Heat-resistant steel welded joint structure damage assessment method based on grain boundary integrity
Through the evaluation method based on grain boundary integrity and high-temperature and high-stress creep test, the insufficient evaluation of the fine-grained heat-affected zone of the welded joint of martensite heat-resistant steel in the prior art is solved, and the martensite heat-resistant steel is realized safety warning and accurate assessment of tissue damage have increased safety margin.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411096587.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-12
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-08-12
AI Technical Summary
The existing tissue damage assessment methods are not targeted for the fine crystal heat-affected zones of martensite heat-resistant steel welded joints, making it difficult to accurately count the precipitated phases and tiny holes in the crystal, resulting in the failure of effective positioning.
The evaluation method based on grain boundary integrity is adopted, and the grain boundary and precipitation phase perimeter are measured by scanning electron microscopy, damage harmony factors are introduced, and tissue damage parameter thresholds are defined to provide safety warning evaluation.
It improves the safety warning capability of martensite heat-resistant steel welded joints, reduces statistical workload, avoids the influence of original slat traces, provides a more targeted micro-tissue damage assessment, and enhances safety margin.
Smart Images

Figure CN118961784A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present application relates to the technical field of industrial equipment failure detection, and in particular to a method for evaluating the structural damage of a heat-resistant steel weld joint. Background Art
[0002] Thermal power generation is the main power generation method in my country. Low pollution and high efficiency power generation make the service conditions of ultra-supercritical units more stringent. Higher service temperature and steam pressure put forward higher requirements on the performance of welding pipe materials in boilers. Martensitic heat-resistant steel is often used for welding pipes in boilers due to its good high temperature mechanical properties. Such welded joints often have type IV cracking in the fine grain heat affected zone during service, which is easy to cause major safety accidents. Therefore, it is necessary to conduct regular inspections of the fine grain heat affected zone of such service joints. Before type IV cracking, the microstructure damage characteristics of the fine grain heat affected zone are mainly manifested as the number and size of creep voids increase with the increase of service time, and the types and sizes of precipitates increase. The existing microstructure damage assessment methods mainly use statistics on the average size, area proportion, hole spacing and hole number density of creep voids appearing in the organization, as well as the average size, area proportion and number density of all second phases. These methods have the following problems: 1. Statistics of all precipitates and voids appearing in the organization of martensitic heat-resistant steel lack pertinence to the main failure position (grain boundary) of martensitic heat-resistant steel. 2. It is difficult to make accurate and effective statistics on the precipitation phases and tiny voids within the crystal due to the influence of the lath traces of the original lath martensite. Summary of the invention
[0003] In order to overcome the shortcomings of the existing evaluation methods, this application provides a method for evaluating the microstructure damage of heat-resistant steel welded joints based on grain boundary integrity. The specific steps are as follows:
[0004] (1) Preparation of standard metallographic samples: Prepare standard metallographic samples of the fine-grained heat-affected zone of the heat-resistant steel in the welded joint to be evaluated, i.e., a welded joint with a certain service time;
[0005] (2) Standard metallographic sample structure measurement: The above metallographic sample is photographed continuously under the field of view of a scanning electron microscope, for a total of M images; for the i-th image, the sum of all grain boundary lengths L is measured. i ; Measure the perimeter p of the precipitated phase on all grain boundaries i-1 , p i-2 ,…,p i-m ; Where m is the total number of precipitated phases on the grain boundaries in the corresponding image; if there are voids on the grain boundaries, the perimeter of the voids on all grain boundaries is measured h i-1 ,h i-2 ,…,h i-n ; where n is the total number of voids on the grain boundary in the corresponding image; then the average tissue damage parameter S i For Si =[f1(p i-1 +p i-2 +p i-3 +…p i-m )+f2(h i-1 +h i-2 +h i-3 +…h i-n )] / L i , where i = 1, 2, ..., M, f1 is the harmonic factor of precipitate damage; f2 is the harmonic factor of void damage; for the standard metallographic sample, S 服役时长 =(S1+S2+…+S M ) / M;
[0006] (3) High temperature and high stress creep step test on the original welded joint test bar: Take the original welded joint, i.e., the unserved welded joint, which is made by the same process as the welded joint to be evaluated, and conduct the high temperature and high stress creep test until the test bar breaks. The breaking time is TD. The high temperature and high stress creep test is conducted at different time periods in the interval of [50% TD, TD);
[0007] (4) creep metallographic sample structure measurement: referring to the method described in step (2), similarly measure the metallographic sample structure after the creep test at different time periods described in step (3), and calculate the average structure damage parameters of the creep test rod at the corresponding time periods in turn;
[0008] (5) Early warning assessment of damage to the welded joint to be assessed; the average of the average microstructural damage parameters of the creep test bar at each time period in step (4) is taken as S th , compared with S 服役时长 With S th , if S 服役时长 th The service joint is safe; if S 服役时长 >S th , then the service joint safety warning.
