Process for producing glycolic acid
By carrying out a continuous flow process in a fixed bed reactor, using a supported metal hydrogenation catalyst, controlling the reaction conditions to achieve high conversion of oxalic acid and high selectivity of glycolic acid, the high temperature by-products of the oxalic acid conversion process in the prior art are solved. The problem of inapplicability of formation and batch processes provides an efficient method of producing glycolic acid.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202380026423.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-03-15
- Filing Date
- 2023-03-14
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-05
AI Technical Summary
In the prior art, the process of converting oxalic acid to glycolic acid has problems with oxalic acid decomposition and by-product formation under high temperature conditions, which makes it difficult to reach a high level of conversion and selectivity at the same time, and the batch process is not suitable for industrial applications.
The hydrogenation reaction of oxalic acid is carried out in a fixed bed reactor using a continuous flow process. The supported metal-containing hydrogenation catalyst is used, and the temperature is controlled at 40-85°C, the hydrogen pressure is 10-150 bar, and the residence time is 5 minutes-1 hour to ensure that The conversion rate of oxalic acid and selectivity of glycolic acid reached 80% or above.
High conversion of oxalic acid and high selectivity of glycolic acid are achieved under lower temperatures and short-term conditions, providing an industrially feasible method for efficient production of glycolic acid, avoiding the problems of energy consumption and high cost of batch processes.
Smart Images

Figure CN118900834A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a process for producing glycolic acid, said process comprising the hydrogenation of oxalic acid. Background Art
[0002] In light of climate change concerns, many initiatives are being developed to reduce the amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. There is a growing interest in capturing CO2, which is mainly captured from large point sources such as chemical plants or power plants, industries with large CO2 emissions (e.g. steelmaking), natural gas processing, hydrogen production from fossil fuels, etc. After capture, the next step is CO2 storage (CCS) and / or CO2 utilization (CCU). The significant difference between storage and utilization is that CCS technology stores CO2 underground so that it cannot re-enter the atmosphere, while CCU technology converts CO2 into more valuable products such as plastics or biofuels. It is worth noting that while today's traditional fossil energy production can be replaced by net-zero emission methods (at least in theory), the production of materials like plastics or concrete is not the case. Therefore, the use of CO2 to produce materials is crucial to ensure a reduced impact on natural resources and is one of the few options to achieve negative emissions (provided that at least non-fossil CO2 and renewable energy are used).
[0003] For example, CO2 can be used to produce oxalic acid (HOOCCOOH), which in turn can be hydrogenated to produce, for example, glycolic acid (HOCH2COOH; GA) and ethylene glycol (HOCH2CH2OH; MEG), which are valuable chemicals for many different applications, such as in plastic production, and in the case of GA as a preservative in food processing and in cosmetics as a skin care agent.
[0004] However, although the hydrogenation of carboxylic acids is an important organic reaction for the synthesis of useful and valuable chemicals, it is a chemically difficult reaction due to the low reactivity and acidity of the carboxyl group. This requires rational catalyst design, for example. See: Tamura, M. et al., Recent Developments of Heterogeneous Catalysts for Hydrogenation of Carboxylic Acids to Their Corresponding Alcohols, Asian J. Org. Chem. 2020, 9(2), 126–143.
[0005] Therefore, the direct reduction of carboxylic acids requires harsh conditions. However, high temperatures cannot be used because oxalic acid begins to decompose above 130°C, producing CO2 and formate, and further producing methane under hydrogenation conditions. Therefore, there is little disclosure in the art about this particular reaction.
[0006] Santos et al. (Reaction Kinetics, Mechanism and Catalysis (2020) 131: 139-151) reported the catalytic hydrogenation of oxalic acid over a ruthenium-carbon catalyst. They studied the reduction of oxalic acid in a slurry reactor in the presence of a 5 wt% Ru / C microporous catalyst in an intermittent mode at a pressure of 80 bar, a temperature range of 120-150°C, and a continuous gas flow for 7 hours. They observed the formation of glycolic acid, acetic acid, ethylene glycol, and volatile compounds. The oxalic acid conversion rate reached more than 90%, and the highest operating selectivities for glycolic acid, ethylene glycol, and volatile products were 63% (120°C), 16% (130°C), and 87% (150°C), respectively.
[0007] WO2017134139 discloses a method for preparing glycolic acid and / or ethylene glycol, the method comprising at least the following steps: (a) providing an aqueous material stream containing oxalic acid, the water / oxalic acid molar ratio being greater than 5.0; (b) hydrogenating the aqueous material stream containing oxalic acid provided in step (a) in the presence of a hydrogenation metal catalyst and hydrogen to obtain a material stream containing glycolic acid; and (c) optionally, hydrogenating the material stream containing glycolic acid obtained in step (b) in the presence of a hydrogenation metal catalyst and hydrogen to obtain a material stream containing ethylene glycol (HOCH2CH2OH). All embodiments of WO2017134139 are carried out in batch mode. According to the report of WO2017134139 in the batch process, after reacting for 4 hours at 100°C and 100-120 bar H2 pressure, the highest selectivity of the generated glycolic acid is 76%, and the oxalic acid conversion rate is 80%.
