Scale test method based on equivalent penetration fuse impulse
Through the shrinkage test method and Chen model based on impulse equivalent, combined with dimension analysis, the problem of harsh overload environment in the shrinkage test in the existing technology is solved, and the impulse equivalence and reliability of hard target fuze is achieved. , reduces the cost of testing and is suitable for warhead testing under different working conditions.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410832570.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-06-26
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
In the prior art, the equivalent model based on similar theories cannot accurately simulate the overload environment in which the hard target penetrates the fuse in the shrinkage test, resulting in the overload peak being several times that of the actual working conditions, affecting the fuse detonation control strategy and the assessment results of the component strength.
Using a shrinkage test method based on impulse equivalent, combined with dimension analysis and Chen model, the appropriate shrinkage bomb is selected, and numerical simulation verification is carried out to ensure that the impact felt by the shrinkage bomb and the prototype bomb during the invasion process. Control the overload peak within a reasonable range, keep the fuze structure unchanged, and conduct dynamic tests on the shooting range.
The equivalent of the fuze impulse in the shrinkage test is achieved, the test cost is reduced, the test reliability is improved, and the assessment results of the fuze reliability are ensured. It is suitable for warhead tests under different working conditions.
Smart Images

Figure CN119026309A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of projectile penetration, in particular to a scaled-down test design method based on penetration fuze impulse equivalence. Background Art
[0002] In modern warfare, the ever-strengthening protection measures for important military targets have put forward higher requirements on the destructive capability and combat mode of penetrating ammunition. As the core of penetrating ammunition, the hard target penetration fuze is responsible for the detonation control task during the penetration process, and it also faces the test of harsh dynamic mechanical environment. Therefore, the assessment of hard target penetration fuze is particularly important. However, the full-scale range penetration test is expensive and the test cycle is long. It is often difficult to directly use the full-scale warhead to conduct sufficient range dynamic tests. Therefore, the equivalent scale test has become an important method to assess the survivability, functional completeness and satisfaction of combat technical indicators of the fuze.
[0003] At present, an equivalent model is established based on similarity theory, that is, a scaled-down model is designed in the form of a dimensionless function given after dimensional analysis of the missile-target model, and the prototype missile is used to carry out relevant test experiments. As a result, the overload environment of the fuze is too harsh, and the overload peak value is often several times that of the actual working condition. The scaled-down test cannot achieve "equivalence", which directly affects the fuze initiation control strategy and component strength assessment results. Summary of the invention
[0004] In view of the above-mentioned technical difficulties, the present invention proposes a scaled-down test method based on impulse equivalence in combination with the residual velocity model and dimensional analysis, and carries out numerical simulation verification in combination with specific penetration tests, thereby providing a feasible solution for the scaled-down test of high-value ammunition penetration.
[0005] The technical solution adopted by the present invention is as follows:
[0006] A scaled-down test method based on penetration fuze impulse equivalence comprises the following steps:
[0007] Step 1: Select the appropriate scaled-down bomb according to the prototype bomb's fuze size, kilogram class, and numerical simulation results;
[0009] Step 2: Determine the target thickness and target plate strength based on dimensional analysis;
[0010] Step 3: Substitute the parameters into the Chen model to obtain the initial velocity of the projectile and determine the scaling scheme;
[0011] As a further improvement of the above technical solution: When the penetrating ammunition penetrates the target, the interaction time between the projectile and the target is extremely short, but the impact force is extremely large, and the impact force changes drastically in this short period of time. As an internal component, the impact force felt by the fuze is amplified several times through factors such as the projectile and fuze structural response. Its structural damage is also mainly caused by the cumulative effect of the impact force and time, that is, the impulse received by the fuze. During the warhead penetration process, the impulse felt by the fuze is calculated as follows:
[0012]
[0013] Therefore, when designing a scaled-down test, it is not necessary to know the force and speed at every moment. It is only necessary to know the cumulative effect of the force over the action time and its effect. Even if the scaled-down projectile and the full-size projectile penetrate the target, the impulse felt by the fuze in the projectile body is similar, so as to achieve the equivalent penetration environment. The total impulse received by the fuze during the scaled-down projectile penetrating the actual target is I m (m0, a0, t0), the total impulse I received by the test fuze during the penetration of the equivalent test target by a full-scale projectile p (m1, a1, t1) should be basically equivalent, that is,
[0014] I m / I p ≈1
[0015] At the same time, requirements should also be made for the overload peak value of the scaled-down bomb. If the overload peak value of the scaled-down bomb is too large, the reliability assessment of the fuze will be too strict, which will greatly increase the possibility of problems in its structural strength and other aspects, thus leading to erroneous conclusions. Therefore, the overload peak value of the scaled-down bomb penetration is a m The peak overload of the full-size projectile is a p The ratio should be controlled within a reasonable range, that is,
[0016] a m / a p ≈1.0~1.5
[0017] As a further improvement to the above technical solution: when selecting the scaled-down projectile, comprehensive consideration should be given to the relevant parameters of the prototype test. For example, the penetrating projectile has different requirements for the material properties of the projectile body under different working conditions. The scaled-down projectile should be made of approximately the same material as the prototype projectile to ensure that the projectile body does not crack, break or other engineering problems during the penetration process. This scaled-down method is applicable to prototype tests of large-sized warheads under complex working conditions.
