Zero-carbon power supply station carbon evaluation classification index system construction method considering carbon flow analysis

By obtaining the output results of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network and the frequency statistics method empowerment in the zero-carbon power supply station, a carbon evaluation classification index system was formed. Combined with carbon flow analysis, the problem of inaccurate evaluation results in the existing technology was solved, and the realization of the realization of the realization of the evaluation results. More accurate carbon emission assessment and green development assessment.

CN118941135APending Publication Date: 2024-11-12GUANGXI POWER GRID CORP
View PDF 0 Cites 1 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410941916.0
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-15
Publication Date
2024-11-12

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118941135A_ABST
    Figure CN118941135A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a construction method of a zero-carbon power supply station carbon evaluation classification index system considering carbon flow analysis, and relates to the technical field of carbon emission monitoring, and the method comprises the steps: obtaining an output result of a power network steady-state carbon flow model of a zero-carbon power supply station; according to the output result and a target of the zero-carbon power supply station, obtaining each carbon evaluation classification index of zero-carbon power supply; weighting each carbon evaluation classification index through a frequency statistical method; and integrating the weighted carbon evaluation classification indexes to obtain a zero-carbon power supply station carbon evaluation classification index system. According to the method, multi-dimensional comprehensive evaluation is carried out in combination with carbon flow analysis, and the zero carbon level of the power supply station is evaluated more comprehensively and more accurately. And meanwhile, through carbon flow analysis, the flowing and conversion process of carbon in the power supply station can be accurately tracked, so that the carbon emission condition of the power supply station is more accurately evaluated, and the evaluation result is more comparable and operable.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of carbon emission monitoring, and in particular to a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station taking carbon flow analysis into consideration. Background Art

[0002] Carbon emissions are the main factor causing global climate change and energy crisis. At the same time, as the main participant in carbon emissions, the power industry is in urgent need of "low-carbon" reforms. Zero-carbon power stations are micro-power systems that integrate new energy power generation, energy storage, charging piles, and power facilities to achieve full clean energy supply and zero-carbon operation in power stations. This type of power station is an important part of promoting the construction of new power systems and provides an effective implementation path for achieving the "dual carbon" goals. For zero-carbon power stations, the carbon assessment classification indicator system helps to measure their carbon emission levels and evaluate the effectiveness of low-carbon measures, thereby promoting their development in a lower-carbon and more environmentally friendly direction.

[0003] The current carbon assessment classification indicator system mainly conducts carbon assessment analysis by setting relevant indicators and combining indicator weights. Although this method can serve as a reference, it does not combine carbon flow analysis, which can easily lead to inaccurate assessment results of the evaluation system.

[0004] In view of this, a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for zero-carbon power supply stations that considers carbon flow analysis is needed. Summary of the invention

[0005] In view of the problem that the carbon assessment classification index system in the prior art does not combine carbon flow analysis, resulting in inaccurate assessment results, the present invention provides a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for zero-carbon power supply stations that considers carbon flow analysis, which can more comprehensively and accurately assess the carbon emissions of zero-carbon power supply stations. The specific technical solution is as follows:

[0006] A method for constructing a carbon assessment classification indicator system for zero-carbon power supply stations considering carbon flow analysis, including:

[0007] Obtain the output results of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network of the zero-carbon power supply station;

[0008] According to the output results and the goal of zero-carbon power supply, various carbon assessment classification indicators of zero-carbon power supply are obtained;

[0009] Weights are assigned to each carbon assessment classification indicator through frequency statistics;

[0010] The weighted carbon assessment classification indicators are integrated to obtain the carbon assessment classification indicator system of zero-carbon power supply stations.

[0011] Preferably, obtaining the output result of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network of the zero-carbon power supply station includes:

[0012] Obtain the carbon flow rate data of each node, branch and unit calculated by the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network;

[0013] The carbon flow rate data of each node, branch and unit are analyzed to obtain the main sources of carbon emissions, distribution characteristics and change trends over time.

[0014] Preferably, the various carbon assessment classification indicators for zero-carbon power supply include clean energy power generation indicators, terminal load power consumption indicators, system evaluation indicators, zero-carbon management and control platform indicators, carbon sink indicators, low-carbon atmosphere creation indicators, safety management indicators, and additional classification indicators.

[0015] Preferably, the weighting of each carbon assessment classification indicator by frequency statistics method includes:

[0016] Obtain key sub-indicators for each carbon assessment classification indicator;

[0017] The key secondary indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator are weighted through frequency statistics to obtain the weighted carbon assessment classification indicators.

[0018] Preferably, the key evaluation indicators for obtaining each carbon assessment classification indicator include:

[0019] The key secondary indicators were screened out from each carbon assessment classification indicator through the expert trust communication-decision laboratory analysis method. The screening results are as follows:

[0020] The key sub-indicators of the clean energy power generation indicators include the proportion of photovoltaic power generation, the proportion of wind power generation and the proportion of energy storage;

[0021] The key sub-indicators of the terminal load electricity consumption indicators include the proportion of new energy vehicles, the proportion of two-way charging pile facilities and the proportion of DC electricity consumption in buildings;

[0022] The key sub-indicators of the building system evaluation indicators include the proportion of green building materials used and the building energy saving rate;

[0023] The key secondary indicators of the zero-carbon management and control platform indicators include carbon flow analysis and calculation, and green electricity trading balance calculation of zero-carbon power supply stations;

[0024] The key sub-indicators of the carbon sink indicators include green coverage rate, purchase of certified voluntary emission reductions and other methods to offset carbon emissions;

[0025] The key sub-indicators of the low-carbon atmosphere creation index include the reuse of electrical equipment and wastewater greening irrigation;

[0026] The key sub-indicators of the safety management indicators include regular equipment maintenance;

[0027] The key sub-indicators of the additional classification indicators include green building certification and carbon neutral certification.