[0009] Furthermore, in step (2), the field of view magnification of the captured image is 500 to 5000.
[0010] Furthermore, in the step (2), M>=20.
[0011] Furthermore, the high temperature and high stress creep test of the welded joint to be evaluated in step (4) is a high temperature and high stress step creep test, and the high temperature and high stress creep test is carried out at 50%, 60%, 70%, and 80% step time periods of TD.
[0012] Furthermore, in step (2), f1 is [1, 2], and f2 is [3, 4].
[0013] Furthermore, the step (5) of evaluating the weld joint damage early warning evaluation is to record the average tissue damage parameters of the creep test rod at each time period in step (4) as S 50%TD , S 60%TD , S 70%TD , S 80%TD , S th =(1-0.5)*0.5*S 50%TD +(1-0.6)*0.6*S 60%TD +(1-0.7)*0.7*S 70%TD +(1-0.8)*0.8*S 80%TD , compared with S 服役时长 With S th , if S 服役时长 th The service joint is safe; if S 服役时长 >S th , then the service joint safety warning.
[0014] Precipitation phases and voids are signs of aging of martensitic heat-resistant steel during service, and precipitation phases and voids on grain boundaries are often the locations of service failure. This method provides an early warning assessment of the safety status of heat-resistant steel based on the degree of damage to grain boundary integrity caused by changes in precipitation phases and voids on grain boundaries of welded joints during service. Compared with the prior art, the beneficial effects of this application are:
[0015] 1. The strength of grain boundaries of martensitic heat-resistant steel welded joints decreases more than that of grains in the service temperature, and the strength of grain boundaries is greatly weakened. The irregularity of the grain boundary structure attracts the solute atoms of the precipitated phase to continuously concentrate toward the grain boundaries at high service temperatures, forming a precipitated phase that continues to coarsen. Under vapor pressure, vacancies diffuse to the interface of the precipitated phase at the grain boundary, causing the precipitated phase at the grain boundary to fall off and form creep voids. Therefore, the grain boundaries of heat-resistant steel are often where cracks initiate. This application is based on the failure mechanism during the above service process, and defines the microstructure damage parameter as S based on the grain boundary incompleteness. i =[f1(p i-1 +p i-2 +p i-3 +…p i-m )+f2(h i-1 +h i-2 +h i-3 +…h i-n )] / L i . According to the different degrees of damage to the tissue caused by different damage types, different reconciliation factors are introduced for precipitation phase and void type damage, where f1 is the reconciliation factor for precipitation phase damage, and f1 is [1, 2]; f2 is the reconciliation factor for void type damage, and f2 is [3, 4]. This application considers the failure mechanism and prone-to-failure position of martensitic heat-resistant steel, and takes into account the type of microscopic tissue damage by setting the reconciliation factor. This tissue damage-based assessment perspective provides a more targeted safety warning method for martensitic heat-resistant steel under service conditions.
