A method for evaluating impact damage repair solutions for composite honeycomb sandwich panels
The damage repair solution of composite honeycomb sandwich panels is evaluated through finite element simulation method, which solves the problem of high cost and low efficiency in the prior art, and achieves rapid and accurate repair solution evaluation and verification.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202211197733.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-09-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-09-29
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is costly and inefficient and requires a lot of tests when evaluating and formulating impact damage repair plans for composite honeycomb sandwich structures.
The finite element simulation method is used to establish a geometric model of three working conditions: integrity, damage and repair of honeycomb sandwich plates, define the material constitutive relationship between skin, glue layer and honeycomb sandwich, and perform Buckle analysis and Dynamic explicit dynamic analysis. Evaluate the structural strength and damage mode of the repair plan.
Through the finite element method analysis, the test cost is reduced, the repair plan is improved, and the repair plan of the honeycomb sandwich plate can be quickly evaluated and verified on high-performance computers.
Smart Images

Figure CN115544833B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to a method for evaluating a repair plan for impact damage of a composite honeycomb sandwich panel, and belongs to the technical field of composite material structure repair. Background Art
[0002] Composite honeycomb sandwich structures are widely used in civil aircraft structures due to their high specific stiffness, high specific strength, excellent vibration damping and fatigue resistance. The composite honeycomb sandwich structures of civil aircraft in service are susceptible to impact damage caused by various low-speed impact loads, posing serious safety hazards to the aircraft. In order to ensure the safe operation of civil aircraft, it is particularly important to formulate a reasonable repair plan for impact damage of composite honeycomb sandwich structures. In engineering practice, the evaluation of repair plans for composite honeycomb sandwich panel structures of civil aircraft requires a large number of tests, which is costly and inefficient. Summary of the invention
[0003] The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is: in view of the defects of the prior art, a method for evaluating the repair plan for impact damage of composite honeycomb sandwich panels is proposed, and the repair plan is evaluated by finite element simulation to determine the appropriate repair plan, which can fully reduce the cost of experimental research and improve the efficiency of repair plan formulation.
[0004] The present invention adopts the following technical solutions to solve the above technical problems:
[0005] The present invention provides a method for evaluating a repair plan for impact damage of a composite honeycomb sandwich panel, and the specific steps include:
[0006] Step 1: Establish the finite element geometric model of the composite honeycomb sandwich panel under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired.
[0007] Step 2: Define the material constitutive relationship of the skin, glue layer and honeycomb core.
[0008] Step 3: Set the boundary conditions of the composite honeycomb sandwich panel model under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired, and apply displacement loads.
[0009] Step 4: Perform Buckle analysis on the composite honeycomb sandwich panel model under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired. Calculate the buckling load under each working condition. Extract the displacement of the first-order buckling mode and multiply it by the coefficient k. Apply it as the initial defect to the subsequent Dynamic explicit analysis. Calculate the compressive strength and failure mode of the honeycomb sandwich panel model under the three working conditions.
[0010] Step 5. Compare the load-displacement curves of the honeycomb sandwich panel model under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired. Obtain the strength comparison results of the honeycomb sandwich panel repair model with those of the intact and damaged models, and evaluate the honeycomb sandwich panel repair plan.
[0011] As a further preferred embodiment of the present invention, the specific implementation of step 1 is as follows:
[0012] In the finite element geometric model, the skin adopts continuous shell SC8R unit, the skin is composite material, the honeycomb core adopts solid unit C3D8R, the glue layer adopts cohesive interface element COH3D8, and the impact hammer adopts solid unit C3D8R.
[0013] As a further preferred embodiment of the present invention, the specific implementation of step 2 is as follows:
[0014] (1) The two-dimensional Hashin criterion progressive damage analysis method is used to analyze the material failure of the skin composite material layer, and the stiffness degradation method based on fracture energy is used to analyze the failure evolution process; the cohesive zone model and Quads criterion are used for the failure analysis of the adhesive layer, and the energy-based Benzeggagh-Kenane criterion is used to analyze the failure evolution process; the honeycomb core adopts the failure criterion of the honeycomb core under compression-shear coupling stress proposed by T. Besant. When the honeycomb core is damaged, regardless of the load, the overall elastic constant and other properties of the material are degraded, and the reduction factor is λ.