[0028] Preferably, the key secondary indicators screened out from each carbon assessment classification indicator by the expert trust propagation-decision laboratory analysis method include:

[0029] Obtain scores from multiple experts for all sub-indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator under the preset impact degree scoring rules, and obtain multiple direct impact matrices corresponding to the number of experts based on the scoring results;

[0030] Get the weighted results of multiple experts;

[0031] Obtaining a comprehensive influence matrix according to the multiple direct influence matrices and the weight results;

[0032] Through the calculation results of the comprehensive impact matrix, key secondary indicators are screened out from all secondary indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator.

[0033] Preferably, the key secondary indicators selected from all secondary indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator through the calculation result of the comprehensive impact matrix include:

[0034] By comparing the calculation result of the comprehensive impact matrix with the preset impact factor threshold, when the calculation result of the secondary indicator is greater than the impact factor threshold, it is screened as a key secondary indicator, otherwise it is a non-key secondary indicator.

[0035] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:

[0036] The method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station considering carbon flow analysis of the present invention obtains the output result of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network of the zero-carbon power supply station; obtains each carbon assessment classification index of the zero-carbon power supply according to the output result and the goal of the zero-carbon power supply station; weights each carbon assessment classification index by frequency statistics; integrates each weighted carbon assessment classification index to obtain a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station. The present invention combines carbon flow analysis with a multi-dimensional comprehensive evaluation to more comprehensively and accurately evaluate the zero-carbon level of the power supply station. At the same time, through carbon flow analysis, the flow and transformation process of carbon in the power supply station can be accurately tracked, thereby more accurately evaluating the carbon emissions of the power supply station, making the evaluation results more comparable and operational. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0037] In order to more clearly illustrate the specific embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the following is a brief introduction to the drawings required for the specific embodiments or the description of the prior art. In all the drawings, similar elements or parts are generally identified by similar reference numerals. In the drawings, the elements or parts are not necessarily drawn according to the actual scale.

[0038] Figure 1 This is a flow chart of a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station that takes carbon flow analysis into consideration according to the present invention.

[0039] Figure 2 This is a flow chart of another embodiment of a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply taking into account carbon flow analysis of the present invention.

[0040] Figure 3 Schematic diagram of a steady-state carbon flow model for an energy station without taking into account equipment losses according to an embodiment of the present invention.

[0041] Figure 4 Schematic diagram of the relationship between the carbon flow density of the distribution network and the carbon potential of the corresponding node according to an embodiment of the present invention.

[0042] Figure 5 Schematic diagram of the relationship between the carbon flow density of the gas distribution network and the carbon potential of the corresponding node in an embodiment of the present invention.

[0043] Figure 6 Schematic diagram of the relationship between the carbon flow density of the thermal network and the carbon potential of the corresponding node according to an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0044] The following will be combined with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention to clearly and completely describe the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0045] It should be understood that when used in this specification and the appended claims, the terms "include" and "comprises" indicate the presence of described features, integers, steps, operations, elements and / or components, but do not exclude the presence or addition of one or more other features, integers, steps, operations, elements, components and / or combinations thereof.

[0046] It should also be understood that the terms used in the present specification are only for the purpose of describing specific embodiments and are not intended to limit the present invention. As used in the present specification and the appended claims, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise, the singular forms "a", "an" and "the" are intended to include plural forms.

[0047] It should be further understood that the term "and / or" used in the present description and the appended claims refers to any and all possible combinations of one or more of the associated listed items, and includes these combinations.

[0048] See the following examples Figures 1 to 6 .

[0049] The present application embodiment provides a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station taking into account carbon flow analysis, including:

[0050] Step S1, obtaining the output result of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network of the zero-carbon power supply station;

[0051] The steady-state carbon flow model of the power network in this embodiment is a model for analyzing and calculating the flow of carbon emissions in the power system of a building. The model is based on the power flow distribution of the power system and introduces the concept of carbon flow to quantify the carbon emissions of each node and branch in the power system, thereby achieving refined management of carbon emissions in the power system.

[0052] Specifically, the output results of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network of the zero-carbon power supply station include:

[0053] Obtain the carbon flow rate data of each node, branch and unit calculated by the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network.

[0054] The carbon flow rate data of each node, branch and unit are analyzed to obtain the main sources of carbon emissions, distribution characteristics and change trends over time.

[0055] Step S2, obtaining various carbon assessment classification indicators of zero-carbon power supply according to the output results and the goal of zero-carbon power supply;

[0056] The output results of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network include the carbon flow rate data of each node, branch and unit, and the corresponding carbon emission data. The goal of the zero-carbon power supply station is to achieve zero carbon emissions in the power supply process. The various carbon assessment classification indicators of zero-carbon power supply are obtained by combining the output data in the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network with the goal of the zero-carbon power supply station.

[0057] Specifically, the various carbon assessment classification indicators for zero-carbon power supply include clean energy power generation indicators, terminal load power consumption indicators, system evaluation indicators, zero-carbon management and control platform indicators, carbon sink indicators, low-carbon atmosphere creation indicators, safety management indicators, and additional classification indicators.

[0058] Reasons for establishing clean energy power generation evaluation indicators: Clean energy power generation produces no or very little greenhouse gas emissions, and plays a key role in promoting the transformation of the power industry to low-carbon and carbon-free. Establishing clean energy power generation indicators can clarify the goals and results of clean energy utilization in power supply areas, and help guide the power industry to develop in a more environmentally friendly direction.

[0059] Reasons for setting up terminal load power consumption indicators: By setting up terminal load power consumption indicators, power supply stations can more accurately grasp the changing patterns of power loads, thereby optimizing grid dispatching and operation. This helps improve grid operation efficiency, reduce energy loss, and lower operating costs.

[0060] The reason for establishing building system evaluation indicators is to ensure that the building part is coordinated with the overall zero-carbon goal and promote the low-carbon transformation of the energy structure.

[0061] Reasons for setting up zero-carbon management and control platform evaluation indicators: It helps to establish a carbon emission management system and regulate the carbon emission behavior of power supply stations. Through real-time monitoring, data analysis, early warning and other functions, abnormal carbon emissions can be discovered in time, and effective measures can be taken to correct them, ensuring that the carbon emissions of power supply stations meet relevant standards and requirements.