[0016] 2. This method takes into account the safety warning during service and scientifically defines the critical average tissue damage parameter threshold S th Taking the creep rupture time TD of the original welded joint fracture creep specimen as the benchmark, the original welded joint was subjected to high temperature and high stress creep tests at different time periods such as [50%, 100%) TD, and the threshold of the tissue damage parameter was defined by the above tissue damage parameters; since the statistics are only for the perimeter of the grain boundary, the perimeter of the void near the grain boundary, and the perimeter of the precipitated phase, the statistical object is easy to locate, the types of parameters are relatively small, the statistical work is easy to operate, and the statistical workload is greatly reduced compared with the existing methods.
[0017] 3. This method focuses on measuring and counting the circumference of the precipitates and voids on the grain boundaries, effectively avoiding the problem of inaccurate statistical results of the precipitates and tiny voids in the grains caused by the lath marks of the original lath martensite in the fine-grained heat-affected zone of martensitic heat-resistant steel in the welded joints. The statistical objects are easy to identify, and the threshold comparison method is quick and simple. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0018] Figure 1 A flowchart of the steps of the evaluation method described in this application.
[0019] Figure 2 Typical tissue image at 5000X field of view. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0020] The technical solution of the present application is described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments.
[0021] Example 1
[0022] It is known that a dissimilar steel welded joint has been in service for 70,000 hours. A safety early warning assessment is conducted on this joint. The specific steps are as follows:
[0023] (1) Preparation of standard metallographic samples: Prepare standard metallographic samples of the fine grain heat affected zone of martensitic heat resistant steel in the welded joint to be evaluated, i.e., the welded joint with a service life of 70,000 hours;
[0024] (2) Standard metallographic sample structure measurement: The above metallographic sample is continuously photographed at 1000X (M = 30 images) under the field of view of a certain type of field emission scanning electron microscope; for the i-th image, the sum of all grain boundary lengths L is measured. i ; Measure the perimeter p of the precipitated phase on all grain boundaries i-1 , p i-2 ,…,p i-m ; Where m is the total number of precipitated phases on the grain boundaries in the corresponding image; if there are voids on the grain boundaries, the perimeter of the voids on all grain boundaries is measured h i-1 ,h i-2 ,…,h i-n ; Where n is the total number of voids on the grain boundary in the corresponding image; then the tissue damage parameter S obtained by the grain boundary imperfection in the corresponding scan image is calculated based on the above measurement data i For S i =[f1(p i-1 +p i-2 +p i-3 +…+p i-m )+f2(h i-1 +h i-2 +h i-3 +…h i-n )] / L i , where i=1, 2, ..., M, f1 is the harmonic factor of precipitate damage, and in this embodiment, f1=2; f2 is the harmonic factor of void damage, and in this embodiment, f2=4; for the standard metallographic sample, the average microstructure damage parameter S of the heat-resistant steel welded joint with a service time of 70,000 hours is calculated based on the statistical calculation results of 30 scanned images. 7万h =(S1+S2+…+S 30 ) / 30;
[0025] Due to the continuous increase in the operating temperature of ultra-supercritical units, the grain boundary strength of the grains of heat-resistant steel welded joints at the service temperature decreases more than that inside the grain, and the grain boundary strength is greatly weakened. The irregularity of the grain boundary structure attracts the solute atoms of the precipitated phase to continuously segregate to the grain boundary at high service temperature, forming a precipitated phase and continuously coarsening. Under vapor pressure, vacancies diffuse to the interface of the grain boundary precipitated phase, causing the grain boundary precipitated phase to fall off and form creep voids. Therefore, the grain boundaries of heat-resistant steel are often the place where cracks initiate. This application mainly focuses on the statistical measurement of the perimeter of the grain boundary position that is prone to failure, that is, the perimeter of the grain boundary and the precipitated phase and void on the grain boundary of the fine grain zone and the critical heat affected zone of martensitic heat-resistant steel is measured. According to the failure mechanism in the above-mentioned service process, the organizational evolution law of martensitic heat-resistant steel that causes failure in the service process (the formation of grain boundary precipitated phase and voids), the mathematical idea of average statistics is adopted, and a reasonable damage reconciliation factor is introduced according to different damage types (precipitated phases and voids) by grain boundary imperfections to make corresponding corrections.