[0008] It can be seen from the Santos publication and WO2017134139 respectively that at a relatively high temperature (120°C) and a running time of 7 hours, the conversion of oxalic acid is relatively high (91%), but this is at the expense of the selectivity for glycolic acid (only 63%); while at a lower temperature (100°C) and a reaction time of 4 hours, the selectivity for glycolic acid is higher (76%), but the conversion of oxalic acid decreases (80%).
[0009] There remains a need for a process for converting oxalic acid to glycolic acid characterized by high conversion of the oxalic acid starting material and high yield of the desired glycolic acid product. Notably, the 4-7 hour residence time system used in the Santos process is not practical. It would be particularly advantageous to provide an industrially applicable continuous process for hydrogenating oxalic acid to selectively produce glycolic acid. Summary of the invention
[0010] Therefore, the present invention provides a method for producing glycolic acid, the method comprising subjecting an aqueous oxalic acid solution to a hydrogenation reaction in the presence of hydrogen gas and a metal-containing hydrogenation catalyst,
[0011] wherein the method is a continuous flow process in a fixed bed; and
[0012] wherein the aqueous oxalic acid solution does not contain potassium; and
[0013] wherein the oxalic acid aqueous solution and the hydrogen gas flow are fed into a fixed bed reactor, and the oxalic acid aqueous solution in the feed has an oxalic acid concentration of up to 100% saturation at the feed temperature; and
[0014] wherein the reactor comprises a hydrogenation catalyst bed, the catalyst being a supported metal-containing hydrogenation catalyst having a total metal loading of greater than or equal to 2.0 wt % and less than or equal to 20.0 wt %; and
[0015] wherein the hydrogenation reaction is carried out at a temperature selected from the range of greater than or equal to 40° C. and less than or equal to 85° C., a hydrogen pressure selected from the range of greater than or equal to 10 bar H2 and less than or equal to 150 bar H2, and a residence time selected from the range of greater than or equal to 5 minutes and less than or equal to 1 hour;
[0016] Thus, glycolic acid is produced with a high selectivity of 80% and above, and the conversion rate of oxalic acid is 80% to 100%.
[0017] Contrary to expectations, high conversion of oxalic acid and high selectivity to glycolic acid were found in the continuous flow process of the present application at temperatures significantly lower than the reaction temperatures of the prior art processes and at shorter reaction times / residence times (commercially attractive time ranges).
[0018] Advantageously, this new process provides an opportunity for efficient industrial production of glycolic acid from oxalic acid. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0019] The present invention relates to a continuous flow process for producing glycolic acid from oxalic acid. In contrast to batch processes, continuous flow means that the process can be run uninterruptedly and does not require frequent feeding. To date, there are only a few prior art publications related to the production of glycolic acid from oxalic acid, and these publications only describe methods in batch mode. "Batch process" refers to a process involving a series of steps performed in a specific order, and the process has a start and an end. The continuous flow process of the present invention refers to a process defined by the flow of reactants and products (for each step), wherein the process runs for a longer time while continuously feeding in fresh reactants and continuously removing products. Batch processing generally requires more energy, is more expensive, and takes longer, but it is generally considered to be the safest and most manageable method for processing certain compounds. Although continuous processing is efficient and cost-effective, it is not always suitable for any chemical reaction.
[0020] The continuous flow process of the present disclosure is carried out in a fixed bed reactor (also referred to as a packed bed reactor), which can be any fixed bed reactor known in the art, including, for example, a reactor as a single cylindrical tube, but can also be a multi-tubular reactor, in which a suitable catalyst is properly filled / loaded. The catalyst bed is generally in the form of pellets, which are placed in such a way that they do not move relative to the reactor itself. Reactants including reactant gases flow evenly through the fixed catalyst bed. A preferred type of fixed bed reactor for implementing the method of the present invention is a trickle bed reactor. A trickle bed reactor includes a series of reactors in which gas phase reactants react with liquid phase reactants while flowing through a bed of solid catalyst particles in a downward direction (toward the direction of gravity). Depending on the type of application, the gas phase flow can be in an upward or downward direction. Preferably, in the method described in the present invention, the gas phase reactants (hydrogen) and the liquid phase reactants (aqueous oxalic acid solution) flow downward together.