[0062] Reasons for setting up carbon sink evaluation indicators: The core goal of a zero-carbon power station is to achieve zero or negative carbon emissions within the power station. Carbon sinks, as an effective measure to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, can increase the absorption and fixation of carbon dioxide through greening methods such as afforestation, forest management and vegetation restoration, thereby significantly reducing the concentration of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.

[0063] Reasons for setting up evaluation indicators for creating a low-carbon atmosphere: Evaluation indicators for creating a low-carbon atmosphere can quantitatively evaluate the efforts and achievements of power supply stations in promoting green and low-carbon concepts. By setting specific evaluation indicators, such as the reduction rate of office power loss and the coverage rate of green plants, power supply stations can be guided to take active measures to create a strong low-carbon cultural atmosphere, thereby enhancing the image and reputation of power supply stations in the society.

[0064] Reasons for setting up safety management indicators: Safety management is the foundation of the power industry and is directly related to the stable operation of power supply stations. Setting up safety management indicators can ensure that power supply stations have a high degree of safety and reliability while pursuing zero carbon emissions.

[0065] Reasons for setting up additional bonus indicators: As a positive incentive mechanism, additional bonus indicators can encourage power suppliers to pursue higher energy efficiency, technological innovation and environmental performance on the basis of achieving zero carbon emission goals.

[0066] Step S3, weighting each carbon assessment classification indicator by frequency statistics method;

[0067] Specifically, the weighting of each carbon assessment classification indicator by frequency statistics method includes:

[0068] Obtain key sub-indicators for each carbon assessment classification indicator;

[0069] The key secondary indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator are weighted through frequency statistics to obtain the weighted carbon assessment classification indicators.

[0070] For each indicator, all the experts' scores are grouped according to a certain group interval, and the frequency of scores in each group is calculated. The median (or average) of the group with the largest frequency is the final weight of the indicator. This method can reduce the impact of extreme scores and make the results more stable.

[0071] The frequency statistics method mainly relies on the experience, knowledge and subjective judgment of experts in related fields. It is a subjective weighting method. It believes that the essence of weight is the quantitative reflection of the relative importance of the evaluation index to the evaluation target.

[0072] Step S4: Integrate the weighted carbon assessment classification indicators to obtain a carbon assessment classification indicator system for a zero-carbon power supply station.

[0073] Based on the integrated carbon assessment classification index system of zero-carbon power supply stations, a comprehensive and accurate assessment of the carbon emission level and green development level of zero-carbon power supply stations can be achieved.

[0074] In this embodiment, the carbon flow rate data of each node, branch and unit calculated by the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network. In this embodiment, the relevant carbon flow rate is selected for reference explanation:

[0075] The steady-state carbon flow model of the power network is constructed by obtaining the topological structure information of the power network, including the connection relationship between nodes, branches, transformers and other components; collecting parameters such as carbon emission intensity and efficiency of each unit, which may come from the unit manufacturer, historical statistical data or real-time monitoring system; obtaining the load data of the power network, including the load size and load curve of each node. The power flow calculation is performed under the steady state of the power grid to obtain the power flow data such as active power and reactive power of each branch. Based on the power flow distribution of the power system and the carbon emission characteristics of the unit, a carbon flow calculation model is established. Carbon flow exists dependent on power flow, and its distribution is affected by factors such as the topological structure of the power grid, the operating status and the carbon emission intensity of the unit. The carbon emission intensity of the unit is combined with the power flow data to calculate the carbon emission rate of each branch. The power flow tracking method and other methods are used to calculate the contribution of each unit to the system network loss, and the network loss carbon emission is allocated to each unit accordingly. At the same time, the carbon emission that the system load should bear is determined.

[0076] (1) Steady-state carbon flow model for building-level power grid

[0077] When considering the line loss of the power network, the line carbon flow rate represents the carbon flow that passes through the branch line with the active power flow per unit time. If the carbon emissions caused by line loss are taken into account, the carbon flow rate is expressed as follows:

[0078]

[0079] In the formula, are the active power and active power loss of the j-th branch of the power network connecting node n, respectively;

[0080] According to the aforementioned PSP basic conditions, the carbon potential of a node is determined by the carbon emission flow generated by the generator set connected to the node and the carbon emission flow flowing into the node from other nodes, which can be expressed as follows:

[0081]

[0082] Where NP and KP are the number of other nodes and the number of generators connected to node n in the power network, respectively; are the active power and active power loss of the j-th branch of the power network connecting node n, respectively; Active power of the kth generator set; is the carbon flow density of the j-th branch of the power network connecting node n; is the carbon potential of the kth generator connected to the power network node n.

[0083] (2) Steady-state carbon flow model for building-level natural gas network

[0084] Natural gas is a primary energy source, so the carbon emissions in the natural gas network are regarded as the potential carbon emissions of natural gas. When considering the connection of the compressor to the natural gas pipeline network, it is necessary to consider the additional carbon emissions caused by the compressor energy consumption. The carbon flow rate of the natural gas network line is expressed as follows:

[0085]

[0086] In the formula, and are the natural gas flow of natural gas network branch j and the natural gas flow consumed by the compressor; q gas is the calorific value of natural gas.

[0087] Similar to the power grid, the carbon potential of a natural gas network node is determined by the carbon emission flow generated by the upper-level natural gas gate station connected to the node and the carbon emission flow flowing into the node from other nodes, which can be expressed as follows:

[0088]

[0089] Where NG and KG are the number of other nodes connected to node n in the natural gas network and the number of upper-level natural gas gate stations, respectively; and They are the natural gas flow of the jth branch of the natural gas network connection node n and the natural gas flow consumed by the compressor, as well as the natural gas flow input to the kth natural gas gate station; is the carbon flow density of the j-th branch of the natural gas network connecting node n; is the carbon potential of the kth natural gas gate station connected to the natural gas network node n.

