation time of the ball mill is 10-25 minutes, the intermediate interval time is 5-15 minutes, and the total setting time is 50-100 minutes.
[0022] As a further illustration of the present invention, the preparation method further comprises:
[0023] The mixed powder is placed in a vacuum drying oven and dried at 100-150° C. for 2-3 hours.
[0024] As a further illustration of the present invention, the laser cladding substrate is a 316 stainless steel substrate; the preheating temperature of the laser cladding substrate is 200-300°C.
[0025] As a further illustration of the present invention, the laser cladding parameters in step 4 are: laser power is 1.2-1.8kW. Since the melting point of cobalt-based alloy is about 1400 degrees Celsius, if the power is too low, the powder and the substrate cannot present a good metallurgical bond, and the bonding strength is low; if the power is too high, cracks will appear in the coating, and the macro quality will deteriorate. The laser power parameter temperature of 1.2-1.8kW is more suitable, and the powder and the substrate are better bonded; the circular spot diameter is 2-4mm; the overlap rate is: 40-60%, if the overlap rate is too low, deeper grooves will appear, and if the overlap rate is too high, higher protrusions will appear in the middle; the scanning speed is: 2-4mm / s, if the scanning speed is too slow, the material will have problems such as overburning, and if the scanning speed is too fast, the material cannot be fully melted; the protective gas is: argon; the powder feeding speed is: 12-24g / min; the powder feeding gas flow rate is 7-9L / min.
[0026] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following advantages:
[0027] The coating prepared by the present invention is a cobalt-based alloy as the main cladding component, WC as a ceramic strengthening phase, and CaF2 as a high-temperature self-lubricating phase. The present invention adds tungsten carbide, calcium fluoride, and a cobalt-based alloy on the surface of the substrate by a laser cladding method to significantly increase the hardness and wear resistance of the substrate. The composite coating includes a 316 stainless steel substrate, a heat-affected zone, and a cladding layer. The present invention can be applied to technical fields such as lead-based reactor heat transfer tubes in nuclear power plants. Under this working condition, the material is affected by high temperature on the one hand, and the pipeline is subject to micro-motion wear on the other hand. Combined with the influence of the coupling of the two, the wear of the substrate and the coating under high-temperature friction is tested, and the failure of the pipeline material under the coupling is analyzed.
[0028] The coating prepared by the present invention has no obvious defects such as holes and cracks inside, and the cladding layer is tightly bonded to the substrate, showing good metallurgical bonding. Through testing, it is found that the coating has good wear resistance and self-lubricating properties at a high temperature of 500 degrees Celsius, so that the heat transfer pipe of the steam generator has good fretting wear resistance and significantly increases the service life of the pipe. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0029] Figure 1 The XRD diagram of the laser cladding tungsten carbide calcium fluoride reinforced cobalt-based composite coating prepared by the present invention;
[0030] Figure 2 The curve of the friction coefficient changing with time in an environment of 500 degrees Celsius is shown for a 316 stainless steel substrate without coating and a sample of a cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride composite coating prepared by the present invention;
[0031] Figure 3 For the present invention, hardness curves of samples of cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride composite coatings as the distance from the top of the cladding layer changes were prepared;
[0032] Figure 4 Scanning electron microscope images of the interface between the coating and the substrate of the composite coating of cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide and calcium fluoride prepared for the present invention;
[0033] Figure 5 Scanning electron microscope images of wear pits on the substrate and the composite coating made of cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide and calcium fluoride after friction and wear tests; (a) is a 316 stainless steel substrate; (b) is a composite coating made of cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide and calcium fluoride;
[0034] Figure 6 The difference in wear between a 316 stainless steel substrate without coating and a composite coating of cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide and calcium fluoride according to the present invention is measured on a three-dimensional profilometer after a friction and wear test. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0035] The following will be combined with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention to clearly and completely describe the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0036] Example 1
[0037] A method for preparing a high-temperature fretting-resistant self-lubricating coating comprises the following steps:
[0038] Step 1: Use 316 stainless steel as the substrate and cobalt-based alloy powder as the cladding material. The morphology of the cobalt-based alloy is a powder with a particle size of about 75 μm. Use tungsten carbide as the ceramic strengthening phase, and the morphology is also a powder of about 75 μm. Use calcium fluoride as the high-temperature self-lubricating phase, and the morphology is also a powder of about 75 microns.
[0039] Step 2: Weigh 85g of cobalt-based alloy powder, 10g of tungsten carbide powder, and 5g of calcium fluoride powder in a glove box, put them into a ball mill, and add 316 stainless steel balls with a diameter of 7mm into the ball mill. The ball-to-material ratio is set to 5:1. The ball milling parameters are set to forward rotation for 20 minutes, reverse rotation for 20 minutes, and pause for 10 minutes in the middle, for a total of 50 minutes. After being evenly mixed together, put the ball mill into the glove box, use a sieve to filter out the 316 stainless steel balls, and place the sieved powder in a vacuum drying oven. The vacuum drying oven is set to a temperature of 120°C and a drying time of 2.5 hours. After drying, collect the powder and seal it in a vacuum for storage.