[0021] According to the method, an aqueous oxalic acid solution free of potassium and a stream of hydrogen are fed into a fixed bed reactor, the aqueous oxalic acid solution in the feed having an oxalic acid concentration of up to 100% saturation at the feed temperature. The term "saturation" as used herein relates to the solubility of oxalic acid in aqueous solution, i.e. it defines the degree of solubility of oxalic acid at a given temperature compared to the maximum possible degree of solubility. An aqueous oxalic acid solution with 100% saturation means that the maximum amount of oxalic acid is dissolved at this temperature. Examples of aqueous oxalic acid solutions with 100% saturation at different temperatures: 46.9 g / L (5°C), 57.2 g / L (10°C), 75.5 g / L (15°C), 95.5 g / L (20°C), 118 g / L (25°C), 139 g / L (30°C), 178 g / L (35°C), 217 g / L (40°C), 261 g / L (45°C), 315 g / L (50°C), 376 g / L (55°C), 426 g / L (60°C), 548 g / L (65°C) (see the Wikipedia page on oxalic acid: Reference A: Apelblat et al. (1987), The Journal of Chemical Thermodynamics, Vol. 19, No. 3, pp. 317-320). Suitably, a high concentration of oxalic acid is used, preferably at least 80% aqueous oxalic acid, however more preferably the concentration is as high as possible at the feed temperature, ie most preferably an aqueous oxalic acid solution having 100% saturation.
[0022] In terms of weight percentage, the aqueous oxalic acid solution preferably contains oxalic acid equal to or higher than 1.0 wt % and equal to or lower than 40 wt %, preferably equal to or higher than 2.5 wt %, more preferably equal to or higher than 5.0 wt % and equal to or lower than 20 wt %.
[0023] The selected temperature of the aqueous oxalic acid solution in the feed ("feed temperature") is generally the same temperature at which the hydrogenation reaction is carried out.
[0024] In order to increase the solubility of oxalic acid in water, certain additives such as alcohols, ethers, etc., which are inert under the reaction environment, can be used in the aqueous solution of oxalic acid. Therefore, the presence of such additives in the aqueous solution has an effect on the saturation, which means that, for example, a 100% saturated solution contains more oxalic acid per liter than in the absence of those additives.
[0025] Suitably, the aqueous oxalic acid solution used as feed can be a recycle stream from a hydrogenation reaction or can comprise a recycle stream from a hydrogenation reaction. Therefore, the recycle stream can comprise one or more hydrogenation (by) products, such as glycolic acid, ethylene glycol, glyoxylic acid, acetic acid, etc. Preferably, the aqueous oxalic acid solution used as feed comprises a total of up to 20 wt % of such hydrogenation (by) products.
[0026] The aqueous oxalic acid solution used as feed does not contain potassium in any form. The presence of potassium is considered to be poisonous to the activity of the catalyst. The term "free of potassium" appropriately means that the amount of potassium in the aqueous oxalic acid solution is less than 0.9% by weight (9000 ppm), preferably less than 0.5% by weight, in particular less than 0.1% by weight.
[0027] Suitably, the catalyst in the fixed bed is a supported metal-containing hydrogenation catalyst having a total metal loading of greater than or equal to 2.0 wt% and less than or equal to 20.0 wt%, preferably greater than or equal to 3.0 wt% and less than or equal to 15.0 wt%, more particularly less than or equal to 12.0 wt%.
[0028] The hydrogenation catalyst preferably contains one or more metals selected from the group A metals: platinum, nickel, copper, ruthenium, rhodium and iridium, preferably ruthenium. Further, the hydrogenation catalyst optionally contains one other metal selected from the group B metals: tin, bismuth, palladium, rhenium, gold and antimony. Preferably, the hydrogenation catalyst contains ruthenium (group A metal), and preferably contains one group B metal.
[0029] Highly preferred hydrogenation catalysts comprise ruthenium and tin. Such ruthenium-tin catalysts can be advantageously used to suppress by-product formation, for example, over-reduction products such as acetic acid and ethylene glycol at high oxalic acid conversions. The molar ratio of ruthenium to tin in the catalyst is 10:1 to 1:10, preferably 5:1 to 1:5, more preferably 5:2 to 1:4.
[0030] A more preferred catalyst used in the process is a trimetallic catalyst containing ruthenium, platinum and tin. See, for example, S. Taniguchi et al., Applied Catalysis A: General 397 (2011) 171-173. The amount and molar ratio of ruthenium and tin in the trimetallic catalyst are selected as described above. The amount of platinum is preferably 1 wt% to 5 wt%, more preferably 1.5 wt% to 3 wt%, relative to the catalyst support. A highly preferred catalyst for optimal production of glycolic acid from oxalic acid is Ru1Sn 0.85 Pt 0.2 / C, the catalyst having a metal loading of 5 wt% ruthenium, 5 wt% tin and 2 wt% platinum. When platinum is also present in the catalyst, the oxalic acid conversion rate increases.
[0031] Advantageously, chloride is absent from the catalyst used in the present process, which is believed to be important for the stability of the catalyst.
[0032] Preferably, the catalyst used in the process according to the present disclosure is calcined (pretreated) at a temperature selected from 200°C to 450°C before use.