[0090] (3) Steady-state carbon flow model for building-level thermal network

[0091] The thermal network consists of heat sources, heat loads, and water supply and return pipes. Heat is generated by the heat source, transported to the load through the water circulation of the water supply pipe, and finally returned to the heat source through the water return pipe. Therefore, the thermal network is physically different from the power network and the natural gas network. When analyzing the steady-state carbon flow model, it is necessary to consider the carbon emission flow rate and node carbon potential of the water supply pipe and the water return pipe respectively, and also take into account the pipeline carbon flow rate loss corresponding to the thermal power loss of the water supply and return pipes.

[0092] The thermal power loss of the water supply and return pipes in the thermal network is expressed as follows:

[0093]

[0094] In the formula, and are the thermal power loss of the jth water supply and return pipe in the thermal network; m j is the medium flow rate of the jth pipeline; and are the temperatures at the beginning and end of the jth water supply pipe respectively; and are the head and end temperatures of the jth return pipe respectively.

[0095] When the carbon emissions generated by pipeline losses are taken into account, the carbon flow rate of the heat network supply and return pipeline is expressed as follows:

[0096]

[0097] In the formula, and are the carbon emission flow rates of the jth water supply and return pipe in the thermal network respectively; and are the nodal carbon potential of the jth pipeline respectively; and are the thermal power and thermal power loss of the jth supply and return water pipe respectively.

[0098] Similarly, the carbon potential of a thermal network node consists of two parts: supply water and return water. It is determined by the carbon emission flow generated by the heat source connected to the node and the carbon emission flow flowing into the node from other nodes, as shown below:

[0099]

[0100] In the formula, NH and KH are the number of other nodes and the number of heat sources connected to node n in the thermal network, respectively; and are the thermal power and thermal power loss of the j-th branch of the water supply network connecting node n, and the thermal power output of the k-th heat source; is the carbon flow density of the j-th branch of the water supply network connecting node n; is the carbon potential of the kth heat source connected to the node n in the water supply network; and are the thermal power and thermal power loss of the j-th branch of the return network connecting node n, and the thermal power output of the k-th heat source; is the carbon flow density of the j-th branch of the backwater network connecting node n; is the carbon potential of the kth heat source connected to node n in the return network.

[0101] In actual engineering applications, the regional thermal system is usually operated by an energy station and supplies thermal energy. Therefore, the source node of the thermal network is the heat output node of the energy station. The carbon potential and input carbon flow rate of this node are determined by the steady-state carbon flow model of the energy station. The specific model is described in detail in the next section.

[0102] (4) Carbon flow distribution of power stations based on energy hubs

[0103] In the lossless carbon flow model of energy stations, carbon emissions are transferred from one energy system to another along with energy conversion. Only the conversion and distribution of multi-energy carbon flows in equipment are considered, and the loss of carbon flows in energy stations is not considered. That is, in the process of carbon emission responsibility allocation of building-level integrated energy systems, energy stations are considered not to bear carbon emission responsibility.

[0104] Based on the lossless carbon flow model of energy stations, energy conversion devices are divided into two types: single-input-single-output conversion devices, such as gas boilers, electric boilers, refrigeration units, etc., and single-input-multiple-output conversion devices, such as cogeneration units, combined heat and power units, etc. In this lossless model, the total amount of carbon emission flow at the output end should be equal to the total amount of carbon emission flow at the input end. The steady-state carbon flow models of the two types of devices are established as follows:

[0105] e in ·P in =e out ·P out

[0106] In the formula, ein and e out are the carbon potentials at the input and output ports of the single-input-single-output device, respectively; P in and P out are the input and output active powers respectively.

[0107]

[0108] In the formula, is the carbon potential at the input port of a single-input-multiple-output device; and are the carbon potentials of multiple output ports, respectively; is the active power of the input port; and are the active powers of multiple output ports respectively.

[0109] In order to describe the distribution relationship of carbon emission flow at the output end of a single-input-multiple-output device, it is usually defined that the node carbon potential of different energy output ports is proportional to the efficiency of the corresponding energy.

[0110]

[0111] Where η I and η II are the energy conversion efficiencies of different energy conversion devices.

[0112] Classical calculation method of carbon flow model for building-level integrated energy system

[0113] (1) Principle of carbon flow proportion allocation of building-level energy system

[0114] In order to explore the relationship between the branch carbon flow rate R and the corresponding node carbon potential e, the Proportional Sharing Principle (PSP) is introduced as a basic condition: if node n injects power from several incoming branches at a given ratio, it will distribute the power to each outgoing branch at the original ratio. PSP is usually applied in an ideal lossless network. In fact, for any given node n, regardless of the line loss, the PSP it should comply with is only related to the outflow power of the node's incoming branch and the incoming power of the outgoing branch.

[0115] PSP is also applicable to the carbon flow calculation model of building-level integrated energy system. Its physical meaning is: the carbon flow density ρ of all outflow branch flows is independent of the branch, that is, the carbon flow density ρ of the outflow branch is equal to the carbon potential e of the node. The relationship between the carbon flow density ρ and the node carbon potential e is as follows: Figure 2 shown.

[0116]

[0117] In the formula, and are the carbon flow density of branch j of the power network, natural gas network and thermal network respectively; and are the carbon flow rates of branch j of the power network, natural gas network and thermal network respectively; and are the active power of branch j of the electricity network, natural gas network and thermal network respectively; and are the carbon potential of node n respectively.

[0118] (2) Calculation method of building-level carbon flow matrix

[0119] The basic idea of ​​the carbon flow matrix algorithm is to obtain the matrix representation of the carbon potential of the system nodes through the matrix representation of the power system flow data, and then obtain the "carbon element" data such as the carbon emission flow rate of each branch and key section of the system. The difficulty of the carbon flow matrix algorithm lies in the construction of various matrices that are suitable for computer calculations. Its advantage is that the calculation method is simple and can obtain the carbon emission flow distribution information of the entire system at one time. Its disadvantage is that when the system scale grows, the complexity of matrix calculations increases greatly and the solution speed decreases.

