Meta analysis-based calf roughage demand level evaluation method

Through Meta analysis and mixing model, the optimal addition level of calf roughage was determined, which resolved the debate on the impact of calves feeding on growth performance, provided an accurate calves feeding strategy, and improved the growth performance of calves.

CN119090132APending Publication Date: 2024-12-06SICHUAN AGRI UNIV
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411115478.9
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-08-14
Publication Date
2024-12-06

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

There is still debate in the prior art on whether calves should be fed rough feed, with the lack of quantitative evidence and clear rough feed levels, affecting calves' growth performance and rumen health, and the relatively limited number of different rough feed types.

Method used

The regression curves of calves growth performance and rough feed level were constructed using a method based on meta-analysis and combined with mixed models. The optimal addition level of rough feed was determined through meta-analysis, Cochrane's Q test and subgroup analysis, and accurate calves feeding strategies were provided.

Benefits of technology

Through meta-analysis and mixing models, rough feed can improve the growth performance of calves and provide easy-to-operate strategies for calves feeding to help optimize calves feeding methods.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN119090132A_ABST
    Figure CN119090132A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a Meta analysis-based calf roughage demand level evaluation method, which comprises the following steps of: constructing a regression curve of calf growth performance and roughage level by combining Meta analysis with a mixed model, and searching an optimal roughage addition level; the method comprises the following steps: firstly, performing statistics on heterogeneity by adopting Meta analysis and Cochrange's Q test estimation effect; performing subgroup analysis to evaluate the influence of different coarse feed sources on result heterogeneity; and finally, predicting the relationship between the coarse feed level and the growth performance by adopting a mixed model. After literatures are analyzed by using the method, the result shows that the growth performance of the calves can be improved by supplementing the coarse feed; the method is based on meta analysis and explores the influence of roughage on the growth performance of the calves and the optimal roughage feeding level of the calves, so that the feeding method for feeding the calves is accurately obtained; a thought can be provided for accurate feeding of the calves to help the feeding strategy of the calves, and operation is easy and convenient to implement.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of calf roughage feeding, and in particular relates to an evaluation method for calf roughage requirement level based on Meta analysis. Background Art

[0002] In recent years, the debate over whether calves should be fed roughage has received widespread attention, although research in this area began as early as the mid-20th century. Studies in the United States have shown that in the past 20 years, the probability of feeding roughage before weaning has dropped from 86.7% to 43.3%, indicating a change in the concept of dairy producers. Supporters believe that feeding roughage is beneficial to the growth of calves and the improvement of the rumen environment. Some studies have shown that adding roughage to calf starter feed can increase feed intake and feeding efficiency, promote rumination, growth, increase rumen pH and relieve rumen acidosis, and have positive improvements on the appearance of the rumen wall and rumen muscle growth. On the other hand, opponents of feeding roughage believe that calves have an underdeveloped rumen epithelium and limited rumen capacity, and cannot effectively utilize roughage during the milk feeding stage. They should be fed concentrate to promote the production of butyrate and propionate, which is essential for rumen development before weaning. However, concentrates are highly palatable and digestible, with rapidly fermented carbohydrates producing high amounts of volatile fatty acids (VFAs) and potentially aggravating ruminal acidosis in calves by affecting digestibility of nutrients in rumination and saliva as well as in the rumen. Calves require adequate energy and protein to maintain growth and reach recommended weights before weaning. A mature intestine improves feed digestibility, allowing more nutrients to support metabolism and calf growth. Concentrates readily provide nutrients for rumen growth and development. However, feeding roughage affects DM, organic matter (OM), and total nutrient digestibility in dairy cows. The total apparent digestibility of DM, OM, and CP was lower in calves fed roughage compared to calves not fed roughage. In addition, CP digestibility in calves fed alfalfa hay (AH) was higher than that in starter calves not fed roughage, but similar to that in calves fed wheat straw and beet pulp. However, some researchers have noted that no significant differences in DM, OM, or CP digestibility were observed when calves were fed alfalfa hay in addition to a concentrate diet or when they were fed concentrate alone. Many factors have been implicated in confounding the results, including forage source, forage level, physical form of starter, forage feeding method, and milk feeding strategy. Recently, several studies in young calves have found that feeding a total mixed ration (TMR; defined as a mixture of calf starter and forage) is more optimal than feeding a free-choice diet (starter and forage in separate buckets). Adding NDF from AH to calf starter was more effective than adding beet pulp in improving rumen pH and chewing activity, but did not affect starter intake or ADG. Although the issue of feeding forage to growing calves has been explored using meta-analytic tools, questions continue to arise regarding whether forage should be included in calf diets (NRC, 2001). Despite the growing body of research in this area, quantitative evidence for or against feeding forage remains sparse. Furthermore, the ideal roughage level is unclear and different types of roughage have been used in studies.The roughages used in the study included bromide hay, oat hay, and alfalfa. In addition, there are limited comparisons between different roughage types in the literature, despite the potential for differences in the effects of feeding roughage on calf performance. Therefore, the objectives of the present invention are to: (1) evaluate the effects of feeding roughage on growth performance in calves; (2) determine the role of roughage source in heterogeneity in response to roughage feeding; and (3) determine the optimal roughage feeding level for improving growth performance based on data from articles reporting roughage levels. Summary of the invention

