Micro-grid flexible supply multi-period energy storage value evaluation method
By constructing a composite weight-TODIM-based energy storage flexibility adjustment utility evaluation model, the problem of insufficient energy storage technology planning and operation safety evaluation in microgrids is solved, and the utility analysis of energy storage technology in various scenarios is realized. Support the construction of efficient and clean new power systems.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411027539.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-30
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
In microgrids, the high investment cost and limited returns of energy storage technology, coupled with the fuzzy effect in different scenarios under the framework of the power market, complicates its wider application and safe planning and operation of energy storage technology. Sexual evaluation has not received enough attention and lacks in-depth comprehensive utilization analysis.
Provide a comprehensive evaluation model for energy storage flexibility adjustment utility based on composite weight-TODIM. By constructing a comprehensive evaluation index system for energy storage efficiency, considering decision makers' risk preferences, and evaluating the effectiveness of energy storage in energy storage performance, emission reduction and power system revenue increase Establish a utility evaluation model for flexible adjustment of energy storage in the power market during the construction of a new power system.
A comparative analysis of the utility of energy storage technology in various scenarios is realized, a comprehensive evaluation model for energy storage efficiency is provided, and a new power system construction is supported, which verifies the feasibility and effectiveness of the model.
Smart Images

Figure CN118917736A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of microgrids, and in particular relates to a method for evaluating the value of multi-period energy storage provided by a microgrid in a flexible manner. Background Art
[0002] With the advancement of distributed generation technology and the deepening of low-carbon transformation of energy structure, a high proportion of renewable energy has become an inevitable trend for future energy systems, especially microgrids. However, the volatility and uncertainty of renewable energy pose a major challenge to the safe and stable operation of power systems, and it is necessary to explore the flexible regulation of resources. Energy storage, as an important flexible resource, has technical diversity and multiple regulation capabilities and has been widely studied and applied. However, the high investment cost and limited returns of energy storage technology, coupled with its ambiguous utility in different scenarios under the current electricity market framework, complicate its wider application. Evaluating the flexibility value provided by existing energy storage technology is the first step to improve the application efficiency of energy storage technology, save resources and protect the environment. However, a comprehensive evaluation of the planning and operation safety of various energy storage technologies is still underway. It has not received enough attention, and the focus is mainly on how to efficiently and effectively plan and dispatch limited resources in microgrids; however, in the context of building efficient microgrids, in-depth analysis and research on the comprehensive utilization of energy storage technology is very lacking. The overall utility evaluation of energy storage can not only verify the effectiveness of the existing construction plan and provide constructive feedback for power system developers, energy storage investors and government agencies, but also conduct a longitudinal comparison of energy storage value at different stages of new power system construction, and promote coordinated planning and development among different units within the system; therefore, it is very necessary to provide a method for evaluating the value of multi-period energy storage for flexible supply of microgrids based on a composite weight-TODIM energy storage flexible adjustment utility evaluation model, which establishes a comprehensive evaluation index system for energy storage utility, considers the risk preferences of decision makers, and constructs a microgrid flexible supply multi-period energy storage value evaluation method. Summary of the invention
[0003] The purpose of the present invention is to overcome the shortcomings of the prior art and to provide a method for evaluating the value of multi-period energy storage for flexible supply of microgrids by establishing a comprehensive evaluation index system for energy storage utility, taking into account the risk preferences of decision makers, and constructing a composite weight-TODIM energy storage flexible adjustment utility evaluation model.
[0004] The object of the present invention is achieved by: a method for evaluating the value of multi-period energy storage for flexible supply of a microgrid, the method comprising the following steps:
[0005] Step 1: Comprehensively consider the effectiveness of energy storage in terms of energy storage performance, emission reduction and power system revenue increase, and build a comprehensive evaluation index system for the flexible adjustment of energy storage power stations in the power market;
[0006] Step 2: Establish a utility evaluation model for energy storage participating in the flexible adjustment of the electricity market during the construction of a new power system based on the composite weight framework of TODIM utility evaluation;
[0007] Step 3: Example analysis.
[0008] The evaluation index system constructed in step 1 is composed of three parts: energy storage utility, social welfare benefit and power system incremental revenue effect, and is further divided into ten secondary indicators.
[0009] The energy storage utility includes the system energy storage investment cost, system energy storage operation cost, cumulative energy storage, cumulative energy storage operation time and energy storage discharge times; ① System energy storage investment cost: When evaluating the utility of the energy storage system, it is hoped that the system can meet a large number of flexible adjustment needs at the lowest cost. The corresponding cost calculation model is as follows: Among them, C construction-in represents the total investment cost of energy storage throughout its entire life cycle; β1 and β2 represent the construction cost per unit rated power and rated energy storage capacity, respectively; They represent the rated power and rated capacity of the energy storage station respectively; x is the discount rate; T es The life of the energy storage station; ② System energy storage operation cost: The operation cost of energy storage is determined by the charging and discharging power and the unit operation price. In the formula, C om is the operation and maintenance cost of the energy storage station; β3 represents the unit operation cost of the energy storage unit; P dis (t), P cha (t) are the power generation power and charging power of the energy storage unit at time t; K es,dis (t), K es,cha (t) are the constraint variables of the energy storage operation state; ③ Accumulated storage capacity: The accumulated storage capacity reflects the total storage capacity during the flexible adjustment period, indicating the flexible adjustment capability of the energy storage, and its calculation method is: In the formula, is the total amount of electricity stored in the system in a given time period; η1 is the leakage coefficient of the system; ④ Cumulative operation time of energy storage: The cumulative operation time of energy storage refers to the total operation time of energy storage in the system, in hours, and the calculation formula is: ⑤ Energy storage discharge times: The number of charge and discharge cycles of energy storage reflects the participation of energy storage in flexible regulation, and further illustrates the contribution of energy storage to flexible regulation. The calculation method is:
[0010] The social welfare benefits include the effect of reducing carbon emissions, the absorption rate of renewable energy, and government subsidies and benefits; ① The effect of reducing carbon emissions: The calculation method is: ② Renewable energy absorption rate: The absorption rate of renewable energy can be used as one of the comprehensive evaluation indicators of energy storage application effectiveness. Its calculation method is: Among them, P res (t) represents the actual electricity generation from renewable energy sources; Represents the actual reduction in renewable energy; ③ Government subsidies and benefits: Use government electricity price subsidies to calculate the additional benefits of energy storage. The calculation formula is: Where P dis (t) represents the discharge power of the energy storage system at time t; C sub The government subsidizes electricity prices.