[0018] As a further improvement of the above technical solution: directly select the appropriate standard bomb as the scaled-down bomb, no longer redesign the scaled-down bomb, and no need to consider the change of the bomb body mass and center of mass position after modifying the bomb body parameters. The fuze maintains its full size before and after scaling down, the overload peak value and pulse width of the scaled-down bomb fuze are more accurate, and the evaluation results of the fuze reliability are more credible.
[0019] As a further improvement of the above technical solution: Chen et al. proposed a three-stage model of "front pit area-tunnel area-shear impact area", and on this basis considered the influence of steel bars in the target plate on the penetration of the projectile, and changed the reinforcement ratio ρ s and the uniaxial tensile strength of the steel bar f s It is defined as a new dimensionless steel bar number Θ, and together with the impact function I, the projectile geometry function N, and the dimensionless thickness of the concrete target plate χ, they control the whole process of the rigid projectile penetrating the reinforced concrete target, forming an analytical model that penetrates the reinforced concrete target plate. The dimensionless steel bar number Θ and the dimensionless thickness of the concrete target plate χ can be expressed as
[0020]
[0021] χ=H / d
[0022] Where: s is the concrete reinforcement ratio, f s is the uniaxial tensile strength of the steel bar, f c is the compressive strength of concrete, α is the crater cone angle of the concrete target thickness, which is generally taken as 60°, H is the concrete target thickness, and d is the projectile diameter.
[0023] Then the dimensionless critical target thickness of concrete target is
[0024]
[0025] Where: S is the infinite lateral compressive strength of concrete f c The relevant empirical constant is k is the dimensionless pit depth, that is, k = 0.707 + h / d, and h is the length of the projectile head.
[0026] The thickness H of the conical plug when the projectile just penetrates the target plate BL for
[0027]
[0028] The limiting penetration velocity can be expressed as
[0029]
[0030] The residual speed can be expressed as
[0031] v r=v0-v BL χ≤χ c
[0032]
[0033] As a further improvement of the above technical solution: With the help of Chen model, the expression of its residual speed can be given as
[0034] v r =f(D,M,σ t ,H,v)
[0035] The above formula does not list all the projectile parameters that affect the residual velocity. Since this article directly selects the standard projectile as the scaled-down projectile, only one or two parameters are substituted for analysis. The influence of the remaining parameters is brought into the residual velocity formula for detailed calculation after dimensional analysis.
[0036] There are 6 variables in the above formula, including 1 dependent variable and 5 independent variables. The variable dimension power exponents are shown in the following table
[0037] Table 1 Dimensional exponentiation of variables
[0038]
[0039] There are three basic dimensions involved in this problem. Select the projectile mass M, projectile diameter D and initial incident velocity v as reference physical quantities, sort the above table, and we can get Table 2.
[0040] Table 2 Dimensional exponentiation of variables (after sorting)
[0041]
[0042] By performing row transformation on the above table, we can obtain Table 3.