[0015] (2) The calculation method of equivalent stress and equivalent strain of skin failure is as follows:
[0016]
[0017] In the formula is the equivalent displacement when the stress in the constitutive model is equal to 0 (i.e., when the failure is complete), G C is the fracture energy. Equivalent displacement The characteristic length L of the unit in the finite element model C It is estimated that the characteristic length of a first-order surface element is the square root of the area, and the characteristic length of a first-order volume element is the cube root of the volume.
[0018]
[0019] (3) The calculation method of the initial failure and failure evolution of the honeycomb core is as follows:
[0020]
[0021] Where σ 33 , σ 13 , σ 23are the normal stress in the thickness T direction, the shear stress in the SL and WT directions (the L, T, and W directions represent the strip direction of the honeycomb, the core extension direction, and the direction perpendicular to the strip direction, respectively); X TT , S LT , S WT is the compression strength and shear strength of the honeycomb core in the corresponding direction. The value of the index n in this method is 2. When the honeycomb core is subjected to a compression-shear composite load, if F core When ≥1, it is judged that the honeycomb core is damaged.
[0022] When the honeycomb core is damaged, regardless of the load, the overall elastic constant and other properties of the material will degrade, with a reduction factor of λ, which is 0.01.
[0023] As a further preferred embodiment of the present invention, the specific implementation of step 4 is as follows:
[0024] The coefficient k of the initial defect is taken as one thousandth of the thickness of the honeycomb sandwich panel.
[0025] Compared with the prior art, the present invention adopts the above technical solution and has the following technical effects:
[0026] The strength assessment method for the impact damage repair structure of a composite honeycomb sandwich panel proposed in the present invention can analyze the compressive strength and failure mode of the composite honeycomb sandwich panel repair structure by the finite element method, and then evaluate the honeycomb sandwich panel repair plan and verify the repair plan. The method does not require a large number of engineering tests and can be implemented by a high-performance computer. The method can be used in conjunction with engineering tests to reduce test costs, improve test efficiency, and better evaluate and verify the repair plan of the honeycomb sandwich panel structure. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0027] Figure 1 It is a schematic flow chart of the method of the present invention;
[0028] Figure 2 Schematic diagram of the bilinear damage evolution model of the skin in the present invention;
[0029] Figure 3 It is a displacement-load curve diagram of the intact, impact-damaged and repaired structures of the honeycomb sandwich panel in the present invention;
[0030] Figure 4 It is a schematic diagram of the damage mode of the honeycomb sandwich panel after compression after impact in the present invention;
[0031] Figure 5 It is a schematic diagram of the damage mode of the repair structure compression of the honeycomb sandwich panel in the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0032] The technical solution of the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings:
[0033] It should be understood by those skilled in the art that unless otherwise defined, all terms (including technical and scientific terms) used herein have the same meaning as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art to which this invention belongs.
[0034] like Figure 1 As shown, a composite honeycomb sandwich panel impact damage repair scheme evaluation method proposed by the present invention comprises the following steps:
[0035] Step 1: Establish the finite element geometric model of the composite honeycomb sandwich panel under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired. The skin uses the continuous shell SC8R unit; the honeycomb sandwich uses the solid unit C3D8R; the adhesive layer uses the cohesive interface element COH3D8; and the impact hammer uses the solid unit C3D8R.
[0036] Step 2: Define the material constitutive relationship of the skin, glue layer and honeycomb core. The constitutive relationship is the relationship between the stress tensor and the strain tensor. The skin is a composite material. The two-dimensional Hashin criterion progressive damage analysis method is used to analyze its material failure, and the stiffness degradation method based on fracture energy is used to analyze its failure evolution process; for a specific damage state of the material, the solution method for the four independent damage state variables of fiber tensile damage, fiber compression damage, matrix tensile damage and matrix compression damage is as follows:
[0037]
[0038] In the formula, δ eq is the equivalent displacement corresponding to a certain failure mode; It is the equivalent displacement when a certain damage begins (that is, when a certain failure criterion is equal to 1).