[0033] The catalyst support can be selected from any support material that does not interfere with the current hydrogenation reaction. Preferably, the hydrogenation catalyst is supported on a support selected from carbon, silicon carbide, MAX phase (Ti2Al2C), TiO2 and ZrO2, more preferably carbon or MAX phase, most preferably carbon.
[0034] According to the present invention, very useful reaction conditions have been found for a continuous flow process for selectively producing glycolic acid at high oxalic acid conversion at relatively low temperatures. A glycolic acid selectivity of at least 80% can be obtained, in particular, at a glycolic acid conversion of at least 80% and up to and including 100%, at a temperature of 40°C or higher, preferably 50°C or higher, up to 85°C or lower, and within a commercially attractive time frame. In certain advantageous embodiments, the temperature is 60°C or higher, up to 85°C or lower.
[0035] The commercially attractive time range for the occurrence of this continuous flow process is represented by "residence time". The term "residence time" defines the average length of time that the molecules in the feed, or specifically the feed, are retained in the reactor interior, and the reactor interior refers to the interior of the part containing the catalyst bed in this article. According to the method of the present invention, it is necessary to be equal to or longer than 5 minutes and equal to or less than 2 hours. Preferably, the residence time is equal to or longer than 10 minutes and equal to or less than 1 hour. For the flow reactor suitable for the hydrogenation reaction of the present invention, the residence time can be changed by changing factors such as reactor volume, feed flow rate (flow rate of both oxalic acid solution and hydrogen), the length of the catalyst bed. Compared with the continuous flow process, in the batch process, the residence time is related to the reaction time, i.e., how long the container is kept at a specific temperature in the batch process.
[0036] According to the general chemical rules set by the Arrhenius equation, as a rule of thumb, the reaction rate approximately doubles (or halves) for every 10°C increase (or decrease). Taking the prior art of WO2017134139 as an example, after 4 hours of reaction at 100°C, the oxalic acid conversion rate was 80%, and the selectivity of the produced glycolic acid was 76%. These results show that reacting at a lower temperature will definitely lead to a decrease in conversion rate (the reaction time is also 4 hours). Since lowering the temperature by 10°C for reaction usually halves the reaction rate, according to the prior art intermittent process WO2017134139, the reaction at 50°C for the same reaction time is expected to be 2×2×2×2×2=32 times lower than the reaction rate at 100°C (5 times halved). In other words, the reaction carried out at 50°C in WO2017134139 only produced an estimated 2-3% conversion rate after 4 hours. Therefore, in order to achieve a conversion of 60% to 100% at 50°C, the batch process of WO2017134139 should be run for at least 80 to 200 hours, which is obviously not commercially attractive.
[0037] In the process of the present invention, it was found that increasing the feed rate did not affect the selectivity to glycolic acid. If the feed rate is very high, resulting in a very short residence time, only oxalic acid will not be fully converted, while glycolic acid is still selectively formed. Those skilled in the art will understand how to balance the feed rate and the most appropriate residence time at a specific temperature. At relatively high temperatures, a shorter residence time (and therefore a higher feed rate) is required to maximize the conversion of oxalic acid and the selectivity of glycolic acid. At higher temperatures (particularly above about 95°C), ethylene glycol may begin to form as a byproduct before oxalic acid is fully converted.
[0038] The process is carried out at a hydrogen pressure selected from the range of greater than or equal to 10 bar H2 and less than or equal to 150 bar H2, preferably in the range of 20 bar to 100 bar H2.
[0039] According to the present disclosure, the product stream of a continuous flow process can be continuously removed from the process and directly subjected to further processing if deemed necessary, and can also be (partially) recycled before separating the desired glycolic acid from solution.
[0040] Oxalic acid is a corrosive substance. Therefore, stainless steel reactors are not ideal for the present process. Therefore, advantageously, the hydrogenation reaction of the present process is carried out in a reactor having a non-metallic or inert liner (e.g., Teflon, glass, PVC, titanium or Hastelloy).
[0041] A suitable and advantageous manner of carrying out the process of the present invention comprises subjecting a potassium-free aqueous oxalic acid solution to a hydrogenation reaction in the presence of hydrogen and a metal-containing hydrogenation catalyst; wherein the process is a continuous flow process in a trickle Hastelloy reactor; wherein a 5-15% aqueous oxalic acid solution and a hydrogen stream are fed to the top of the reactor; wherein the reactor contains Ru1Sn 0.85 Pt 0.2 / C catalyst bed, the catalyst preferably contains ruthenium with a metal loading of 5 wt%, tin with 4.7 wt% and platinum with a metal loading of 2 wt%; wherein the hydrogenation reaction is carried out at a temperature selected from the range of greater than or equal to 50°C and less than or equal to 85°C, a hydrogen pressure selected from the range of greater than or equal to 50 bar H2 and less than or equal to 100 bar H2, and a residence time greater than or equal to 10 minutes and less than or equal to 45 minutes; thereby producing glycolic acid with a high selectivity of more than 90%, and the oxalic acid conversion rate is 90% to 100%.