[0011] The incremental benefit effect of the power system includes the expected benefits of delaying equipment investment and peak load regulation and valley filling; ① Delaying equipment investment: Energy storage participates in the flexible adjustment of the power system, which can delay the investment in system equipment, and its benefit function is: F du =λ×δ×C distribution ×P est (9), where δ represents the fixed depreciation rate of the distribution network equipment; λ represents the charging and discharging efficiency of the energy storage system; C distribution Represents the unit capacity cost of power distribution equipment; P est is the rated power of the energy storage system; ② The expected benefits of peak load regulation and valley filling: Under the influence of time-of-use electricity prices, energy storage can be charged at low prices during peak hours to achieve peak load regulation and valley filling arbitrage. The calculation formula is: Among them, ρ t It is the time-of-use electricity price of the power system.
[0012] The composite weight framework based on TODIM utility evaluation in step 2 establishes a utility evaluation model for energy storage participating in the flexible adjustment of the power market during the construction of a new power system, which specifically includes the following steps:
[0013] Step 2.1: Weight combination method in energy storage utility evaluation;
[0014] Step 2.2: Use the energy storage utility evaluation method based on the TODIM method;
[0015] Step 2.3: Quantitative method of energy storage utility evaluation index;
[0016] Step 2.4: Establish an energy storage utility evaluation process based on multi-scenario system operation simulation;
[0017] Step 2.5: Analysis of error sources of comprehensive evaluation method.
[0018] The weight combination method in the energy storage utility evaluation in step 2.1 specifically includes the following steps:
[0019] Step 2.11: Construct the initial judgment matrix of the subjective weights of the indicators;
[0020] Step 2.12: Solve the judgment matrix of energy storage utility index by row geometric mean method: as shown below:
[0021] Step 2.13: Check the consistency of the energy storage utility evaluation index weight information: First, use the formula Determine the maximum eigenvalue of the energy storage utility evaluation index judgment matrix, and use the formula After a consistency check, the decision maker introduces the random index RI to further alleviate the problem of inconsistent correction factors caused by the matrix order. In the formula, λ max , n represent the maximum eigenvalue and order of the judgment matrix respectively; A represents the judgment matrix of the first-level indicators of level A;
[0022] Step 2.14: Use the entropy weight method to determine the objective weight of the evaluation index of the flexible regulation utility of energy storage in the construction of the new power system, set as the entropy e of the evaluation index i i The calculation formula is: If i is the weighted value w of entropy in evaluation index i i ∈[0,1], Then i The calculation formula is: g i =1-e i (18), where w i The characteristics of the value can further reveal the changing rules of the indicator value; in order to reasonably show the subjective preferences of decision makers and the objective attributes of decision criteria, the following formula is used to summarize the subjective and objective weights: com =α1×w sub +α2×w ob (19).
[0023] The energy storage utility evaluation method based on the TODIM method in step 2.2 is specifically as follows: first, the evaluation information is standardized: Secondly, calculate the relative importance of each indicator: Finally, the advantage function in the TODIM model is used to calculate the relative advantage of the evaluation object for energy storage utility under each indicator: The loss aversion coefficient θ represents the decision maker's attitude toward risk; finally, using the formula The advantages of all evaluation indicators of each alternative are summed up; where x pj represents the performance score of alternative p relative to criterion j; denote the best and worst performance scores among all alternatives for criterion j, respectively; w jris the weight of criterion j in the context of reference r; C refers to a set of criteria where alternative p is better than the reference; B refers to a set of criteria where alternative p is worse than the reference; Optional T p With reference T q The partial value function of criterion j during comparison; θ is the attenuation factor; d(x pj ,x qj ) represents the difference in performance scores between alternatives p and q for criterion j; δ(T p ,T q ) refers to the substitution of T in all standards q Relative to reference T q overall advantage.
[0024] The step 2.3: quantification method of energy storage utility evaluation index, specifically: construct the following system optimization model: maxf = F up-low +F sub -C carbon -C loss -C in -C con (25),
[0025] Among them, F up-low represents the expected benefits of peak load regulation and valley filling; F sub represents government subsidy income, C carbon , C loss , C in , C con They represent carbon emission cost, wind and solar power abandonment cost, total energy storage investment cost and traditional energy operation cost respectively; c i is the unit carbon emission cost of the i-th type of traditional energy; P con,i (t) represents the power generation of the i-th traditional energy at time t; η w , η s are the cost coefficients of each unit of abandoned wind and solar energy; P w,loss (t), P s,loss (t) are the total amount of wind and solar energy abandoned at time t; P con,fuel is the unit fuel cost of traditional energy; Q con,i,t is the consumption of the i-th traditional energy at time t; C con represents unit variable operating cost; stk es,dis (t)+k es,cha (t)≤1(29), SOC min ≤SOC(t)≤SOC max (31), k es,dis (t)×Pdis,t,min ≤P dis,t ≤k es,dis (t)×P dis,t,max (32), k es,cha (t)×P cha,t,min ≤P cha,t ≤k es,cha (t)×P cha,t,max (33), Among them, k es,dis (t), k es,cha (t) respectively represent the discharge state and charge state variables of the energy storage at time t; SOC(t) represents the percentage of the energy storage system in the charge state; π is the energy storage self-discharge rate; η c , η d are the charging and discharging efficiencies of energy storage, respectively; E es is the rated capacity of energy storage; P dis,t , P cha,t They represent the discharge and charging power of the energy storage system at time t respectively; φ is the capacity degradation coefficient; Among them, P s (t), P w (t) represents the photovoltaic and wind power output at time t, respectively; D(t) represents the load at time t; δ1 and δ2 represent the maximum allowable rates of wind and heat abandonment, respectively.