[0040] Step 3: Load the mixed powder into the powder feeder of the YLS-3000-CL laser cladding equipment, preheat the 316 stainless steel substrate short rod with a diameter of 25 mm to about 250°C and then perform laser cladding. The cladding parameters are: laser cladding power is 1.5 kW, the circular spot diameter of the laser is 3 mm, the overlap rate is 50%, the scanning speed is set to 2 mm / s, the powder feeding amount is set to 20 g / min, the protective gas flow rate is set to 12 L / min, the powder feeding gas flow rate is set to 8 L / min, and the protective atmosphere is argon. After preparing two samples by laser cladding, they are cooled in argon to obtain laser cladding coating samples.
[0041] Performance Test:
[0042] The 316 stainless steel substrate with laser cladding coating was cut into small pieces by a wire cutting machine, and the cross section of the cladding coating was polished with 200 mesh, 400 mesh, 600 mesh, 800 mesh, 1000 mesh, 2000 mesh and 4000 mesh in sequence; the polished section was then polished with polishing paste to remove the scratches produced on the cross section during grinding. When there were no scratches on the cross section, a microhardness tester was used to perform a dot test under a load of 200N and a pressure holding condition of 5s. The hardness of each point was measured and recorded, and the distance of each point from the surface of the cladding layer was recorded, thereby measuring the microhardness of the cross section of the cladding layer.
[0043] The surface of another prepared laser cladding coating sample was polished, and 200 mesh, 400 mesh, 600 mesh, 800 mesh, 1000 mesh, 2000 mesh, and 4000 mesh were also polished. Then the polished section was polished with polishing paste to remove the scratches on the section during polishing. When there were no scratches on the section, the side without coating was cut off using wire cutting equipment, so that the total height of the sample was 7.9 mm and the diameter was 25 mm. The sample was fixed with a high-temperature fixture, and the sample was preloaded and heated. The temperature was set to 500 degrees Celsius. When the temperature rose to 500 degrees Celsius, the friction and wear test was started, and the load of the test was set to 60N; the stroke of the test was set to 40 microns, and the frequency of the test was set to 30 Hz. After 200,000 cycles, the friction test ended. After the test environment dropped to room temperature, the sample was taken out. The friction coefficient during the friction and wear test was derived, and the wear volume was measured using a three-dimensional profiler.
[0044] XRD test: The prepared coating sample was placed in an XRD machine with a copper target, the setting time was 45 minutes, and the scanning angle was 15-110 degrees.
[0045] SEM scanning: The test sample is placed in a scanning electron microscope (SEM) equipped with a secondary electron backscatter diffusion (EBSD) probe to scan the test area. One part is used to shoot the middle part of the cross section of the cladding layer, and the other part is used to shoot the interface between the cladding layer and the substrate to observe its bonding with the substrate.
[0046] Wear resistance test: A high temperature friction and wear tester (SRV) was used to conduct the friction and wear test. After the test, a three-dimensional optical profiler from Bruker Corporation of the United States was used to test the wear volume of the grinding pit.
[0047] A 316 stainless steel substrate was selected, and the substrate surface was polished. Sandpaper of 200, 400, 600, 800, 1000, 2000, and 4000 mesh was used for polishing. The polished surface was then polished with polishing paste to remove the scratches on the surface during polishing. When there were no scratches on the surface, a wire cutting device was used to cut off a part of the unpolished side, so that the total height of the sample was 7.9 mm and the diameter was 25 mm. The sample was fixed with a high-temperature fixture, and the sample was preloaded and heated. The temperature was set to 500 degrees Celsius. When the temperature rose to 500 degrees Celsius, the friction and wear test was started. After 200,000 cycles, the friction test ended. After the test environment dropped to room temperature, the substrate sample was taken out. The wear volume was measured using a three-dimensional profiler. Wear resistance test: A high-temperature friction and wear tester (SRV) was used for the friction and wear test. After the test, a three-dimensional optical profiler from Brooke, USA, was used to test the wear volume of the grinding pit.
[0048] Figure 1 The XRD diagram of the laser cladding cobalt-based alloy and tungsten carbide, calcium fluoride composite coating shows that the prepared coating mainly contains high-temperature α-Co, WC, M 23 C6 ingredient.
[0049] Figure 2 The curves of the friction coefficient of the 316 stainless steel substrate without coating and the composite coating of cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide and calcium fluoride at 500℃ vary with time. Figure 2 The listed results show that the friction coefficient of the sample decreases with the use of the cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride composite coating. The friction coefficient of the pure 316 stainless steel substrate reaches about 0.8 at 500°C, while the friction coefficient of the composite coating using cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride reaches about 0.75 at 500 degrees Celsius. This shows that the addition of the cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride composite coating significantly improves the wear resistance. At the same time, due to the self-lubricating effect of calcium fluoride itself, the coating has a certain self-lubricating function at high temperature, which also reduces the friction coefficient.