[0120] The matrix calculation formula of the carbon potential of the power system node is as follows:

[0121]

[0122] In the formula, is the carbon potential matrix of power system nodes; is the node active flux matrix; is the branch active power flow matrix; is the active matrix of the generator set; is the carbon emission intensity vector at the source end of the power system.

[0123] The unit-node carbon flow association matrix of the power system can identify the way the flow injected into the system by the unit flows from the node where the unit is located to the target node. The matrix calculation formula is as follows:

[0124]

[0125] In the formula, is the power system unit-node carbon flow correlation matrix; is the unit-load carbon flow correlation matrix; ξ m is an m-dimensional row vector, where all elements are 1.

[0126] Specifically, the key evaluation indicators for obtaining each carbon assessment classification indicator include:

[0127] The key sub-indicators are screened out from each carbon assessment classification indicator through the expert trust diffusion-decision laboratory analysis method. The screening includes the following steps:

[0128] Step S31: Obtain scores from multiple experts for all sub-indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator under a preset impact degree scoring rule (as shown in Table 1), and obtain multiple direct impact matrices corresponding to the number of experts according to the scoring results;

[0129] The preset impact scoring rules are shown in Table 1. They are a unified scoring rule used to quantify the experts' judgment on the impact of each sub-indicator. This rule is based on a three-point scoring system. Invite multiple experts with professional knowledge and experience in relevant fields to score all sub-indicators under each carbon assessment classification indicator according to the preset scoring rules. The scoring should reflect the expert's subjective judgment on the importance of each sub-indicator in the classification indicator to which it belongs. The scoring results of each expert will be used to construct a direct impact matrix. Each row and column of this matrix corresponds to a sub-indicator, and the elements in the matrix represent the degree of influence of one sub-indicator on another sub-indicator. Since each expert will provide such a matrix, multiple direct impact matrices will be obtained, each corresponding to the evaluation results of an expert.

[0130] Table 1 Impact rating table

[0131] Impact Unrelated Low middle high Fraction 0 1 2 3

[0132] Step S32, obtaining weight results of multiple experts;

[0133] The weight of the experts reflects their authority and credibility in the evaluation process. This can be determined in a variety of ways, such as based on the expert's qualifications, experience, publications in related fields, etc. The weight result can be a value between 0 and 1, and the sum of all experts' weights should be 1.

[0134] Step S33, obtaining a comprehensive influence matrix according to the multiple direct influence matrices and the weight results;

[0135] All weighted direct impact matrices are synthesized, usually through simple arithmetic or weighted average, to obtain a comprehensive impact matrix that integrates the opinions of multiple experts.

[0136] Step S34: Using the calculation results of the comprehensive impact matrix, select key secondary indicators from all secondary indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator.

[0137] The elements in the comprehensive impact matrix reflect the relative importance or degree of influence of each secondary indicator. By analyzing the element values ​​in the matrix, it is possible to identify which secondary indicators have a significant impact on other indicators or the entire classification indicator. According to the analysis results, the secondary indicators with the highest degree of influence and the most critical can be screened out from all the secondary indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator. For example, by comparing the calculation result of the comprehensive impact matrix with the preset influencing factor threshold, when the calculation result of the secondary indicator is greater than the influencing factor threshold, it is screened as a key secondary indicator, otherwise it is a non-key secondary indicator.

[0138] The following results can be obtained through the above calculation and analysis:

[0139] The key sub-indicators of the clean energy power generation indicators include the proportion of photovoltaic power generation, wind power generation and energy storage; clean energy power generation produces no or very little greenhouse gas emissions, and plays a key role in promoting the transformation of the power industry to low-carbon and carbon-free. The establishment of clean energy power generation indicators can clarify the goals and achievements of clean energy utilization in power supply, and help guide the power industry to develop in a more environmentally friendly direction. The specific key sub-indicators are as follows:

[0140] (1) Proportion of photovoltaic power generation

[0141] The proportion of photovoltaic power generation is the ratio of the amount of photovoltaic power generated by the power supply station through self-built photovoltaic power generation during the evaluation period to the total comprehensive energy consumption of the power supply station during the period. The larger the indicator is, the greater the proportion of clean energy in the power supply station is, and the more conducive it is to the power supply station to achieve low carbon.

[0142]

[0143] In the formula, E 光伏 The photovoltaic power generation of the power supply station during the evaluation period, in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce); N 综合消耗 The total comprehensive energy consumption during the evaluation period is measured in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce).

[0144] (2) Proportion of wind power generation

[0145] The proportion of wind power generation is the ratio of the wind power generation in the power supply station during the evaluation period to the total comprehensive energy consumption of the power supply station during the period. The larger the index is, the greater the proportion of clean energy in the power supply station is, and the more conducive it is to achieving low carbon in the power supply station.

[0146]

[0147] In the formula, E 风力 is the wind power generation of the power station, in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce); N 综合消耗 It is the total comprehensive energy consumption, measured in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce).

[0148] (3) Energy storage ratio

[0149] When the system power supply is greater than the demand, energy storage is equivalent to load and can store the unconsumed power; when the supply is less than the demand, energy storage can be equivalent to the power supply to the load, so energy storage is crucial in achieving clean energy supply and zero carbon power supply. At the same time, energy storage consumes energy while storing, so this indicator refers to the ratio of the difference between the power supply and energy storage loss in the power supply station during the evaluation period to the total comprehensive energy consumption of the power supply station during the period.

[0150]

[0151] In the formula, E 储能供电 E is the energy storage power supply, in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce); 储能损耗 is the energy consumption of energy storage, in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce); N 综合消耗 It is the total comprehensive energy consumption, measured in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce).