[0026] The energy storage utility evaluation process based on multi-scenario system operation simulation in step 2.4 specifically includes the following steps:
[0027] Step 2.41: Calculate relevant evaluation indicators of the flexible adjustment effect of the energy storage system using the planning model constructed above;
[0028] Step 2.42: Optimize the energy storage technology operation scenario;
[0029] Step 2.43: Based on the optimized system operation results, the comprehensive weight-TODIM utility evaluation model is used to comprehensively evaluate the energy storage utility under different scenarios;
[0030] Step 2.44: Analyze the utility of energy storage applications and discuss the utility of energy storage across multiple scenarios.
[0031] Beneficial effects of the present invention: The present invention is a method for evaluating the value of multi-period energy storage for flexible supply of microgrids, and is intended to thoroughly analyze the effectiveness of energy storage in promoting flexible adjustment of microgrids. In use, the present invention first introduces a set of comprehensive evaluation indicators for evaluating the effectiveness of flexible adjustment of energy storage, and then constructs a composite weight-TODIM model for evaluating the effectiveness of energy storage. The model includes the heterogeneity of risk preferences, and the model takes the risk preferences of decision makers into account. It can conduct comparative analysis on the effectiveness of energy storage technology in various scenarios, thereby providing strategic insights for the application of multi-period energy storage in microgrids. The method of the present invention is conducive to horizontal analysis and vertical comparison of energy storage utility under different environmental conditions, thereby helping to establish a comprehensive evaluation model for energy storage utility, thereby supporting the construction of efficient and clean new power systems. The feasibility and effectiveness of the model have been verified through example analysis. The present invention has the advantages of establishing a comprehensive evaluation index system for energy storage utility, considering the risk preferences of decision makers, and constructing a composite weight-TODIM energy storage flexible adjustment utility evaluation model. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0032] Figure 1 Schematic diagram of the classification of typical energy storage technologies of the present invention.
[0033] Figure 2 It is a schematic diagram of the evaluation index system of the utility flexible regulation of the energy storage power station of the present invention.
[0034] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of the optimization results of the evaluation indicators of the present invention.
[0035] Figure 4 It is a schematic diagram of the subjective and objective comprehensive weighted results of the energy storage efficiency evaluation standard of the present invention.
[0036] Figure 5 The figure is a schematic diagram showing the calculation results of the advantages of the 20% permeability of the present invention over other permeability levels.
[0037] Figure 6 It is a schematic diagram of the calculation results of the advantages of 50% permeability of the present invention over other permeability levels.
[0038] Figure 7 It is a schematic diagram of the comparative calculation results of the 70% permeability advantage of the present invention and other permeability levels.
[0039] Figure 8 It is a schematic diagram of the energy storage utility evaluation results under multiple scenarios of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0040] In order to achieve the "dual carbon" goal, the development of a new power system based on renewable energy has become a key approach. As a dynamic and efficient secondary energy source, electricity has great significance in the contemporary social framework. Building a new power system with renewable energy as the main energy source and effectively replacing fossil fuels is the key to promoting the low-carbon and sustainable development of the power system; however, renewable energy generation methods, mainly wind power and photovoltaic power generation, are largely affected by uncontrollable environmental factors, resulting in variability and uncertainty; with the increasing dependence of the new power system on renewable energy and the clean construction of microgrids, the safety and stability of power grid operation are threatened, and flexible resource solutions are urgently needed to continuously monitor and adjust the balance of power supply and demand to ensure the safety of power lines; energy storage, as a flexible and multifunctional technology with a wide range of technical changes and application scenarios, is widely used in the establishment of new power systems; energy storage technology can be divided into mechanical energy storage, electrochemical energy storage, electromagnetic energy storage and thermal energy storage according to the working principle; it can be divided into short-term, medium-term and long-term storage according to the duration of the reaction; and it can be divided into power type and capacity type storage on the basis of flexible functional adjustment, such as Figure 1 As shown, the horizontal axis represents the response time of energy storage, from milliseconds to hours; the vertical axis divides the application scenarios of different energy storage technologies according to power and energy support;
[0041] The present invention will be further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0042] Example 1
[0043] like Figure 1-8 As shown, a method for evaluating the value of multi-period energy storage for flexible supply of a microgrid comprises the following steps:
[0044] Step 1: Comprehensively consider the effectiveness of energy storage in terms of energy storage performance, emission reduction and power system revenue increase, and build a comprehensive evaluation index system for the flexible adjustment of energy storage power stations in the power market;
[0045] In this embodiment, if Figure 2 As shown, the evaluation index system of energy storage constructed by the present invention consists of three parts: energy storage utility, social welfare benefit and power system incremental revenue effect, and is further divided into ten secondary indicators. The detailed description of the index system is as follows:
[0046] 1) Energy storage utility includes system energy storage investment cost, system energy storage operation cost, cumulative energy storage, cumulative energy storage operation time and energy storage discharge times; ① System energy storage investment cost: When evaluating the utility of the energy storage system, it is hoped that the system can meet a large number of flexible adjustment needs at the lowest cost. Therefore, it is desirable to reduce the investment and operation costs of the energy storage system. The corresponding cost calculation model is as follows: Among them, C construction-inrepresents the total investment cost of energy storage throughout its entire life cycle; β1 and β2 represent the construction cost per unit rated power and rated energy storage capacity, respectively; They represent the rated power and rated capacity of the energy storage station respectively; x is the discount rate; T es The life of the energy storage station; ② System energy storage operation cost: Similar to the investment cost, the operation cost of energy storage is determined by the charging and discharging power and the unit operation price. In the formula, C om is the operation and maintenance cost of the energy storage station; β3 represents the unit operation cost of the energy storage unit; P dis (t), P cha (t) are the power generation power and charging power of the energy storage unit at time t; K es,dis (t), K es,cha (t) are the constraint variables of the energy storage operation state. If the energy storage is in the discharge state, then K es,dis (t)=1,K es,cha (t) = 0; if charging, then K es,dis (t)=0,K es,cha (t) = 1; if not activated, K es,dis (t)=0,K es,cha (t) = 0; ③ Accumulated energy storage: The accumulated energy storage reflects the total amount of energy storage during the flexible adjustment period, indicating the flexible adjustment capability of energy storage. The calculation method is: In the formula, is the total amount of electricity stored in the system in a given time period; η1 is the leakage coefficient of the system; ④ Cumulative operation time of energy storage: The cumulative operation time of energy storage refers to the total operation time of energy storage in the system, in hours, and the calculation formula is:
[0047] ⑤ Energy storage discharge times: The number of charge and discharge cycles of energy storage reflects the participation of energy storage in flexible regulation, and further illustrates the contribution of energy storage to flexible regulation. The calculation method is:
[0048] 2) Social welfare benefits include the effectiveness of reducing carbon emissions, renewable energy absorption rate, and government subsidies and benefits; ① The effectiveness of reducing carbon emissions: As the proportion of renewable energy in the new power system is high, the supply variability and instability of the system will increase significantly. Energy storage participates in the flexible adjustment of the power system, which can reduce the operating frequency of traditional energy to a certain extent and realize flexible alternatives to traditional energy. The calculation method is: ② Renewable energy absorption rate: Due to the variability and uncertainty of renewable energy, wind power and solar power abandonment often occur during the operation of the power system. Energy storage participating in the adjustment of the power system can further reduce the occurrence of the above situation, thereby improving the utilization rate of renewable energy. Therefore, the absorption rate of renewable energy can be used as one of the comprehensive evaluation indicators of the utility of energy storage application. Its calculation method is: Among them, P res (t) represents the actual electricity generation from renewable energy sources; Represents the actual reduction in renewable energy; ③ Government subsidies and benefits: In the face of the high investment cost of energy storage technology, the government has introduced a series of favorable policies including electricity price subsidies. The government electricity price subsidies are used to calculate the additional benefits of energy storage. The calculation formula is: Where P dis (t) represents the discharge power of the energy storage system at time t; C sub The government subsidizes electricity prices.