[0042] BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0043] Figure 1 .QCS experimental results of RuSn (5 wt% / 5.9 wt) catalysts on different supports. Conversion (A), selectivity (B) and carbon balance (C) data were obtained by liquid chromatography (LC). Reaction conditions: temperature = 75°C, pressure = 80 bar, substrate = oxalic acid (5 wt%) in deionized water (2 mL), catalyst / support loading = 50 mg, reaction time = 2 hours, 4 hours and 6 hours, respectively.
[0044] Figure 2 .SFU experimental results of oxalic acid reduction at different temperatures. Conversion (A), selectivity (B) and carbon balance (C) data were obtained by liquid chromatography (LC). Reaction conditions: temperature = 50-120 °C, pressure = 60 bar, feed = aqueous solution of oxalic acid (5 wt%), feed flow rate = 0.1 mL min -1 (equivalent to 18 minutes of residence time under full liquid conditions), gas flow rate (H2) = 200 mL min -1 In this reaction, Ru1Sn 2.3 / C (calcined) was used as catalyst.
[0045] Figure 3 .100 h SFU experimental results of oxalic acid reduction produced by electrocatalytic CO2 reduction. Conversion (A), selectivity (B) and carbon balance (C) data were obtained by liquid chromatography (LC). Reaction conditions: temperature = 50 °C, pressure = 60 bar, feed = aqueous solution of oxalic acid (2.37 wt%), feed flow rate = 0.1 mL min -1 , Gas flow rate (H2) = 200 mL min -1The catalyst was 9.76 wt% Ru / C (0.5 wt% water; Johnson Matthey).
[0046] Figure 4 .100-hour SFU test results for commercial oxalic acid reduction. Conversion (A), selectivity (B) and carbon balance (C) data were obtained by liquid chromatography (LC). Reaction conditions: temperature = 50 °C, pressure = 60 bar, feed = aqueous solution of oxalic acid (2.37 wt%), feed flow rate = 0.1 mL min -1 , Gas flow rate (H2) = 200 mL min -1 The catalyst was 9.76 wt% Ru / C (0.5 wt% water; Johnson Matthey).
[0047] The following non-limiting examples further illustrate the present invention.
[0048] Example
[0049] List of abbreviations
[0050] AA = Acetic acid
[0051] EG = (mono)ethylene glycol
[0052] GA = glycolic acid
[0053] GlyA = glyoxylic acid
[0054] MEG = (mono)ethylene glycol
[0055] OA = Oxalic acid
[0056] QCS = Rapid Catalytic Screening
[0057] SFU = Single Flow Unit
[0058] experiment
[0059] Materials and reagents
[0060] Oxalic acid (C2H2O4) from Sigma-Aldrich Obtained, dried and stored in a dry environment. All water used in this work was filtered using a Millipore system.
[0061] All commercially available catalysts are listed in the table below and were purchased directly from the manufacturers. All catalysts were stored in a dry environment.
[0062]
[0063] Another catalyst used was 9.76 wt% ruthenium on carbon, supplied by Johnson Matthey (ID: 110005, batch M17160). The catalyst contained 0.5% water.
[0064] All catalyst support materials: carbon (NORIT SX 1G), Ti2Al2C (MAX phase), titanium dioxide (TiO2), aluminum oxide (γ-Al2O3) and zirconium oxide (ZrO2) were purchased from commercial suppliers (Sigma-Aldrich). ), dried and stored in a dry environment.
[0065] Catalyst reduction and preparation
[0066] The catalyst extrudates were crushed in a ceramic mortar and sieved to obtain a mesh size of 105-200 μm. The catalyst particles were transferred to a ceramic crucible and placed in a tube furnace for reduction. In the furnace, the particles were treated with a gas mixture (7% H2 in N2) at a flow rate of 100 mL min -1 The furnace temperature is 10℃ min -1 The temperature was then raised at a rate of 1.5 % to 300-450° C. The temperature was kept constant for 180 minutes. After the reduction process was complete, the temperature was slowly lowered and the 7% H2 / N2 mixture was purged with a stream of pure nitrogen.