[0043] Table 3 Dimensional exponentiation of variables (after row transformation)
[0044]
[0045] According to the properties of the Π theorem and dimensional analysis, three dimensionless quantities can be given:
[0046]
[0047] Therefore, the residual velocity can be expressed as a dimensionless function:
[0048]
[0049] Assume that the ratio of the diameter of the projectile in the scaled-down test to that in the prototype test is
[0050]
[0051] If satisfied
[0052]
[0053] There must be
[0054] (v r ) m =(v r ) p
[0055] That is, the residual speed after penetrating the target in the scaled-down test and the prototype test is the same. The similarity law of this problem is
[0056]
[0057] If the material of the target plate in the scaled model is the same as that in the prototype, then
[0058] γ σt =1
[0059] At this time, the scaled model and the prototype satisfy similar similarity laws and can be simplified as follows:
[0060]
[0061] The above formula shows that when the target material in the scaled model is the same or similar to that in the prototype, if the target thickness, projectile mass, and projectile velocity in the scaled model are consistent with those in the prototype, then the scaled model and the prototype meet the similarity condition. M =γ 3 The conditions cannot be strictly met. At the same time, the influence of some parameters is ignored during dimensional analysis. The scaled-down test designed strictly according to dimensional analysis will result in large errors, and the parameters need to be adjusted in combination with the residual velocity model in the future.
[0062] As a further improvement of the above technical solution: after numerical simulation of the prototype bullet, the appropriate standard bullet can be selected as the scaled-down bullet according to the equivalent principle and dimensional analysis results. However, the mass scaling coefficient obtained by dimensional analysis cannot be strictly satisfied in most cases, and some parameters are ignored during the analysis, such as the projectile head coefficient, which will also affect the residual velocity of the projectile. Therefore, the obtained scaling law is not accurate and has certain errors.
[0063] At this time, the target thickness or initial velocity can be used as the dependent variable, and the other determined parameters and the projectile velocity drop in the prototype test simulation results can be substituted into the residual velocity model (Chen model) for accurate calculation. If the target thickness is used as the dependent variable, that is, the initial velocity is scaled down according to the dimensional analysis results, the scaled projectile will face a large overload amplitude and a small pulse width, and the equivalence is poor. Therefore, considering the initial velocity as the dependent variable, the target thickness is scaled down according to the dimensional analysis results, and the corresponding initial velocity is substituted into the Chen model to obtain the corresponding initial velocity, the error can be controlled within a small range.
[0064] After all the scaling parameters are obtained, numerical simulation verification is carried out. If the simulation results meet the impulse equivalence principle, a dynamic test at the shooting range can be carried out for further verification. If the error is large, a simulation comparison model can be established based on the simulation situation to optimize parameters such as the initial velocity of the projectile and the target thickness to reduce the error until the scaling principle is met and the equivalent test plan is determined.
[0065] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following significant advantages:
[0066] (1) The method of establishing a traditional equivalent model based on similarity theory, that is, scaling down the target model to replace the prototype for relevant test, is only suitable for assessing the penetration performance of the projectile. Direct application to the fuze will result in an overload environment that is too harsh. The overload peak is often several times higher than the actual working condition, and the scaled-down test cannot achieve "equivalence". The present invention combines dimensional analysis and the Chen model to achieve the equivalence of the impulse felt by the fuze during the penetration process within the allowable error range.
[0067] (2) The present invention can directly select a suitable standard projectile as the scaled-down projectile without redesigning it. Instead, the target impact speed and target parameters can be re-determined. There is no need to consider whether the mass of the projectile, the center of mass position, etc. after modifying the projectile parameters meet the overall performance requirements of the test platform for flight attitude control, etc. The scaled-down test platform has a large selection, which can greatly reduce the test cost of the full-size projectile and improve the test reliability.
[0068] (3) The scale-down test method based on the equivalent impulse of the penetration fuze proposed in the present invention keeps the full size of the fuze unchanged before and after the scale-down, so that the overload peak value and pulse width of the scaled-down projectile fuze are more accurate, and the assessment result of the fuze reliability is also more credible.
[0069] (4) The scale-down test method based on penetration fuze impulse equivalence disclosed in the present invention is universal and applicable not only to the following embodiments, but also to scale-down tests of other kilogram-class warheads.