[0152] In addition to the above three key secondary indicators, the secondary indicators of clean energy power generation evaluation indicators also include the daily utilization hours of photovoltaic power generation (different typical days), annual utilization hours, the daily utilization hours of wind turbine power generation (different typical days), annual utilization hours, the power generation efficiency of rooftop photovoltaics and photovoltaic carports in different time periods, wind speed, wind direction, and wind density in different time periods in the region, the power generation efficiency of wind turbines in different time periods, the photovoltaic power generation absorption rate or power abandonment rate on different typical days, the wind turbine power generation absorption rate or wind abandonment rate on different typical days, and the charging and discharging efficiency of energy storage devices.

[0153] The key secondary indicators of the terminal load power consumption indicators include the proportion of new energy vehicles, the proportion of two-way charging pile facilities and the proportion of DC power consumption in buildings; by setting up terminal load power consumption indicators, power supply stations can more accurately grasp the changing laws of power loads, thereby optimizing grid dispatch and operation. This helps to improve the efficiency of grid operation, reduce energy loss and reduce operating costs. In addition, terminal load power consumption indicators help promote the development of distributed power sources and clean energy. Smart grids can adjust the power generation plans of distributed power sources or clean energy according to the terminal load power consumption, and achieve compatible grid connection with large power grids. This not only expands the range of resource selection, but also improves the flexibility and reliability of grid operation. The specific key magnetic secondary indicators are as follows:

[0154] (1) Proportion of new energy vehicles

[0155] The proportion of new energy vehicles refers to the ratio of new energy vehicles in the power supply station to the total number of vehicles in the power supply station.

[0156]

[0157] Where: E 新能源汽车 Refers to the number of new energy vehicles in the power supply station, in units of vehicles; N 所内汽车 Refers to the total number of vehicles in the power supply station, in units of vehicles.

[0158] (2) Proportion of bidirectional charging pile facilities

[0159] The proportion of two-way charging pile facilities refers to the ratio of the number of charging piles in the power supply station to the number of new energy vehicles in the power supply station.

[0160]

[0161] Where: E 双向充电桩 is the number of charging piles, in units of vehicles; N 新能源车 It is the total number of new energy vehicles, in units.

[0162] (3) Proportion of DC power consumption in buildings

[0163] This indicator refers to the ratio of the total DC power consumption in the power supply station building to the total energy consumption of the building during the evaluation period.

[0164]

[0165] Where: E 直流用电 is the total electricity consumption of the building, in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce); N 建筑总能耗 It is the total energy consumption of the building, measured in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce).

[0166] In addition to the above-mentioned key secondary indicators, the secondary indicators of terminal load electricity consumption evaluation indicators also include the proportion of AC electricity consumption in buildings, the proportion of electricity consumption in accommodation, the CO2 emission intensity of terminal electricity consumption activities, peak load management, the utilization rate of smart meters, the effectiveness of power demand side management, and the coverage rate of the electricity consumption information collection system.

[0167] The key sub-indicators of the building system evaluation indicators include the proportion of green building materials used and the building energy saving rate; the establishment of building system indicators can ensure that the building part is coordinated with the overall zero-carbon goal and promote the low-carbon transformation of the energy structure. Building system indicators can comprehensively evaluate the energy consumption of buildings, including the clean energy supply, energy efficiency, etc., and provide data support for reducing energy consumption. Building system indicators require the selection of low-carbon, renewable and recycled materials, reduce energy consumption and carbon emissions in the production and transportation of materials, and promote the circular utilization of resources. The specific key sub-indicators are as follows:

[0168] (1) Proportion of green building materials used

[0169] The proportion of green building materials used is calculated by the ratio of the amount of green building materials used to the total amount of building materials used.

[0170]

[0171] Where: E 绿色建材 is the amount of green building materials used, in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce); N 所内总建材 It is the total amount of building materials used in the power supply station, in tons of standard coal equivalent (tce).

[0172] (2) Building energy saving rate

[0173] The building energy saving rate is usually expressed as the energy saving efficiency achieved after energy-saving measures are taken, expressed as a percentage.

[0174]

[0175] Where: E 基准能耗 It represents the baseline energy consumption of the power supply station, which refers to the energy consumption of the building without any energy-saving measures, and can be estimated based on the building design, equipment configuration and expected usage. 实际能耗 It indicates the actual energy consumption of the power supply station, which refers to the actual energy consumption of the building after adopting energy-saving measures, and usually needs to be measured through actual operating data.

[0176] In addition to the above two key secondary indicators, the secondary indicators of building system evaluation indicators also include indoor air quality, landscape maintenance, and energy consumption monitoring.

[0177] The key secondary indicators of the zero-carbon management and control platform indicators include carbon flow analysis and calculation, and green electricity trading balance calculation of zero-carbon power supply stations; the zero-carbon management and control platform evaluation indicators are helpful to establish a carbon emission management system and regulate the carbon emission behavior of power supply stations. Through real-time monitoring, data analysis, early warning reminders and other functions, abnormal carbon emissions can be discovered in time, and effective measures can be taken to correct them to ensure that the carbon emissions of power supply stations meet relevant standards and requirements. By encouraging and supporting the development and utilization of new energy, we will promote the low-carbon transformation of the energy structure of power supply stations, reduce dependence on traditional energy, and reduce carbon emissions. The specific key secondary indicators are as follows:

[0178] (1) Carbon flow analysis and calculation

[0179] Carbon flow analysis and calculation indicators include the carbon potential M of the upper grid 41 , the power M of the upper power grid 42 , the carbon flow rate of the node under the upper power grid M 43 , Network loss carbon flow rate monitoring M 44 .

[0180] For the AC and DC loads in the power supply station, the input active power and output node carbon potential, output carbon flow rate have the following relationship:

[0181] R=EP

[0182] Where: P represents the input active power of AC and DC loads in the power supply station, unit kW, E represents the carbon potential of the load output node, unit kgCO2 / kWh, and R represents the load output carbon flow rate, unit kgCO2 / h.

[0183] The carbon potential of the upper grid node, the amount of electricity under the upper grid, and the carbon flow rate of the electricity node under the upper grid also satisfy the above formula, that is, the carbon flow rate of the electricity node under the upper grid M 43 Equal to the carbon potential M of the upper grid node 41 The power M of the upper power grid 42 The product of .