[0067] Catalyst screening
[0068] We used the QCS reaction to compare the performance of using synthetic catalysts in the reduction of oxalic acid [using the Batchington reactor for rapid catalyst screening (QCS) developed by Avantium Technologies]. For these reactions, tantalum reactors were used instead of stainless steel reactors. These reactors were equipped with Teflon liners inserted into the reactors. The pre-reduced catalyst (see Catalyst Reduction and Preparation Section) (50±2.5 mg) was loaded into each reactor and then the reactor was stored for 16 hours. The reactor was closed from the top to prevent air leakage and oxidation of the catalyst during the reactor storage step. After 16 hours, stirring beans were added to each reactor. A 2 mL deionized water storage solution of oxalic acid (5 wt %) was transferred to each reactor using a Gilson Pipetman Concept (electric air displacement pipette). The septum was placed on each reactor. The reactor cover was connected in a "cross" tightening sequence starting from the middle. A torque wrench (5 Nm) was used to produce a uniform force distribution between the different screws. The reactor was purged 3 times with N2 (10 bar) and 3 times with H2 (10 bar), after which the reactor was placed under a H2 pressure of about 79 bar in a pressurizer. The temperature during the QCS was not actively measured, but an equilibrium process was performed before the experiment to determine the required settings during the reaction to maintain 75°C. A stirring speed of 800 rpm was used during the experiment. The reactor was taken out of the QCS device to stop the reaction and immediately cooled in an ice bath to stop the reaction from continuing. The QCS cover was removed by removing the screws in a "cross" pattern similar to that used in the initial connection sequence. When the cover was opened, gas could be heard escaping from the reactor. The catalyst was removed from the reaction mixture by transferring the liquid portion of the mixture via a syringe M-type filter, which prevented the transfer of solid particles.
[0069] Different supports (carbon, TiO2, ZrO2, Al2O3 and Ti3(Al 0.8 Sn 0.2 The Ru / Sn catalyst (5 wt% / 5.9 wt%, corresponding to a Ru:Sn molar ratio of 1:1) on the C2 MAX phase was prepared by wet impregnation. Before testing, the catalyst was reduced ex situ in a hydrogen atmosphere at 350-500°C.
[0070] QCS experiments were performed using ruthenium-tin (5 wt% / 5.9 wt%) catalysts on different supports. Conversion (A), selectivity (B) and carbon balance (C) data were obtained by liquid chromatography (LC). Reaction conditions: temperature = 75°C, pressure = 80 bar H2, substrate = oxalic acid (5 wt%) in deionized water (2 mL), catalyst / support loading = 50 mg (pre-reduced ex situ in H2 at 350°C for 3 h and in situ in H2 at 200°C for 2 h), stirring rate 800 rpm, reaction time = 2 h, 4 h and 6 h.
[0071] Figure 1 Results of QCS experiments on different supports after 2, 4 and 6 hours are shown. The percent conversion (A), product selectivity (B) and carbon balance (C) of the reactions were measured, wherein the amounts of EG, AA, GA, GlyA and OA were determined.
[0072] Single Flow Unit (SFU) Components
[0073] Flow chemistry experiments are performed in a trickle bed reactor system. The unit can be split into different subsections. The gas flows of nitrogen and hydrogen are controlled by 2 mass flow controllers (MFCs). The nitrogen MFC can reach a flow rate of 1000 mL min -1 , while the flow rate of hydrogen MFC can reach 200mL min -1 The pressure in the reactor is controlled by a pressure indicator, which applies pressure to the back pressure regulator located behind the reactor to adjust the pressure in the system. The feed section consists of a Jasco HPLC pump. The liquid feed flow rate range is 0.1 mL min -1 to 5mL min -1 , which is transferred to the reactor separately from the gas stream.
[0074] The reactor used for the experiments was a 30 cm long reaction tube with a diameter of 4.6 mm. The reactor volume of this reactor was 5 mL, of which 1.82 mL was within the isothermal region of the system, thus allowing for loading of the catalyst. For full liquid flow in plug flow mode, the maximum residence time of the system was 18 minutes with a liquid flow rate of 0.1 mL per minute. In trickle flow operation, the residence time was slightly shorter (less liquid was present in the reactor).
[0075] The system has room for 8 separate effluent sample bottles which collect the effluent that passes through the reactor and is directed to the sample bottles via the selector valve system. The sample bottles have 2 needles inserted into them, one input needle from the selector valve and one output needle for relieving pressure or overflowing the feed to a "purge" jerry can. The selector valve itself has 16 channels, 8 of which go to the sample bottles and 8 go to the "waste" jerry can through the manifold.
[0076] The system is equipped with a heating and stirring system for the feed solution, which can heat and stir the feed solution to form a more uniformly distributed feed solution.
[0077] Reactor material
[0078] Since oxalic acid is a good complexing agent, it may leach metals from reactor components or catalysts. To understand the leaching, we analyzed the reaction solution of a 25 wt% aqueous solution of OA at 65 °C in a Hastelloy reactor for 2 h using ICP-OES. We observed strong leaching of Cr, Fe, and Ni, but no leaching of Ru from the catalyst. To investigate the effect of these metals in solution, we added Cr, Fe, and Ni to the initial solution in three times the amounts found in the leaching experiments. We noticed that the initial reaction rate was suppressed by 10-15%. To prevent leaching, we tested non-metallic liners for the Hastelloy reactor and avoided any metal parts from contacting the reaction solution. We compared the performance of reactors with and without Teflon and glass liners and found better catalyst stability in the lined reactor. We performed six consecutive reactions using the same solvent to amplify potential leaching effects. For each of the six reactions, we added fresh reactant solution but kept the catalyst in the reactor. Teflon linings best preserve catalytic activity as shown by high overreduction to ethylene glycol. PPM levels of metal ions (Ni, Cr, Mo) from reactor corrosion may inhibit catalyst performance and only Teflon linings can provide adequate protection.