[0039] This method uses Figure 2 The stress-(equivalent) displacement relationship shown in Figure 1 is used to describe the damage evolution law. It should be emphasized that the damage initiation displacement is not a constant material constant, but varies with the stress state of the material point. Different units may obtain different damage initiation displacement values. is the equivalent displacement when the stress in the constitutive model is equal to 0 (i.e., when the failure is complete), It can be calculated by the following expression:
[0040]
[0041] Equivalent displacement The characteristic length L of the unit in the finite element model CThe evaluation is as shown in expression (3), and the characteristic length of the first-order surface element is the square root of the area, and the characteristic length of the first-order solid element is the cube root of the volume. Under different failure modes of the material, the expressions of equivalent displacement and equivalent stress are also different.
[0042]
[0043] The cohesive zone model and Quads criterion were used to analyze the failure of the adhesive layer, and the energy-based Benzeggagh-Kenane criterion was used to analyze the failure evolution process.
[0044] The honeycomb core adopts the failure criterion of the honeycomb core under compression and shear coupling stress proposed by T. Besant, and the VUSDFLD subroutine is written. The calculation method of the initial failure and failure evolution of the honeycomb core is as follows:
[0045]
[0046] Where σ 33 , σ 13 , σ 23 are the normal stress in the thickness T direction, the shear stress in the SL and WT directions, and the L, T, and W directions represent the strip direction of the honeycomb, the core extension direction, and the direction perpendicular to the strip direction, respectively; X TT , S LT , S WT is the compression strength and shear strength of the honeycomb core in the corresponding direction. The value of the index n in this method is 2. When the honeycomb core is subjected to a compression-shear composite load, if F core When ≥1, the honeycomb core is judged to be damaged. Regardless of the load, the overall elastic constant and other properties of the material are degraded. The reduction coefficient is λ, and the value of λ is 0.01.
[0047] Step 3: Set the boundary conditions of the composite honeycomb sandwich panel model under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired, and apply displacement loads. One end of the honeycomb sandwich panel is an Encastre constraint, and the other end is a Coupling constraint with the reference point, retaining only the longitudinal degrees of freedom of the honeycomb sandwich panel.
[0048] Step 4: Perform Buckle analysis on the composite honeycomb sandwich panel model under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired. Calculate the buckling load under each working condition. Extract the displacement of the first-order buckling mode and multiply it by the coefficient k (k is one thousandth of the thickness of the honeycomb sandwich panel). Apply it as the initial defect to the subsequent Dynamic explicit analysis to calculate the compressive strength and failure mode of the honeycomb sandwich panel model under the three working conditions.
[0049] Step 5. Compare the load-displacement curves of the honeycomb sandwich panel model under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired. Obtain the strength comparison results of the honeycomb sandwich panel repair model with those of the intact and damaged models, and evaluate the honeycomb sandwich panel repair plan.
[0050] The following is a specific example to illustrate the honeycomb sandwich panel repair solution evaluation method of the present invention:
[0051] The size of the composite honeycomb sandwich panel is 380 mm × 150 mm, of which the skin thickness is 1 mm (the laying direction is [45° / -45° / 0° / 90° / 90° / 0° / -45° / 45°]), and the honeycomb sandwich thickness is 15 mm. Tests and repair scheme evaluation based on this method are carried out at the same time, such as Figure 3 to Figure 5 As shown, the compressive strength of the honeycomb sandwich panel repair structure can be restored to 97.7% of the intact structure, which is 50.4% higher than the compressive strength of the impact damaged structure; and the errors between the results of this method under the three working conditions and the test results are all within 10%, which meets the engineering requirements.
[0052] In summary, the present invention proposes a composite honeycomb sandwich panel impact damage repair scheme evaluation method, which does not require a large number of engineering tests and can be implemented by a high-performance computer. The method can be used in conjunction with engineering tests to reduce test costs, improve test efficiency, and better evaluate and verify the repair scheme of the honeycomb sandwich panel structure.