[0184] Loss carbon flow rate M 44 The calculation of needs to consider the two-way sharing coefficient, that is, part of the loss is borne by the network (power supply line) and the other part is borne by the load.

[0185] (2) Calculation of green electricity trading balance of zero-carbon power supply station

[0186] The power supply cycle is a year-round cycle. To achieve zero carbon, the following relationship must be met: carbon emissions from electricity generated by the upper power grid - green electricity sold online M45 - green electricity purchased M46 ≤ 0. The green electricity sold online is the amount of electricity that is still left after wind and photovoltaic power generation meet the power supply needs of the microgrid, and is sent back to the upper power grid. It is equivalent to the green electricity sold online and can be used to offset the amount of green electricity purchased.

[0187] In addition to the above-mentioned key secondary indicators, the secondary indicators of the zero-carbon management and control platform evaluation indicators also include carbon emission factors of coal-fired power and nuclear power, construction of power supply station energy management platform, real-time monitoring and data collection capabilities, data security and privacy protection, etc.

[0188] The key secondary indicators of the carbon sink indicators include green coverage rate, purchasing certified voluntary emission reductions and other methods to offset carbon emissions; carbon sinks, as an effective carbon dioxide emission reduction measure, can increase the absorption and fixation of carbon dioxide through greening methods such as afforestation, forest management and vegetation restoration, thereby significantly reducing the concentration of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. Therefore, incorporating carbon sinks into the zero-carbon power supply indicator evaluation system will help to more accurately measure and evaluate the progress and effectiveness of power supplies in achieving carbon neutrality goals. The specific key secondary indicators are as follows:

[0189] (1) Green coverage rate

[0190] The green coverage rate refers to the ratio of the total area of ​​various green spaces within the power supply station to the total land area within the planning scope of the power supply station.

[0191]

[0192] Where: E 绿地Refers to the total area of ​​various green spaces within the power supply station, in square meters; N 所用地 Refers to the total area of ​​land used by the power supply station, measured in square meters.

[0193] (2) Offsetting carbon emissions by purchasing certified voluntary emission reductions

[0194] Certified Emission Reductions (CCERs) are greenhouse gas emission reductions that are quantitatively verified for the greenhouse gas emission reduction effects of specific projects within my country and registered in the National Greenhouse Gas Voluntary Emission Reduction Trading Registration System.

[0195] As a key emission unit, power supply stations generate a large amount of carbon dioxide emissions during their operation. By purchasing CCERs, power supply stations can offset part of their carbon emissions, thereby directly reducing their carbon emissions.

[0196] The key sub-indicators of the low-carbon atmosphere creation indicators include the reuse of electrical equipment and wastewater greening irrigation; the low-carbon atmosphere creation evaluation indicators can quantitatively evaluate the efforts and achievements of the power supply station in promoting the green and low-carbon concept. By setting specific evaluation indicators, such as the office power loss reduction rate and green plant coverage rate, the power supply station can be guided to take active measures to create a strong low-carbon cultural atmosphere, thereby enhancing the image and reputation of the power supply station in the society. The specific key sub-indicators are as follows.

[0197] 1. Reuse of electrical equipment materials

[0198] The recycling of electrical equipment materials refers to the ratio of the number of electrical equipment materials that have been recycled during the evaluation period to the number of all recycled materials.

[0199]

[0200] Among them, E 回收利用 Refers to the number of electrical equipment materials collected and used, in pieces; N 总回收 Refers to the quantity of all recycled materials in the power supply station, in pieces.

[0201] 2. Wastewater greening irrigation

[0202] Wastewater greening irrigation This indicator refers to the ratio of wastewater greening irrigation water consumption of the power supply station to the total wastewater volume during the evaluation period.

[0203]

[0204] Where: E 废水绿化灌溉 The water consumption of wastewater greening irrigation of power supply station, in cubic meters; N 总废水 The total amount of wastewater generated for the purpose of supplying electricity, in cubic metres.

[0205] In addition to the above-mentioned key secondary indicators, the secondary indicators of the low-carbon atmosphere creation evaluation index also include office digital management, low-carbon energy-saving publicity, and domestic sewage treatment.

[0206] The key secondary indicators of the safety management indicators include regular equipment maintenance; safety management is the foundation of the power industry and is directly related to the stable operation of power supply stations. The establishment of safety management indicators can ensure that power supply stations have a high degree of safety and reliability while pursuing zero carbon emissions. Through safety management indicators, unsafe factors and potential safety hazards in the operation of power supply stations can be discovered in a timely manner, so as to take corresponding preventive measures and emergency plans to ensure safe production. The main safety management indicators include emergency response, hazardous waste disposal, punishment for violations, network security monitoring, regular equipment maintenance, and no violation operation rate.

[0207] The key sub-indicators of the additional classification indicators include green building certification and carbon neutrality certification. As a positive incentive mechanism, the additional points indicators can encourage power supply stations to pursue higher energy efficiency, technological innovation and environmental performance on the basis of achieving zero carbon emission goals. By setting up bonus items, power supply stations will be more motivated to implement measures such as energy conservation and emission reduction, improve energy efficiency, and promote green technology innovation, thereby further promoting the realization of zero carbon goals. The additional points indicators include green building (two-star and above rating) certification, carbon neutrality certification, and energy saving investment payback period. Table 2 shows the key sub-indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator that were not screened out.

[0208] Table 2 Key sub-indicators of carbon assessment classification indicators

[0209]

[0210]

[0211] The method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station considering carbon flow analysis of the present invention obtains the output result of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network of the zero-carbon power supply station; obtains each carbon assessment classification index of the zero-carbon power supply according to the output result and the goal of the zero-carbon power supply station; weights each carbon assessment classification index by frequency statistics; integrates each weighted carbon assessment classification index to obtain a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station. The present invention combines carbon flow analysis with a multi-dimensional comprehensive evaluation to more comprehensively and accurately evaluate the zero-carbon level of the power supply station. At the same time, through carbon flow analysis, the flow and transformation process of carbon in the power supply station can be accurately tracked, thereby more accurately evaluating the carbon emissions of the power supply station, making the evaluation results more comparable and operational.