[0079] Reactor load
[0080] The single flow reaction used a 30 cm long stainless steel reactor. Before the present study was conducted on the reactor, an equilibrium experiment was conducted to determine the position of the isothermal zone between 9 cm and 20 cm from the bottom. The inner diameter of the reactor was 4.6 mm, equivalent to a reactor volume of 5 mL (or an isothermal zone of 1.82 mL). For each reactor load, the maximum volume (1.82 mL) of catalyst was used to fill the isothermal zone of the reactor. The catalyst was reduced ex situ in a hydrogen atmosphere at 350 ° C, filled into the reactor bed and pre-reduced in situ in a hydrogen atmosphere at 200 ° C in the flow reactor. The remainder of the reactor was filled with silicon carbide (SiC) and quartz wool layers.
[0081] Reactor connection
[0082] The stainless steel reactor is equipped with Swagelok fittings. The reactor is connected to the SFU using standard Swagelok connection procedures. Swagelok fittings were chosen for this connection because they can withstand high pressures while remaining leak-free.
[0083] analyze
[0084] Liquid chromatography was performed as follows. The stock solution was diluted to a concentration of 0.67 mg mL -1 The samples were prepared using an Agilent Technologies 1260 Infinity II. The concentrations of oxalic acid, glycolic acid, glyoxylic acid, acetic acid, and ethylene glycol were measured. To confirm the results by a second method, quantitative liquid phase infrared measurements were used in a random order. The results from both methods matched.
[0085] Example
[0086] The system used for these reactions was a trickle bed reactor system that could run indefinitely and automatically collect 8 samples per experiment without interruption. A Jasco HPLC pump formed the reactant feed stream, while a mass flow controller (MFC) controlled the gas (H2 or N2) flowing to the reactor. At the top of the reactor, the feed stream and the gas stream merged, resulting in a downward flow of liquid and a co-current flow of gas over the packed catalyst bed.
[0087] The effects of different reaction parameters such as reaction temperature (50-100 °C), hydrogen pressure (10-60 bar), hydrogen flow rate (50-200 mL min -1 ), liquid / gas ratio, residence time, equilibrium step, and inclusion / exclusion of a pre-reduction step and the corresponding temperature. For all experiments, the length and volume of the catalyst bed and the filling therein, as well as the OA concentration (5 wt % OA aqueous solution) were kept constant.
[0088] For each experiment, fresh catalyst was used.
[0089] Controlled experiment
[0090] (1) No Catalyst - Control experiments were performed to exclude any possible reaction of the trickle bed reactor with the reactant feed. These control experiments used a similar loaded reactor as described in the "Reactor Loading" section. For the control experiments, the catalyst in the isothermal zone of the system was replaced with silicon carbide. Different reactant feed flow rates (5 mL min -1 To 0.1mLmin -1 ).
[0091] Results: During these reactions, the observed conversion of oxalic acid to observable reaction products was close to zero. The marginal conversion observed was within the error of the analytical method. The liquid chromatography showed only oxalic acid. Therefore, in the absence of any catalyst, no conversion of oxalic acid occurred in the system used.
[0092] (2) No Hydrogen - The effect of the presence of hydrogen was studied. A reactor following the procedure described in the "Reactor Loading" section was used. For this experiment, a commercial catalyst provided by Johnson Mattey having the following properties (9.76 wt% Ru / C, 0.5 wt% moisture) was loaded into the isothermal zone of the reactor. Different nitrogen flow rates were studied instead of hydrogen flow. The reaction conditions during this experiment were similar to the actual experimental conditions for the production of glycolic acid described herein, with the only exception of nitrogen flow instead of hydrogen.
[0093] Results: Similar to the results of the control experiment without catalyst, this experiment produced no reaction product. The conversions were so low that they were within the error range of the LC analysis and no conclusions could be drawn from these data regarding any possible conversions.
[0094] It was concluded from the control experiments and preliminary experiments that the conversion of oxalic acid requires the presence of catalyst and pressurized hydrogen.
[0095] Note: Byproduct ethylene glycol originates from the reduction of glycolic acid, while acetic acid is formed directly from oxalic acid [as discussed, for example, by Santos et al. (Reaction Kinetics, Mechanism and Catalysis (2020) 131: 139-151)].