[0049] 3) The incremental benefit effect of the power system includes the expected benefits of delaying equipment investment and peak load regulation and valley filling; ① Delaying equipment investment: Energy storage participates in the flexible adjustment of the power system, which can delay the investment in system equipment. Its benefit function is: F du =λ×δ×C distribution ×P est (9), where δ represents the fixed depreciation rate of the distribution network equipment, usually 3%; λ represents the charging and discharging efficiency of the energy storage system; C distribution Represents the unit capacity cost of power distribution equipment; P est is the rated power of the energy storage system; ② The expected benefits of peak load regulation and valley filling: Under the influence of time-of-use electricity prices, energy storage can be charged at low prices during peak hours to achieve peak load regulation and valley filling arbitrage. The calculation formula is: Among them, ρ t It is the time-of-use electricity price of the power system.
[0050] Step 2: Establish a utility evaluation model for energy storage participating in the flexible adjustment of the electricity market during the construction of a new power system based on the composite weight framework of TODIM utility evaluation;
[0051] Step 3: Example analysis.
[0052] The present invention is a method for evaluating the value of multi-period energy storage for flexible supply of microgrids. The purpose is to thoroughly analyze the effectiveness of energy storage in promoting flexible adjustment of microgrids. In use, in order to comprehensively evaluate the effectiveness of energy storage in new power systems participating in flexible adjustment of the power market under different proportions of renewable energy application, the present invention establishes a comprehensive evaluation index system for energy storage effectiveness, considers the impact of decision makers' risk preferences on the evaluation results, and constructs an energy storage flexible adjustment effectiveness evaluation model based on composite weights and TODIM. The attenuation coefficient in TODIM is used to reflect the heterogeneity of risk preferences of different energy storage types. The effectiveness and feasibility of the model are verified through example analysis. The present invention has the advantages of establishing a comprehensive evaluation index system for energy storage effectiveness, considering decision makers' risk preferences, and constructing an energy storage flexible adjustment effectiveness evaluation model based on composite weights-TODIM.
[0053] Example 2
[0054] like Figure 1-8 As shown, a method for evaluating the value of multi-period energy storage for flexible supply of a microgrid comprises the following steps:
[0055] Step 1: Comprehensively consider the effectiveness of energy storage in terms of energy storage performance, emission reduction and power system revenue increase, and build a comprehensive evaluation index system for the flexible adjustment of energy storage power stations in the power market;
[0056] Step 2: Based on the composite weight framework of TODIM utility evaluation, a utility evaluation model for energy storage participating in the flexible adjustment of the electricity market during the construction of a new power system is established.
[0057] In this embodiment, the present invention establishes a utility evaluation model for the flexible adjustment of energy storage participating in the power market during the construction of a new power system. The model uses a composite weighting method to perform subjective and objective weighting on the evaluation indicators, and uses the TODIM method to calculate the utility evaluation results that take into account the risk preferences of decision makers; the method of the present invention realizes the integration of multi-dimensional information, further ensuring the scientific validity and effectiveness of the evaluation results;
[0058] The energy storage utility evaluation framework is summarized as follows: ① First, clarify the architecture of the power market system and the transaction operation status in different years, organize and collect the annual operation information of the power system to be evaluated, and construct the initial matrix of energy storage utility evaluation indicators;
[0059] ② Secondly, a composite weight evaluation matrix of the index system is established: 1) First, experts in related fields are invited to use the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) to conduct a subjective analysis of the importance of each indicator in the energy storage utility evaluation index system, and calculate the subjective weight value of each indicator; 2) Then, based on the variability of the numerical characteristics of the energy storage utility evaluation index, the entropy weight method is used to calculate the objective weight value of the index system, and a composite weight evaluation matrix is constructed using the subjective and objective weight aggregation operator; 3) Further, based on consulting experts and reviewing literature, the initial value of the decision maker's risk preference is set, and the TODIM method is used to sort all the indicator information of the risk preference object evaluation, and the evaluation results of energy storage utility under different renewable energy penetration rates are obtained;
[0060] ③Finally, based on the results of energy storage utility evaluation, the application status and characteristics of energy storage in new power systems are summarized and analyzed, and suggestions are provided for the government and power system builders to further build and operate energy storage, helping to build a clean, flexible and efficient new power system; The following are the methods and processes for energy storage utility evaluation in this study: Specifically, the following steps are included:
[0061] Step 2.1: Weight combination method in energy storage utility evaluation;
[0062] In this embodiment, the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) can perform a systematic, model-based, data-driven transformation of complex problems, thereby improving the scientific nature of decision-making and reducing the difficulty of decision-making; it has been widely used in many research fields, especially in terms of subjective weights. In the process of systematically weighting the energy storage utility evaluation indicators, the analytic hierarchy process can simulate human cognitive characteristics, mainly through the following steps:
[0063] Step 2.11: Construct an initial judgment matrix of subjective weights of indicators: Invite multiple experts to describe the importance of energy storage utility evaluation indicators, and use the 1-9 point system shown in Table 1 to compare different evaluation indicators in pairs; for example, for the first-level indicators of layer A, the initial decision results are shown in Table 2, and the relative importance of each indicator to itself is 1;
[0064] Table 11-9 Scaling method
[0065]
[0066]
[0067] Table 2 Judgment Matrix
[0068] A <![CDATA[α1]]> <![CDATA[α2]]> … <![CDATA[α n ]]> <![CDATA[α1]]> 1 <![CDATA[f 12 ]]> … <![CDATA[f 1n ]]> <![CDATA[α2]]> <![CDATA[f 21 ]]> 1 … <![CDATA[f 2n ]]> … … … … … <![CDATA[α n ]]> <![CDATA[f n1 ]]> <![CDATA[f n2 ]]> … 1
[0069] Step 2.12: Solve the judgment matrix of energy storage utility index by row geometric mean method: This method facilitates single-level sorting of the secondary evaluation index under the primary evaluation index of energy storage utility, as shown in the following formula:
[0070] Step 2.13: Check the consistency of the energy storage utility evaluation index weight information: First, use the formula Determine the maximum eigenvalue of the energy storage utility evaluation index judgment matrix, and use the formula After a consistency check, the decision maker introduces the random index RI to further alleviate the problem of inconsistent correction factors caused by the matrix order. In the formula, λ max , n represent the maximum eigenvalue and order of the judgment matrix respectively; A represents the judgment matrix of the first-level indicators of level A; In general, when the order of the judgment matrix exceeds 3 and the consistency ratio (CR) ≤ 0.1, the consistency of the judgment matrix is considered acceptable; Otherwise, the judgment matrix must be adjusted for consistency until the above consistency conditions are met;
[0071] Table 3 Relationship between RI value and judgment matrix order
[0072]
[0073] Step 2.14: As a typical objective weighting method, the entropy weight method effectively measures the impact of the diversity of indicator information on the weight of the indicator system and has been widely used in various studies. In order to comprehensively reflect the subjective and objective weight attributes of the energy storage utility evaluation index, the present invention adopts the entropy weight method to determine the objective weight of the energy storage participation in the flexible regulation utility evaluation index during the construction of the new power system, which helps to objectively, scientifically and comprehensively express the information of the evaluation index, and is set as the entropy e of the evaluation index i i The calculation formula is: If i is the weighted value w of entropy in evaluation index i i ∈[0,1], Then i The calculation formula is: g i =1-e i (18), where w i The characteristics of the value can further reveal the changing rules of the indicator value; in order to reasonably display the subjective preferences of the decision maker and the objective attributes of the decision criteria, the present invention uses the following formula to summarize the subjective and objective weights: com =α1×w sub +α2×w ob (19).
[0074] Step 2.2: Use the energy storage utility evaluation method based on the TODIM method;
[0075] In this embodiment, as an extension of prospect theory, the TODIM method incorporates the risk preference of decision makers when evaluating the utility of energy storage applications, thereby reflecting the impact of decision makers' psychological behavior on the evaluation results, making the evaluation results more consistent with the objective evaluation environment; the TODIM method calculates and analyzes the dominance of the evaluation object, which facilitates the analysis of the approximate dominance levels of different evaluation objects and helps decision makers to mine horizontal evaluation information; the TODIM evaluation process includes three steps: first, standardize the evaluation information: Secondly, calculate the relative importance of each indicator: Finally, the advantage function in the TODIM model is used to calculate the relative advantage of the evaluation object for energy storage utility under each indicator: The loss aversion coefficient θ represents the decision maker's attitude toward risk: the lower the value, the stronger the desire to avoid loss. Finally, using the formula The advantages of all evaluation indicators of each alternative plan are summed up; based on the summary results, the advantages and disadvantages of the evaluation object can be evaluated, and improvement measures and policy recommendations can be further analyzed; where x pj represents the performance score of alternative p relative to criterion j; denote the best and worst performance scores among all alternatives for criterion j, respectively; w jr is the weight of criterion j in the context of reference r; C refers to a set of criteria where alternative p is better than the reference; B refers to a set of criteria where alternative p is worse than the reference; Optional T p With reference T q The partial value function of criterion j during comparison; θ is the attenuation factor; d(x pj ,x qj ) represents the difference in performance scores between alternatives p and q for criterion j; δ(T p ,T q ) refers to the substitution of T in all standards q Relative to reference T q overall advantage.
[0076] Step 2.3: Quantitative method of energy storage utility evaluation index;
[0077] In this embodiment, specifically: in order to facilitate the optimization simulation of the power system operation and thus quantify the energy storage utility evaluation index, the present invention constructs the following system optimization model: maxf = F up-low +F sub -C carbon -C loss -C in -C con (25),
[0078] The goal of formula (25) is to maximize the difference between the benefits of flexible adjustment of the system and the costs of flexible adjustment, where F up-low represents the expected benefits of peak load regulation and valley filling; F sub represents government subsidy income, C carbon , C loss , C in , C con They represent carbon emission cost, wind and solar curtailment cost, total energy storage investment cost and traditional energy operation cost respectively; the total energy storage investment cost includes investment cost and operation cost; the present invention analyzes coal-fired power plants as a typical traditional energy source; formulas (26)-(28) list in detail the specific calculation methods of various costs, among which, F up-low 、F sub and C in The calculation method of is shown in the above content; where c i is the unit carbon emission cost of the i-th type of traditional energy; P con,i (t) represents the power generation of the i-th traditional energy at time t; η w , η s are the cost coefficients of each unit of abandoned wind and solar energy; P w,loss (t), P s,loss (t) are the total amount of wind and solar energy abandoned at time t; P con,fuel is the unit fuel cost of traditional energy; Q con,i,t is the consumption of the i-th traditional energy at time t; C con represents the unit variable operating cost;
[0079] stk es,dis (t)+k es,cha (t)≤1(29), SOC min ≤SOC(t)≤SOC max (31), k es,dis (t)×P dis,t,min ≤P dis,t ≤k es,dis (t)×P dis,t,max (32), k es,cha (t)×P cha,t,min ≤P cha,t ≤k es,cha (t)×P cha,t,max (33), Formulas (29)-(34) summarize the operating constraints of energy storage: Formula (29) is the operating state constraint of energy storage, where k es,dis (t), kes,cha (t) represent the discharge state and charge state variables of the energy storage at time t respectively; Formula (30) describes the dynamic update of the energy storage system, where SOC(t) represents the percentage of the energy storage system in the charge state; π is the energy storage self-discharge rate; η c , η d are the charging and discharging efficiencies of energy storage, respectively; E es is the rated capacity of the energy storage; Equations (32) and (33) represent the upper and lower constraints of the discharge and charging power of the energy storage system, respectively, where P dis,t , P cha,t They represent the discharge and charging power of the energy storage system at time t respectively; Formula (34) constrains the capacity of the energy storage system, where φ is the capacity degradation coefficient;
[0080]
[0081] Formulas (35)-(38) describe the operating constraints of the system: Formula (35) is the power balance constraint, where P s (t), P w (t) represent the photovoltaic and wind power output at time t respectively; D(t) represents the load at time t; Equations (36) and (37) represent the constraints on wind and heat abandonment respectively, where δ1 and δ2 represent the maximum allowable rates of wind and heat abandonment respectively; Equation (38) is the output limit of traditional energy.