[0026] (3) High-temperature high-stress creep step test on original welded joint test bars; take a test bar from an original welded joint that has not been in service and is made using the same process as the welded joint to be evaluated, and perform a high-temperature high-stress creep test until the test bar breaks. The break time is TD, and the high-temperature high-stress creep test is performed at different time periods within the interval of [50% TD, TD); in this embodiment, the high-temperature high-stress creep test is performed at 50%, 60%, 70%, and 80% of TD.
[0027] (4) Creep metallographic sample structure measurement: Referring to the method described in step (2), similarly measure the metallographic sample structure after the creep test at different time periods described in step (3), and calculate the average structure damage parameter of each creep test rod at the corresponding step time period, S 50%TD , S 60%TD , S 70%TD , S 80%TD ; Below 50% TD, it corresponds to the first stage of creep (creep rate decreases) and the early and middle stages of the second stage of creep (steady-state creep rate) in the creep curve. At this time, there are almost no voids and precipitation phases in the organization, the organization is stable, and the safety margin is very high. At 50% TD, grain boundary precipitation phases are observed; at 60% TD and 70% TD, the number of grain boundary precipitation phases increases, the size becomes larger, and small grain boundary voids appear; 80% TD corresponds to the end of the steady-state stage of creep, at which time the grain boundary precipitation phases are obviously coarsened and accompanied by grain boundary voids of a certain size; and when the joint enters the third stage of creep (acceleration stage), there will be a risk of fracture, and a certain safety margin must be left in the actual engineering assessment.
[0028] (5) Early warning assessment of damage to the welded joint to be assessed; take S in step (4) 50%D , S 60%D , S 70%D , S 80%D The mean value is S th , compared with S 服役时长 With S th , if S 服役时长 th The service joint is safe; if S 服役时长 >S th , then the service joint safety warning.
[0029] Example 2
[0030] It is known that a dissimilar steel welded joint has been in service for 100,000 hours. A safety early warning assessment is performed on this joint. The specific steps are as follows:
[0031] The steps (1) to (4) are the same as those in Example 1. When measuring the standard metallographic sample structure, 2000X images (M=50 images) are continuously taken under the field of view of a certain type of field emission scanning electron microscope. When it is observed that the structure changes drastically with the step period in the high-temperature and high-stress step creep test, the step (5) of evaluating the weld joint damage early warning evaluation is to record the average structure damage parameters of the creep test bar at each time period in step (4) as S, respectively. 50%TD , S 60%TD , S 70%TD , S 80%TD , then S th =(1-0.5)*0.5*S 50%TD +(1-0.6)*0.6*S 60%TD +(1-0.7)*0.7*S 70%TD +(1-0.8)*0.8*S 80%TD , compared with S 服役时长 With S th , if S 服役时长 th The service joint is safe; if S 服役时长 >S th , then the service joint safety warning.