[0096] Example 1
[0097] We tested the catalyst Ru1Sn in a trickle bed reactor 2.3 / C (Ru:Sn molar ratio of 1:2.3, the most active in our experiments), which contains 5 wt% ruthenium and 13.7 wt% tin. We studied the catalyst performance in the temperature range of 50-120 °C. The conversion rate increased and reached 100% at 70 °C, and only glycolic acid ( Figure 2 , “Series 1”). By adding Sn to the catalyst, the formation of acetic acid (as previously observed with the Ru / C catalyst above 70 °C) as well as the overreduction of glycolic acid to ethylene glycol could be avoided. The glycolic acid yield was 100% in the 70–100 °C range. When we further increased the temperature to 120 °C, the catalyst was deactivated and the conversion dropped by 38%. Subsequently, for subsequent experiments with the used catalyst at, for example, 50 and 100 °C, it was found that the catalyst was already deactivated at temperatures above the applied high temperatures (see Figure 2 , "Series 2"). Furthermore, at 100°C, the catalyst deactivated at longer reaction times.
[0098] Comparative Example 2: Effects of Potassium
[0099] Since this work is part of the development of industrial processes from CO2 to chemicals or polymers, we tested the reaction with a real feed from an electrochemical acidification reactor, in which oxalic acid was produced from potassium oxalate. The only difference from the previously constructed conditions was the lower oxalic acid concentration in the water, 2.37 wt%. To demonstrate the stability of the process, we aimed for a reaction time of at least 100 h in a single uninterrupted reaction. Unfortunately, the conversion dropped sharply already after 16.5 h ( Figure 3 ).
[0100] Please understand this in conjunction with Example 3.
[0101] Example 3.
[0102] As mentioned above, we used the same catalyst as used in Comparative Example 2 for over 100 hours without much deactivation, so we attributed the cause to the real feed and tested it for contaminants. It turned out that not all potassium oxalate was converted to oxalic acid, and 9000 ppm of potassium remained in the feed, which is a known catalyst poison.
[0103] In order to be able to compare side by side with Comparative Example 2, we prepared a potassium-free solution with the same oxalic acid concentration, and its conversion rate stabilized at 88% conversion after 56 hours and remained constant for more than 100 hours ( Figure 4 ). The conversion can be increased by increasing the temperature, residence time or hydrogen pressure. The selectivity for glycolic acid is 94.5%, but [without Sn in the catalyst] the formation of acetic acid still reaches 5.5% (4.3 min, maximum 6.7%).
Claims
1. A method for producing glycolic acid, comprising subjecting an aqueous oxalic acid solution to a hydrogenation reaction in the presence of hydrogen gas and a metal-containing hydrogenation catalyst, in, The method is a continuous flow process in a fixed bed reactor; and wherein the aqueous oxalic acid solution does not contain potassium; and wherein the oxalic acid aqueous solution and the hydrogen gas flow are fed into a fixed bed reactor, and the oxalic acid aqueous solution in the feed has an oxalic acid concentration of up to 100% saturation at the feed temperature; and wherein the reactor comprises a hydrogenation catalyst bed, the catalyst being a supported metal-containing hydrogenation catalyst having a total metal loading of greater than or equal to 2.0 wt % and less than or equal to 20.0 wt %; and wherein the hydrogenation reaction is carried out at a temperature selected from the range of greater than or equal to 40° C. and less than or equal to 85° C., a hydrogen pressure selected from the range of greater than or equal to 10 bar H2 and less than or equal to 150 bar H2, and a residence time selected from the range of greater than or equal to 5 minutes and less than or equal to 1 hour; Thus, glycolic acid is produced with a high selectivity of 80% and above, and the conversion rate of oxalic acid is 80% to 100%.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein: The reactor is a trickle bed reactor.
3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein: The hydrogenation catalyst comprises one or more metals selected from Group A metals: platinum, nickel, copper, ruthenium, rhodium and iridium, and optionally another metal selected from Group B metals: tin, bismuth, palladium, rhenium, gold and antimony.
4. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein: The hydrogenation catalyst comprises ruthenium as the Group A metal and preferably contains a Group B metal.
5. The method of claim 4, wherein: The hydrogenation catalyst comprises ruthenium and tin.
6. The method of claim 5, wherein: The molar ratio of ruthenium to tin in the catalyst is 10:1 to 1:10, preferably 5:1 to 1:5, more preferably 5:2 to 1:
4.
7. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, wherein: The catalyst is a trimetallic catalyst containing ruthenium, platinum and tin.
8. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 7, wherein: The hydrogenation catalyst is supported on a carrier, and the carrier is selected from the group consisting of carbon, silicon carbide, MAX phase (Ti2Al2C), TiO2 and ZrO2, preferably carbon or MAX phase, most preferably carbon.
9. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 8, wherein: The hydrogenation reaction is carried out in a reactor having a non-metallic or inert lining, preferably selected from Teflon, glass, PVC, titanium and Hastelloy.