[0070] (5) The scaled-down test designed by the scaled-down test method disclosed in the present invention can not only complete the task of assessing the strength of the fuze and its internal components, but also verify the detonation control strategy, etc. due to its excellent equivalent ability to sense the impulse of the fuze during the penetration process. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0071] Figure 1 This is a comparison between the prototype and the scaled-down bomb.
[0072] Figure 2 The speed of the prototype projectile during the target penetration process is reduced.
[0073] Figure 3 This is the prototype fuze overload curve.
[0074] Figure 4 The speed reduction of the scaled-down projectile during the target penetration process designed by the present invention is
[0075] Figure 5 This is the overload curve of the scaled-down bomb fuze designed by the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0076] In order to deepen the understanding of the present invention, embodiments of the present invention are described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0077] The embodiment of the present invention is carried out with a scaled test design of a 500 kg warhead. Taking into account the test cost and the overall structural strength of the projectile, the 203 balanced gun test platform is selected for scaled test. Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram comparing the prototype and the scaled-down bomb. The figure shows the 1 / 4 models of the two bomb bodies, the prototype model on the top and the scaled-down model on the bottom. The size of the fuze carried in the scaled-down bomb is the same as that of the prototype bomb, which is a full-size fuze, meeting the reliability assessment requirements of the fuze and other missile-borne components in the prototype test to the greatest extent.
[0078] Attached Figure 2 The speed of the prototype projectile drops during the target penetration process. As can be seen from the figure, the speed drops from 900m / s to 377m / s, and the speed drops to 523m / s.
[0079] Attached Figure 3 This is the fuze overload curve when the prototype projectile penetrates reinforced concrete. It can be seen from the figure that the overload is the largest when the projectile first hits the target, which is 38,100 g, and after the projectile leaves the target, due to the factor of stress wave transmission, the fuze part continues to vibrate, and the pulse width is slightly larger than the speed time curve, which is 11ms.
[0080] Attached Figure 4 The speed reduction of the scaled projectile designed for the present invention during the penetration process. The projectile penetrated a 2.3m thick reinforced concrete target with an initial velocity of 730m / s, the penetration time was 5.6ms, the residual velocity after leaving the target was 227m / s, and the penetration speed was reduced by 503m / s. Compared with the prototype test, the speed reduction was 3.8%, and it can be considered that the impulse felt by the fuze during the penetration process was approximately equal;
[0081] Attached Figure 5 This is the overload curve of the scaled-down bomb fuze of the method of the present invention. The maximum overload of the scaled-down bomb fuze is 53,000 g, which is 40% higher than that of the prototype test and meets the equivalent principle. This shows that the method of the present invention can effectively evaluate the reliability of the fuze.
Claims
1. A scaled-down test method based on penetration fuze impulse equivalence, characterized in that: The steps include: Step 1: Select the appropriate scaled-down bomb according to the prototype bomb's fuze size, kilogram class, and numerical simulation results; Step 2: Determine the target thickness and target plate strength based on dimensional analysis; Step 3: Substitute the parameters into the Chen model to obtain the initial velocity of the projectile and determine the scaling scheme.
2. The scaled-down test method based on penetration fuze overload equivalence according to claim 1 is characterized in that: During the warhead penetration process, the impulse felt by the fuze is calculated as follows: The total impulse received by the fuze during the process of the scaled-down projectile penetrating the actual target is I m (m0, a0, t0), the total impulse I received by the test fuze during the penetration of the equivalent test target by a full-scale projectile p (m1, a1, t1) should be basically equivalent, that is, I m / I p ≈1 Peak value of penetration overload of scaled-down projectile a m The peak overload of the full-size projectile is a p The ratio should be controlled within a reasonable range, that is, a m / a p ≈1.0~1.5。 3. The scaled-down test method based on penetration fuze overload equivalence according to claim 1 is characterized in that: Before selecting a scaled-down bomb, numerical simulation of the prototype bomb should be carried out to preliminarily determine the overload peak and pulse width of the full-scale fuze.