[0003] The purpose of the present invention is to overcome the shortcomings of the prior art, and provide an evaluation method for the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis. A regression curve of calf growth performance and roughage level is constructed by Meta analysis combined with a mixed model to find the optimal roughage addition level; firstly, Meta analysis is adopted and Cochrane's Q test is used to estimate the statistical heterogeneity of effect size; then subgroup analysis is performed to evaluate the influence of different roughage sources and roughage supply methods on the heterogeneity of results; finally, a mixed model is used to predict the relationship between roughage level and growth performance; after using this method to analyze the literature, the results show that supplementing roughage can improve the growth performance of calves; the present invention is based on meta analysis and explores the influence of roughage on the growth performance of calves and the optimal roughage level for feeding calves, so as to accurately obtain the feeding method when feeding calves; it can provide ideas for accurate feeding of calves, so as to help calf feeding strategies, and the operation is simple and easy.

[0004] In order to achieve the above technical effects, the following technical solutions are adopted:

[0005] The method for assessing the roughage requirement level of calves based on meta-analysis includes the following steps:

[0006] Step S1: Article retrieval and inclusion

[0007] Search the literature database for research papers published within a certain period of time; the main search terms include but are not limited to: calves, forage, performance;

[0008] According to the PICO principle, the articles were read and the inclusion criteria were used to determine which studies could be included; review articles, survey articles, and articles that did not include randomized controlled trials were excluded;

[0009] The inclusion criteria are as follows: the research subjects of the research paper must be calves; the experiment in the research paper must include a control group that is not fed any roughage and one or more intervention groups that are fed at least one type of roughage;

[0010] Step S2: Data extraction

[0011] Extraction of necessary data information: average daily weight gain (ADG) value of calves in the control group of each research paper, average daily weight gain (ADG) value of calves in the intervention group of each research paper, sample size n and standard deviation SD, and unify the unit of average daily weight gain (ADG) value; construct a meta-analysis database;

[0012] If some research papers only disclose the standard error SE of the intervention group, it is necessary to convert the standard error SE into the standard deviation SD; the conversion formula is:

[0013] Step S3: Data statistics

[0014] All data in step S2 were recorded and then exported to Stata / MP 16.0 for statistical analysis and drawing. The forest plot can be used to simply and intuitively understand the effect of roughage on a certain indicator of calves. When making a forest plot, the mean difference MD and 95% confidence interval are used to describe the effect size of the variable. Due to the differences in experimental methods, animal numbers, and experimental designs in different research papers, the random effects model was selected. At the same time, I 2 The chi-square Q test was used to describe the heterogeneity of the results; the magnitude of heterogeneity was measured using I 2 The values ​​were classified into categories, less than 50% was considered low heterogeneity, and greater than 50% was considered high heterogeneity, indicating that the results of different research papers were quite different;

[0015] If there are 15 or more trials comparing roughage, and the forest plot results indicate that the overall effect of the research indicator is significant and has significant heterogeneity, a roughage subgroup analysis will be performed to explore the extent of the effect of the roughage subgroup on the indicator;

[0016] Step S4: Regression analysis

[0017] Based on the meta-analysis database, the ADG value of each intervention group was used as the dependent variable, the roughage level as the independent variable, and the study as the random effect to generate a database. A mixed model was used to establish a regression relationship between calf ADG and roughage level to obtain the optimal roughage supplementation level, and the mixed model in the lme4 package of the R language was used for fitting.

[0018] The roughage subgroups are OH level and straw level;

[0019] The steps are as follows: 1. Select a suitable functional regression model; 2. Use a mixed model to eliminate the random effects between studies and obtain the model prediction value; 3. Use the prediction value to establish a regression model and fit the curve;

[0020] The selected models include linear mixed models and nonlinear mixed models:

[0021] The linear mixed model function expression is as follows: ij =B 0 +B 1 X ij +s i +b i X ij +e ij ;

[0022] The nonlinear mixed model function expression is as follows: ij =B 0 +B 1 X ij +B 2 X 2 ij +s i +b i X ij +e ij ;

[0023] Among them, Y ij is the dependent variable (i-th study 1, ...m, j-th observation 1, ...n i ), B 0 is the total intercept for all studies, B 1 is the coefficient of the independent variable, B 2 is the quadratic coefficient of the independent variable, X ij is the value of the independent variable, s i is the random effect intercept of the ith study, b i is the random slope associated with the ith study, e ij is the residual;

[0024] R 2 The square root of the estimated residual variance Srrv is used to measure the goodness of the regression model fit. 2 The larger the value is, the smaller the Srrv is, indicating that the model fit is better.

[0025] Furthermore, the databases in step S1 include: Google Scholar, ScienceDirect and X-Mol databases.