[0050] Figure 3 The cross section of the 316 stainless steel substrate surface prepared with a cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride composite coating shows the hardness change from the cladding layer surface to the 316 stainless steel substrate. It can be seen that the hardness of the coating is about 575HV, the hardness of the intermediate transition zone decreases, and the hardness of the 316 stainless steel substrate is about 215HV. The hardness of the coating is about 2.7 times that of the substrate.
[0051] Figure 4This is a scanning electron microscope image of the junction between the cladding layer of the cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride composite coating and the substrate; it can be seen that most of the WC exists in the cobalt-based solid solution, which improves the hardness and wear resistance, and a small part of the WC is pinned at the grain boundary, which also plays a role in dispersion strengthening and improves the hardness and wear resistance of the coating. It can be seen that there is a good metallurgical bond between the two, and no obvious defects such as shrinkage, shrinkage, and cracks appear. Therefore, the prepared sample meets the test requirements and can meet the use requirements.
[0052] Figure 5 (a) is a 316 stainless steel substrate and (b) is a sample using a cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride composite coating. The morphology of the wear spot was taken under a scanning electron microscope after the friction and wear test. It can be seen that compared with the wear morphology of the substrate, the wear morphology of the cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride composite coating is smaller, the wear is milder, and it has better wear resistance.
[0053] Figure 6 The wear volume of the wear spot measured in a three-dimensional profilometer after the friction and wear test of the sample using the cobalt-based alloy, tungsten carbide, and calcium fluoride composite coating and the 316 stainless steel substrate. It can be seen that the wear volume of the substrate is 1.2×10 6 μm 3 , while the wear volume of the coating is only 0.2×10 6 μm 3 The wear volume of the 316 stainless steel substrate is 6 times that of the coating, which shows that the coating has good wear resistance and self-lubricating properties.
[0054] It should be noted that, in this article, terms such as "comprises", "includes" or any other variations thereof are intended to cover non-exclusive inclusion, so that a process, method, article or apparatus that includes a series of elements includes not only those elements, but also other elements not explicitly listed, or also includes elements inherent to such process, method, article or apparatus.
[0055] Although embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that various changes, modifications, substitutions and variations may be made to the embodiments without departing from the principles and spirit of the present invention, and that the scope of the present invention is defined by the appended claims and their equivalents.
Claims
1. A high temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating, characterized in that: The invention comprises a cobalt-based alloy, a WC ceramic strengthening phase and a CaF2 self-lubricating phase, wherein the contents of each component are as follows by mass percentage: WC: 10-30%, CaF2: 5-15%, and the cobalt-based alloy: the balance; wherein the mass percentage of WC is twice that of CaF2; the contents of the components in the cobalt-based alloy, by mass percentage, comprise the following components: Cr: 28-29%, W: 4-5%, C: 1-1.5%, Si: 1-1.5%, Fe: 1-1.5%, Ni: 2-3%, Mn: 0-1%, and Mo: 0-1%; the coating contains high-temperature α-Co, WC, Mn, and CaF2. 23 C6 ingredients; The method for preparing the above-mentioned high temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating comprises the following steps: Step 1: Weigh the coating composition and proportions mentioned above to prepare laser cladding powder; Step 2: ball-milling the prepared laser cladding powder to mix well, and then sieving the mixed powder with the required particle size; Step 3: preheating the laser cladding substrate; Step 4: Under the protective gas, the laser cladding substrate is laser clad with the dried mixed powder in a synchronous powder feeding manner to form a cladding layer; the laser cladding parameters are: laser power is 1.2-1.8kW; circular spot diameter is 2-4mm; overlap rate is 40-60%; scanning speed is 2-4mm / s; protective gas is argon; powder feeding speed is 12-24g / min, and powder feeding gas flow rate is 7-9L / min.
2. The high temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating according to claim 1, characterized in that: The particle size of each component powder in the coating is 50 μm-150 μm.
3. The high temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating according to claim 1, characterized in that: The weighing operation in step 1 is carried out in a glove box with argon as the protective atmosphere.
4. The high temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating according to claim 1, characterized in that: The grinding balls used in step 2 are 316 stainless steel balls with a diameter of 3-10 mm and a ball-to-material ratio of 5:1; The ball mill parameters are set as follows: the forward rotation time of the ball mill is 10-25 minutes, the reverse rotation time of the ball mill is 10-25 minutes, the intermediate interval time is 5-15 minutes, and the total setting time is 50-100 minutes.
5. The high temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating according to claim 1, characterized in that: The preparation method further comprises: The mixed powder is placed in a vacuum drying oven and dried at 100-150° C. for 2-3 hours.
6. The high temperature fretting wear resistant self-lubricating coating according to claim 1, characterized in that: The laser cladding substrate is a 316 stainless steel substrate; the preheating temperature of the laser cladding substrate is 200-300°C.