[0212] Those of ordinary skill in the art will appreciate that the units of each example described in conjunction with the embodiments disclosed herein can be implemented in electronic hardware, computer software, or a combination of the two. In order to clearly illustrate the interchangeability of hardware and software, the composition of each example has been generally described in terms of function in the above description. Whether these functions are performed in hardware or software depends on the specific application and design constraints of the technical solution. Professional and technical personnel can use different methods to implement the described functions for each specific application, but such implementation should not be considered to be beyond the scope of the present invention.

[0213] In the embodiments provided by the present invention, it should be understood that the division of units is only a logical function division, and there may be other division methods in actual implementation, for example, multiple units can be combined into one unit, one unit can be split into multiple units, or some features can be ignored, etc.

[0214] In addition, each functional unit in each embodiment of the present invention may be integrated into one processing unit, or each unit may exist physically separately, or two or more units may be integrated into one unit. The above-mentioned integrated unit may be implemented in the form of hardware or in the form of software functional units.

[0215] If the integrated unit is implemented in the form of a software functional unit and sold or used as an independent product, it can be stored in a computer-readable storage medium. Based on this understanding, the technical solution of the present invention, in essence, or the part that contributes to the prior art, or all or part of the technical solution can be embodied in the form of a software product, which is stored in a storage medium and includes several instructions for a computer device (which can be a personal computer, a server or a network device, etc.) to perform all or part of the steps of the method described in each embodiment of the present invention. The aforementioned storage medium includes: U disk, read-only memory (ROM, Read-0nlyMemory), random access memory (RAM, RandomAccessMemory), mobile hard disk, magnetic disk or optical disk, etc., which can store program code.

[0216] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention, rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or replace some or all of the technical features therein by equivalents. These modifications or replacements do not make the essence of the corresponding technical solutions deviate from the scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention, and they should all be included in the scope of the claims and specification of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for zero-carbon power supply stations considering carbon flow analysis. It is characterized in that include: Obtain the output results of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network of the zero-carbon power supply station; According to the output results and the goal of zero-carbon power supply, various carbon assessment classification indicators of zero-carbon power supply are obtained; Weights are assigned to each carbon assessment classification indicator through frequency statistics; The weighted carbon assessment classification indicators are integrated to obtain the carbon assessment classification indicator system of zero-carbon power supply stations.

2. According to the method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station taking into account carbon flow analysis as described in claim 1, It is characterized in that The output results of the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network of the zero-carbon power supply station include: Obtain the carbon flow rate data of each node, branch and unit calculated by the steady-state carbon flow model of the power network; The carbon flow rate data of each node, branch and unit are analyzed to obtain the main sources of carbon emissions, distribution characteristics and change trends over time.

3. According to claim 2, a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station taking into account carbon flow analysis, It is characterized in that The various carbon assessment classification indicators for zero-carbon power supply include clean energy power generation indicators, terminal load power consumption indicators, system evaluation indicators, zero-carbon management and control platform indicators, carbon sink indicators, low-carbon atmosphere creation indicators, safety management indicators, and additional classification indicators.

4. According to claim 3, a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station taking into account carbon flow analysis, It is characterized in that The weighting of each carbon assessment classification indicator by frequency statistics method includes: Obtain key sub-indicators for each carbon assessment classification indicator; The key secondary indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator are weighted through frequency statistics to obtain the weighted carbon assessment classification indicators.

5. According to claim 4, a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station taking into account carbon flow analysis, It is characterized in that The key evaluation indicators for obtaining each carbon assessment classification indicator include: The key secondary indicators were screened out from each carbon assessment classification indicator through the expert trust communication-decision laboratory analysis method. The screening results are as follows: The key sub-indicators of the clean energy power generation indicators include the proportion of photovoltaic power generation, the proportion of wind power generation and the proportion of energy storage; the key sub-indicators of the terminal load power consumption indicators include the proportion of new energy vehicles, the proportion of two-way charging pile facilities and the proportion of DC power consumption in buildings; The key sub-indicators of the building system evaluation indicators include the proportion of green building materials used and the building energy saving rate; The key sub-indicators of the zero-carbon management and control platform indicators include carbon flow analysis and calculation, and green electricity trading balance calculation of zero-carbon power supply stations; the key sub-indicators of the carbon sink indicators include green coverage rate, purchase of certified voluntary emission reductions and other methods to offset carbon emissions; the key sub-indicators of the low-carbon atmosphere creation indicators include electrical equipment material reuse and wastewater greening irrigation; The key sub-indicators of the safety management indicators include regular equipment maintenance; The key sub-indicators of the additional classification indicators include green building certification and carbon neutral certification.

6. According to claim 5, a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station taking into account carbon flow analysis, It is characterized in that The key secondary indicators selected from each carbon assessment classification indicator through the expert trust diffusion-decision laboratory analysis method include: Obtain scores from multiple experts for all sub-indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator under the preset impact degree scoring rules, and obtain multiple direct impact matrices corresponding to the number of experts based on the scoring results; Get the weighted results of multiple experts; Obtaining a comprehensive influence matrix according to the multiple direct influence matrices and the weight results; Through the calculation results of the comprehensive impact matrix, key secondary indicators are screened out from all secondary indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator.

7. According to claim 6, a method for constructing a carbon assessment classification index system for a zero-carbon power supply station taking into account carbon flow analysis, It is characterized in that The key secondary indicators selected from all secondary indicators of each carbon assessment classification indicator through the calculation results of the comprehensive impact matrix include: By comparing the calculation result of the comprehensive impact matrix with the preset impact factor threshold, when the calculation result of the secondary indicator is greater than the impact factor threshold, it is screened as a key secondary indicator, otherwise it is a non-key secondary indicator.

Citation Information

Cited By

  • Dynamic multi-level evaluation system

    CN121303969A