4. The scaled-down test method based on penetration fuze overload equivalence according to claim 1 is characterized in that: Chen et al. proposed a three-stage model of "front pit area-tunnel area-shear impact area", and on this basis considered the influence of steel bars in the target plate on the penetration of the projectile, and changed the reinforcement ratio ρ s and the uniaxial tensile strength of the steel bar f s It is defined as a new dimensionless steel bar number Θ, and together with the impact function I, the projectile geometry function N, and the dimensionless thickness of the concrete target plate χ, they control the whole process of the rigid projectile penetrating the reinforced concrete target, forming an analytical model that penetrates the reinforced concrete target plate. The dimensionless steel bar number Θ and the dimensionless thickness of the concrete target plate χ can be expressed as χ=H / d Where: ρ s is the concrete reinforcement ratio, f s is the uniaxial tensile strength of the steel bar, f c is the compressive strength of concrete, α is the crater cone angle of the concrete target thickness, which is generally taken as 60°, H is the concrete target thickness, and d is the projectile diameter. Then the dimensionless critical target thickness of concrete target is Where: S is the infinite lateral compressive strength of concrete f c The relevant empirical constant is S = 82.6f c -0.544 , k is the dimensionless pit depth, that is, k = 0.707 + h / d, and h is the length of the projectile head. The thickness H of the conical plug when the projectile just penetrates the target plate BL for The limiting penetration velocity can be expressed as The residual speed can be expressed as v r =v0-v BL χ≤χ c 5. The scaled-down test method based on penetration fuze overload equivalence according to claim 1 is characterized in that: With the help of Chen model, the expression of its residual velocity can be given as v r =f(D,M,σ t ,H,v) The above formula does not list all the projectile parameters that affect the residual velocity, because this method directly selects the standard projectile as the scaled-down projectile and only substitutes one or two parameters for analysis. The influence of the remaining parameters is brought into the residual velocity formula for detailed calculation after dimensional analysis. There are 6 variables in the above formula, including 1 dependent variable v r and 5 independent variables D, M, σ t , H, v, the variable dimension power exponents are shown in the following table There are three basic dimensions involved in this problem. The projectile mass M, projectile diameter D and initial incident velocity v are selected as reference physical quantities. According to the Π theorem and the properties of dimensional analysis, three dimensionless quantities can be given: Therefore, the residual velocity can be expressed as a dimensionless function: Assume that the ratio of the diameter of the projectile in the scaled-down test to that in the prototype test is If satisfied There must be (v r ) m =(v r ) p That is, the residual speed after penetrating the target in the scaled-down test and the prototype test is the same. The similarity law of this problem is If the material of the target plate in the scaled model is the same as that in the prototype, then c σt =1 At this time, the scaled model and the prototype satisfy similar similarity laws and can be simplified as follows: The above formula shows that when the target material in the scaled model is the same or similar to that in the prototype, if the target thickness, projectile mass, and projectile velocity in the scaled model are consistent with those in the prototype, then the scaled model and the prototype meet the similarity condition. M =γ 3 The conditions cannot be strictly met. At the same time, the influence of some parameters is ignored during dimensional analysis. The scaled-down test designed strictly according to dimensional analysis will result in large errors, and the parameters need to be adjusted in combination with the residual velocity model in the future.
6. The scaled-down test method based on penetration fuze overload equivalence according to claim 1 is characterized in that: At this time, the target thickness or initial velocity can be used as the dependent variable, and the other determined parameters and the projectile velocity drop in the prototype test simulation results can be substituted into the residual velocity model (Chen model) for accurate calculation.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Ship cabin indoor explosion structure damage evaluation method based on equivalent scale model
CN104568613A
Anti-ship missile warhead explosion scaling model construction method
CN113742921A
Collision analysis method for delayed fuze ammunition and bounce type protection structure
CN114297860A
Scale test modeling method based on overload equivalence of penetration fuze
CN117494420A
Cited By
Mapping relation model and response prediction method for penetration ultrahigh overload environment
CN119720695A
A mapping relationship model and response prediction method for the penetration ultra-high overload environment
CN119720695B
Penetration effect prediction method based on dimensionless analysis and multi-task learning
CN120850827A
A penetration effect prediction method based on dimensionless analysis and multi-task learning
CN120850827B