[0053] The above embodiments are only for illustrating the technical idea of the present invention, and cannot be used to limit the protection scope of the present invention. Any changes made on the basis of the technical solution in accordance with the technical idea proposed by the present invention shall fall within the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating impact damage repair solutions for composite honeycomb sandwich panels, characterized in that The method comprises the following steps: Step 1: Establish the finite element geometric model of the composite honeycomb sandwich panel under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired; Step 2: Define the material constitutive relationship of the skin, glue layer and honeycomb core; Step 3, respectively set the boundary conditions of the composite honeycomb sandwich panel model under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired, and apply displacement load; Step 4: Perform Buckle analysis under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired. Calculate the buckling load under each working condition. Extract the displacement of the first-order buckling mode in the buckling load and multiply it by the coefficient k. Apply it as the initial defect to the Dynamic explicit analysis. Calculate the compressive strength and failure mode of the honeycomb sandwich panel model under the three working conditions. Step 5. Compare the load-displacement curves of the honeycomb sandwich panel model under three working conditions: intact, impact damaged, and repaired. Obtain the strength comparison results of the honeycomb sandwich panel repair model with those of the intact and damaged models, and evaluate the honeycomb sandwich panel repair plan.
2. A composite honeycomb sandwich panel impact damage repair plan evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The finite element geometric model in step 1 includes a skin, a honeycomb sandwich layer, a glue layer and an impact hammer, and the impact hammer is used to impact the honeycomb sandwich panel; The skin is a composite material, the skin adopts the continuous shell SC8R unit, the honeycomb core adopts the solid unit C3D8R, the glue layer adopts the cohesive interface element COH3D8, and the impact hammer head adopts the solid unit C3D8R.
3. A composite honeycomb sandwich panel impact damage repair plan evaluation method as claimed in claim 2, characterized in that: In the step 2, the skin is analyzed for failure using the two-dimensional Hashin criterion progressive damage analysis method, and the failure evolution process is analyzed using the fracture energy-based stiffness degradation method; the glue layer is analyzed for failure using the cohesive zone model and the Quads criterion, and the failure evolution process is analyzed using the energy-based Benzeggagh-Kenane criterion; The honeycomb sandwich layer adopts the failure criterion of the honeycomb core under compression and shear coupling stress. When the honeycomb sandwich core is damaged, the reduction factor is λ.
4. A composite honeycomb sandwich panel impact damage repair plan evaluation method as claimed in claim 3, characterized in that: The calculation method of the skin failure equivalent stress and equivalent strain in step 2 is as follows: In the formula is the equivalent displacement when the stress in the constitutive model is equal to 0, G C is the fracture energy; equivalent displacement By considering the characteristic length L of the finite element C Evaluation, the characteristic length in a first-order surface element is the square root of the area, and the characteristic length in a first-order volume element is the cube root of the volume.
5. A composite honeycomb sandwich panel impact damage repair plan evaluation method as claimed in claim 4, characterized in that: The calculation method of the initial failure and failure evolution of the honeycomb core in step 2 is as follows: Where σ 33 , σ 13 , σ 23 are the normal stress in the thickness T direction, the shear stress in the SL and WT directions, L, T, and W represent the strip direction of the honeycomb, the core extension direction, and the direction perpendicular to the strip direction, respectively; X TT , S LT , S WT It is the compressive strength and shear strength of the honeycomb core in the corresponding direction.
6. A composite honeycomb sandwich panel impact damage repair plan evaluation method as claimed in claim 5, characterized in that: In step 2, the value of index n is 2. If F core When ≥1, it is judged that the honeycomb core is damaged.
7. A composite honeycomb sandwich panel impact damage repair plan evaluation method according to claim 6, characterized in that: In the step 2, after the honeycomb core is damaged, the reduction coefficient λ is set to 0.
01.
8. A composite honeycomb sandwich panel impact damage repair plan evaluation method as claimed in claim 7, characterized in that: The coefficient k in step 4 is one thousandth of the thickness of the honeycomb sandwich panel.