[0032] The above is only a preferred specific implementation manner of the present application, but the protection scope of the present application is not limited thereto. Any technician familiar with the technical field can make equivalent substitutions or changes within the technical scope disclosed in the present application according to the technical solution and inventive concept of the present application, which should be covered by the protection scope of the present application.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating microstructure damage of heat-resistant steel welded joints based on grain boundary integrity, characterized in that: Here are the steps: (1) Preparation of standard metallographic samples: Prepare standard metallographic samples of the fine-grained heat-affected zone of the heat-resistant steel in the welded joint to be evaluated, i.e., a welded joint with a certain service time; (2) Standard metallographic sample structure measurement: the above metallographic sample is photographed continuously under the field of view of a scanning electron microscope, a total of M photos; For the i-th image, measure the sum of all grain boundary lengths L i ; Measure the perimeter p of the precipitated phase on all grain boundaries i-1 , p i-2 ,…,p i-m ; Where m is the total number of precipitated phases on the grain boundaries in the corresponding image; if there are voids on the grain boundaries, the perimeter of the voids on all grain boundaries is measured h i-1 ,h i-2 ,…,h i-n ; where n is the total number of voids on the grain boundary in the corresponding image; then the average tissue damage parameter S i For S i =[f1(p i-1 +p i-2 +p i-3 +…p i-m )+f2(h i-1 +h i-2 +h i-3 +…h i-n )] / L i , where i = 1, 2, ..., M, f1 is the harmonic factor of precipitate damage; f2 is the harmonic factor of void damage; for the standard metallographic sample, S 服役时长 =(S1+S2+…+S M ) / M; (3) High temperature and high stress creep step test on the original welded joint test bar: Take the original welded joint, i.e., the unserved welded joint, which is made by the same process as the welded joint to be evaluated, and conduct the high temperature and high stress creep test until the test bar breaks. The breaking time is TD. The high temperature and high stress creep test is conducted at different time periods in the interval of [50% TD, TD); (4) creep metallographic sample structure measurement: referring to the method described in step (2), similarly measure the metallographic sample structure after the creep test at different time periods described in step (3), and calculate the average structure damage parameters of the creep test rod at the corresponding time periods in turn; (5) Early warning assessment of damage to the welded joint to be assessed; the average of the average microstructural damage parameters of the creep test bar at each time period in step (4) is taken as S th , compared with S 服役时长 With S th , if S 服役时长 th The service joint is safe; if S 服役时长 >S th , then the service joint safety warning. 2. The method for evaluating the microstructure damage of heat-resistant steel welded joints based on grain boundary integrity according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In the step (2), the field of view magnification of the captured image is 500 to 5000.
3. The method for evaluating the microstructure damage of heat-resistant steel welded joints based on grain boundary integrity according to claim 2 is characterized in that: In the step (2), M>=20.
4. The method for evaluating the microstructure damage of heat-resistant steel welded joints based on grain boundary integrity according to claim 1, characterized in that: The high temperature and high stress creep test of the original welded joint in step (3) is a high temperature and high stress step creep test. The welded joint to be evaluated is subjected to a high temperature and high stress creep test at 50%, 60%, 70%, and 80% step time periods of TD according to the test conditions of step (3).
5. A method for evaluating microstructure damage of heat-resistant steel welded joints based on grain boundary integrity according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that: In the step (2), f1 is [1, 2], and f2 is [3, 4].
6. The method for evaluating the microstructure damage of heat-resistant steel welded joints based on grain boundary integrity according to claim 4, characterized in that: The step (5) of evaluating the weld joint damage early warning evaluation is to record the average tissue damage parameters of the creep test rod at each time period in step (4) respectively. 50%TD , S 60%TD , S 70%TD , S 80%TD , S th =(1-0.5)*0.5*S 50%TD +(1-0.6)*0.6*S 60%TD +(1-0.7)*0.7*S 70%TD +(1-0.8)*0.8*S 80%TD , compared with S 服役时长 With S th , if S 服役时长 th The service joint is safe; if S 服役时长 >S th , then the service joint safety warning. 7. A method for evaluating heat-resistant steel weld joint structure damage based on grain boundary integrity according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that: The heat-resistant steel is martensitic heat-resistant steel.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Evaluation method for creep damage of dissimilar steel welded joint
CN112730065A
Cold inlaying method for preparing porous metallographic specimen capable of being used for SEM (scanning electron microscope) by adding carbon fibers
CN115876819A
Creep damage grading method for 9% Cr martensitic heat-resistant steel joint fine grain area
CN118329648A
Creep life evaluating method for heat resistant material welded part
JP1997072896A
Piping inspection method and piping lifetime determination method
JP2012173217A