[0082] Step 2.4: Establish an energy storage utility evaluation process based on multi-scenario system operation simulation;
[0083] In this embodiment, in order to obtain scientific and effective energy storage utility evaluation results, the present invention establishes an energy storage utility evaluation process based on multi-scenario system operation simulation, which is as follows:
[0084] Step 2.41: Calculate relevant evaluation indicators of the flexible adjustment effect of the energy storage system using the planning model constructed above;
[0085] Step 2.42: Optimize the energy storage technology operation scenario: Considering the increasing proportion of renewable energy in the new power system, the present invention proposes different energy storage utility evaluation scenarios based on the proportion of renewable energy, including scenarios where the proportion of renewable energy is 20%, 50% and 70%; the proportion of renewable energy is determined based on expert consultation and industry development reports;
[0086] Step 2.43: Based on the optimized system operation results, the comprehensive weight-TODIM utility evaluation model is used to comprehensively evaluate the energy storage utility under different scenarios;
[0087] Step 2.44: Analyze the utility of energy storage applications and discuss the utility of energy storage across multiple scenarios: Based on the comprehensive energy storage utility evaluation results, preliminarily analyze the utility of energy storage in different scenarios and explore the further application and development direction of energy storage; then, conduct a comprehensive comparative analysis of the utility of energy storage in different scenarios, and establish the value positioning of energy storage in the development and construction of new power systems based on the current level of technological development, laying a theoretical foundation for the scientific investment and optimized operation of energy storage.
[0088] Step 2.5: Analysis of error sources of comprehensive evaluation method.
[0089] In this embodiment, the comprehensive evaluation method of the present invention mainly includes two parts: calculation of weights and calculation of storage evaluation indicators; therefore, the main sources of error of the above comprehensive evaluation method are as follows:
[0090] ① The construction of storage value evaluation index and the calculation of weights in the present invention involve subjective factors: differences among decision makers in determining subjective indicators and weights may lead to differences in evaluation results, which can be interpreted as an error;
[0091] ② In the storage value assessment model at the operational level, in order to ensure the solvability of the model, it may be necessary to simplify the storage modeling and system operation simulation, which may affect the results of the storage value quantification at the operational level.
[0092] Step 3: Example analysis.
[0093] In this embodiment, case study: In view of the fact that the new power system is still under construction and the construction data is incomplete, the present invention takes the system energy storage optimization configuration results under the actual annual load under different renewable energy application proportions in a specific region as the background, and takes the actual local wind and solar energy resource endowments as input, to provide reliable indicator data support for the case analysis of the energy storage utility evaluation model. The energy storage technology selected in the case of the present invention is pumped storage;
[0094] like Figure 2 As shown in the figure, the optimization index values of energy storage applications under different proportions of renewable energy are as follows: Figure 3 As shown, there are 3 first-level standards and 10 second-level standards; three experts in the fields of new low-carbon power system development, energy storage system research and carbon emission reduction research were invited to perform subjective weighting on the evaluation index system constructed by the present invention, and the objective weight was calculated according to the value of each index, as shown in Figure 4 As shown; then, the subjective and objective weight results are summarized according to formula (19) to obtain the calculation formula of energy storage advantage under different application scenarios; the present invention compares the advantage calculation results under 20%, 50%, and 70% permeability with the advantage calculation results under other permeability levels, as shown Figure 5-7As shown; Finally, the TODIM model is used to evaluate the application value of energy storage utility in the new power system under different proportions of renewable energy application in multiple scenarios. The loss avoidance coefficient is set to 2, and the comprehensive evaluation results are as follows Figure 8 As shown;
[0095] From the calculation results, it can be seen that in a single scenario, due to the high investment risk preference of decision makers, the utility advantage of energy storage is negative. This is mainly due to the high overall investment cost of energy storage and unclear investment returns. When comparing the evaluation results of energy storage utility under different scenarios, energy storage shows higher utility when the proportion of renewable energy application is low; with the increase in the proportion of renewable energy application, the complementary characteristics of photovoltaic power generation and wind power generation will be further highlighted, and the scale benefits of renewable energy power generation can be further developed. The combined application of energy storage and traditional units, as well as reasonable wind and solar power abandonment strategies, will further make up for the limitations of system and individual flexible resource balance;
[0096] Therefore, for power system builders and governments, there are several aspects that need to be strengthened in order to improve the utility of energy storage in applications, while ensuring safe and reliable power supply and improving the flexible adjustment capabilities of the system;
[0097] ① Technically improve the flexibility and response speed of energy storage, while reducing the self-discharge rate of energy storage: From a cost perspective, reduce the costs related to adjustments, ease the economic pressure of initial investment in energy storage power station construction, and develop multiple financing models such as public-private partnership (PPP) and build-operate-transfer (BOT); in terms of profit, through the evaluation of flexible value, reasonably distribute market profits, and expand the methods of recovering energy storage costs;
[0098] ② Consider resource endowments, give full play to the complementary advantages of various flexible resources such as traditional power generation units, energy storage stations, thermal storage facilities, and gas storage facilities, reasonably select wind and solar power abandonment strategies and demand response strategies, build a clean, reliable, and convenient flexible adjustment system, and establish an effective incentive mechanism;
[0099] ③ Promote the large-scale construction of renewable energy, utilize the complementary capabilities of wind and solar power generation curves, stabilize the scale of energy storage station construction, and reduce the decline in resource utilization caused by excessive and disorderly construction. From the perspective of changes in the external environment, the practicality of energy storage in applications will be enhanced.
[0100] The present invention is a method for evaluating the value of multi-period energy storage for flexible supply of microgrids, and is intended to thoroughly analyze the utility of energy storage in promoting flexible adjustment of microgrids. In use, the present invention first introduces a set of comprehensive evaluation indicators for evaluating the utility of flexible adjustment of energy storage, and then constructs a composite weight-TODIM model for evaluating the utility of energy storage. The model includes the heterogeneity of risk preferences, and the model takes the risk preferences of decision makers into account. It can conduct comparative analysis on the utility of energy storage technology in various scenarios, thereby providing strategic insights for the application of multi-period energy storage in microgrids. The method of the present invention is conducive to horizontal analysis and vertical comparison of energy storage utility under different environmental conditions, thereby helping to establish a comprehensive evaluation model for energy storage utility, thereby supporting efficient and clean new power systems. The construction passed, and the feasibility and effectiveness of the model were verified by example analysis; the evaluation results show that when the application proportion of renewable energy is low, the complementary characteristics of renewable energy are not fully reflected, and the utility of flexible adjustment of energy storage is higher; on the contrary, with the significant increase in the application proportion of renewable energy, the internal complementary characteristics of renewable energy are more obvious, resulting in a decrease in the utility advantage of flexible regulation on energy storage relative to the scenario with a low application proportion of renewable energy; on this basis, policy recommendations are put forward to further promote the construction of a clean, flexible and reliable new power system, which will serve the power system planning and government decision-making; the present invention has the advantages of establishing a comprehensive evaluation index system for energy storage utility, considering the risk preference of decision makers, and constructing a flexible adjustment utility evaluation model for energy storage based on composite weights-TODIM.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the value of energy storage in multiple time periods for flexible supply of microgrids, characterized by: The method comprises the following steps: Step 1: Comprehensively consider the effectiveness of energy storage in terms of energy storage performance, emission reduction and power system revenue increase, and build a comprehensive evaluation index system for the flexible adjustment of energy storage power stations in the power market; Step 2: Establish a utility evaluation model for energy storage participating in the flexible adjustment of the electricity market during the construction of a new power system based on the composite weight framework of TODIM utility evaluation; Step 3: Example analysis.
2. The microgrid flexible supply multi-period energy storage value assessment method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The evaluation index system constructed in step 1 is composed of three parts: energy storage utility, social welfare benefit and power system incremental revenue effect, and is further divided into ten secondary indicators.
3. The microgrid flexible supply multi-period energy storage value assessment method according to claim 2, characterized in that: The energy storage utility includes the system energy storage investment cost, the system energy storage operation cost, the accumulated energy storage, the accumulated energy storage operation time and the number of energy storage discharges; ① System energy storage investment cost: When evaluating the utility of the energy storage system, it is hoped that the system can meet a large number of flexible adjustment needs at the lowest cost. The corresponding cost calculation model is as follows: Among them, C construction-in represents the total investment cost of energy storage throughout its entire life cycle; β1 and β2 represent the construction cost per unit rated power and rated energy storage capacity, respectively; They represent the rated power and rated capacity of the energy storage station respectively; x is the discount rate; T es The life of the energy storage station; ② System energy storage operation cost: The operation cost of energy storage is determined by the charging and discharging power and the unit operation price. In the formula, C om is the operation and maintenance cost of the energy storage station; β3 represents the unit operation cost of the energy storage unit; P dis (t), P cha (t) are the power generation power and charging power of the energy storage unit at time t; K es,dis (t), K es,cha (t) are the constraint variables of the energy storage operation state; ③ Accumulated storage capacity: The accumulated storage capacity reflects the total storage capacity during the flexible adjustment period, indicating the flexible adjustment capability of the energy storage, and its calculation method is: In the formula, is the total amount of electricity stored in the system in a given time period; η1 is the leakage coefficient of the system; ④ Cumulative operation time of energy storage: The cumulative operation time of energy storage refers to the total operation time of energy storage in the system, in hours, and the calculation formula is: ⑤ Energy storage discharge times: The number of charge and discharge cycles of energy storage reflects the participation of energy storage in flexible regulation, and further illustrates the contribution of energy storage to flexible regulation. The calculation method is:
4. The microgrid flexible supply multi-period energy storage value assessment method according to claim 2, characterized in that: The social welfare benefits include the effect of reducing carbon emissions, the absorption rate of renewable energy, and government subsidies and benefits; ① The effect of reducing carbon emissions: The calculation method is: ② Renewable energy absorption rate: The absorption rate of renewable energy can be used as one of the comprehensive evaluation indicators of energy storage application effectiveness. Its calculation method is: Among them, P res (t) represents the actual electricity generation from renewable energy sources; Represents the actual reduction in renewable energy; ③ Government subsidies and benefits: Use government electricity price subsidies to calculate the additional benefits of energy storage. The calculation formula is: Where P dis (t) represents the discharge power of the energy storage system at time t; C sub The government subsidizes electricity prices.
5. The microgrid flexible supply multi-period energy storage value assessment method according to claim 2, characterized in that: The incremental benefit effect of the power system includes the expected benefits of delaying equipment investment and peak load regulation and valley filling; ① Delaying equipment investment: Energy storage participates in the flexible adjustment of the power system, which can delay the investment in system equipment. Its benefit function is: F du =λ×δ×C distribution ×P est (9), where δ represents the fixed depreciation rate of the distribution network equipment; λ represents the charging and discharging efficiency of the energy storage system; C distribution Represents the unit capacity cost of power distribution equipment; P est is the rated power of the energy storage system; ② The expected benefits of peak load regulation and valley filling: Under the influence of time-of-use electricity prices, energy storage can be charged at low prices during peak hours to achieve peak load regulation and valley filling arbitrage. The calculation formula is: Among them, ρ t It is the time-of-use electricity price of the power system.
6. The microgrid flexible supply multi-period energy storage value assessment method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The composite weight framework based on TODIM utility evaluation in step 2 establishes a utility evaluation model for energy storage participating in the flexible adjustment of the power market during the construction of a new power system, which specifically includes the following steps: Step 2.1: Weight combination method in energy storage utility evaluation; Step 2.2: Use the energy storage utility evaluation method based on the TODIM method; Step 2.3: Quantitative method of energy storage utility evaluation index; Step 2.4: Establish an energy storage utility evaluation process based on multi-scenario system operation simulation; Step 2.5: Analysis of error sources of comprehensive evaluation method.
7. The method for evaluating the value of energy storage for flexible supply of microgrid in multiple time periods as claimed in claim 6, characterized in that: The weight combination method in the energy storage utility evaluation in step 2.1 specifically includes the following steps: Step 2.11: Construct the initial judgment matrix of the subjective weights of the indicators; Step 2.12: Solve the judgment matrix of energy storage utility index by row geometric mean method: as shown below: Step 2.13: Check the consistency of the energy storage utility evaluation index weight information: First, use the formula Determine the maximum eigenvalue of the energy storage utility evaluation index judgment matrix, and use the formula After a consistency check, the decision maker then introduces the random index RI to further alleviate the problem of inconsistent correction factors caused by the matrix order. In the formula, λ max , n represent the maximum eigenvalue and order of the judgment matrix respectively; A represents the judgment matrix of the first-level indicators of level A; Step 2.14: Use the entropy weight method to determine the objective weight of the evaluation index of the flexible regulation utility of energy storage in the construction of the new power system, set as the entropy e of the evaluation index i i The calculation formula is: If i is the weighted value w of entropy in evaluation index i i ∈[0,1], Then i The calculation formula is: g i =1-e i (18), where w i The characteristics of the value can further reveal the changing rules of the indicator value; in order to reasonably show the subjective preferences of decision makers and the objective attributes of decision criteria, the following formula is used to summarize the subjective and objective weights: com =α1×w sub +α2×w ob (19).
8. The method for evaluating the value of energy storage in a microgrid with flexible supply in multiple time periods as claimed in claim 6, characterized in that: The energy storage utility evaluation method based on the TODIM method in step 2.2 is specifically as follows: first, the evaluation information is standardized: Secondly, calculate the relative importance of each indicator: Finally, the advantage function in the TODIM model is used to calculate the relative advantage of the evaluation object for energy storage utility under each indicator: The loss aversion coefficient θ represents the decision maker's attitude toward risk; finally, using the formula The advantages of all evaluation indicators of each alternative are summed up; where x pj represents the performance score of alternative p relative to criterion j; denote the best and worst performance scores among all alternatives for criterion j, respectively; w jr is the weight of criterion j in the context of reference r; C refers to a set of criteria where the alternative p is better than the reference; B refers to a set of criteria where the alternative p is worse than the reference; Optional T p With reference T q The partial value function of criterion j during comparison; θ is the attenuation factor; d(x pj ,x qj ) represents the difference in performance scores between alternatives p and q for criterion j; δ(T p ,T q ) refers to the substitution of T in all standards q Relative to reference T q overall advantage.
9. The method for evaluating the value of energy storage in a microgrid with flexible supply in multiple time periods as claimed in claim 6, characterized in that: The step 2.3: quantification method of energy storage utility evaluation index, specifically: construct the following system optimization model: maxf = F up-low +F sub -C carbon -C loss -C in -C con (25), Among them, F up-low represents the expected benefits of peak load regulation and valley filling; F sub represents government subsidy income, C carbon , C loss , C in , C con They represent carbon emission cost, wind and solar power abandonment cost, total energy storage investment cost and traditional energy operation cost respectively; c i is the unit carbon emission cost of the i-th type of traditional energy; P con,i (t) represents the power generation of the i-th traditional energy at time t; η w , η s are the cost coefficients of each unit of abandoned wind and solar energy; P w,loss (t), P s,loss (t) are the total amount of wind and solar energy abandoned at time t; P con,fuel is the unit fuel cost of traditional energy; Q con,i,t is the consumption of the i-th traditional energy at time t; C con represents unit variable operating cost; stk es,dis (t)+k es,cha (t)≤1(29), SOC min ≤SOC(t)≤SOC max (31), k es,dis (t)×P dis,t,min ≤P dis,t ≤k es,dis (t)×P dis,t,max (32), k es,cha (t)×P cha,t,min ≤P cha,t ≤k es,cha (t)×P cha,t,max (33), Among them, k es,dis (t), k es,cha (t) respectively represent the discharge state and charge state variables of the energy storage at time t; SOC(t) represents the percentage of the energy storage system in the charge state; π is the energy storage self-discharge rate; η c , η d are the charging and discharging efficiencies of energy storage, respectively; E es is the rated capacity of energy storage; P dis,t , P cha,t They represent the discharge and charging power of the energy storage system at time t respectively; φ is the capacity degradation coefficient; Among them, P s (t), P w (t) represents the photovoltaic and wind power output at time t, respectively; D(t) represents the load at time t; δ1 and δ2 represent the maximum allowable rates of wind and heat abandonment, respectively.
10. The microgrid flexible supply multi-period energy storage value assessment method according to claim 6, characterized in that: The energy storage utility evaluation process based on multi-scenario system operation simulation in step 2.4 specifically includes the following steps: Step 2.41: Calculate relevant evaluation indicators of the flexible adjustment effect of the energy storage system using the planning model constructed above; Step 2.42: Optimize energy storage technology operation scenarios; Step 2.43: Based on the optimized system operation results, the comprehensive weight-TODIM utility evaluation model is used to comprehensively evaluate the energy storage utility under different scenarios; Step 2.44: Analyze the utility of energy storage applications and discuss the utility of energy storage across multiple scenarios.
Citation Information
Cited By
Method for optimizing advertisement putting effect by combining user group and pre-putting
CN120181925A
Weight-adaptive multi-scene energy storage power station participation frequency modulation contribution degree evaluation method
CN121526036A