[0026] Furthermore, the certain period in step S1 is more than 20 years, the included literature data is at least 15 articles, and the intervention group and the control group are at least 40 groups.

[0027] Furthermore, the PICO principle in step S1 includes research subjects, intervention measures, comparison factors, and diagnosis and treatment results of intervention measures.

[0028] Furthermore, the reading of the paper article in step S1 includes the title, abstract, research method and experimental results.

[0029] Furthermore, the inclusion criteria in step S1 must also provide some basic data on growth performance, including the number, mean value, standard error or standard deviation of the test animals.

[0030] Furthermore, in step S3, Microsoft Excel is used to record all the data in step S2.

[0031] Furthermore, in step S4:

[0032] The relationship between roughage level and ADG is: y = 0.663 + 4.416 × 10 -3 X-1.72×10 -4 X 2 , and the best ADG was achieved at a roughage level of 13%;

[0033] The relationship between OH level and ADG is: y = 0.657 + 0.042 × 10 -3 X-2.826×10 -3 X 2 , the level required to reach the peak ADG is 7%;

[0034] The relationship between straw level and ADG is: y = 0.681 + 0.018X - 9.419 × 10 -4 X 2 , the level required to reach the peak ADG is 9%.

[0035] The beneficial effects of the present invention are:

[0036] The invention discloses an evaluation method for the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis, and a regression curve of calf growth performance and roughage level is constructed by Meta analysis combined with a mixed model to find the optimal roughage addition level; firstly, Meta analysis is adopted and Cochrane's Q test is used to estimate the statistical heterogeneity of effect size; then subgroup analysis is performed to evaluate the influence of different roughage sources on the heterogeneity of results; finally, a mixed model is used to predict the relationship between the roughage level and growth performance; after using this method to analyze literature, the results show that supplementing roughage can improve the growth performance of calves; the invention is based on meta analysis and explores the influence of roughage on the growth performance of calves and the optimal roughage level for feeding calves, so as to accurately obtain the feeding method when feeding calves; it can provide ideas for accurate calf feeding, so as to help calf feeding strategies, and the operation is simple and easy. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0037] In order to more clearly illustrate the embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the description of the prior art will be briefly introduced below. The drawings in the following description are merely embodiments of the present invention. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on the provided drawings without paying any creative work.

[0038] Figure 1 This is a flow chart of document screening for embodiments of the present invention;

[0039] Figure 2 This is a meta-analysis forest diagram of calf ADG in an embodiment of the present invention;

[0040] Figure 3 It is a subgroup analysis diagram of ADG in the whole test of the embodiment of the present invention;

[0041] Figure 4 This is a graph showing the relationship between feed level and ADG of the entire experiment in the embodiment of the present invention;

[0042] Figure 5 is a graph showing the relationship between the OH level and the ADG of the whole test in the embodiment of the present invention;

[0043] Figure 6 4 is a relationship diagram between straw and the ADG of the whole experiment according to an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0044] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the present invention more clearly understood, the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are only used to explain the present invention and are not used to limit the present invention.

[0045] It should be noted that the following detailed descriptions are exemplary and are intended to provide further explanation of the present invention. Unless otherwise specified, all technical and scientific terms used herein have the same meanings as those commonly understood by those skilled in the art to which the present invention belongs.

[0046] It should be noted that the terms used herein are only for describing specific embodiments and are not intended to limit exemplary embodiments according to the present invention. As used herein, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise, the singular form is also intended to include the plural form. In addition, it should be understood that when the terms "comprising" and / or "including" are used in this specification, it indicates the presence of features, steps, operations and / or combinations thereof.

[0047] Embodiment 1:

[0048] Step 1: Literature screening

[0049] Figure 1This is a literature screening flow chart. Search the English literature databases Google Scholar, ScienceDirect, and X-Mol, and search for keywords calves, performance, and forage; and preliminarily screen out the literature that meets the standards from the titles and abstracts according to the PICO principle, with a time range of 2000-2023. Read the full text again, according to the inclusion criteria: 1. The subjects are calves; 2. The trial must include a control group that is not fed any roughage and one or more intervention groups that are fed at least one roughage; 3. Some basic data on growth performance (ADG) must be provided, as well as the number, mean, standard error, or standard deviation of the experimental animals. Finally, 18 documents were included, containing 47 experimental controls.

[0050] Step 2: Build a meta-analysis database

[0051] Necessary data information was extracted: average daily gain (ADG) of calves in the treatment group of each article, ADG value of each treatment group, sample size n and standard deviation SD.

[0052] It should be noted that since the units of some parameters in different articles are different, we try to unify the units. Some articles use the unit of kg / d, and some articles use the unit of g / d, so we unify the unit to kg / d. In addition, most articles only report the standard error (SE) of the treatment group, so we need to use the formula to convert the standard error (SE) to SD:

[0053] Based on the information collected in each article and the level of added roughage in each treatment group, the data were unified and a meta-analysis database was constructed.

[0054] Step 3: Meta-analysis

[0055] Enter the meta-analysis database into stata software and make a forest map ( Figure 2 ), we found that adding roughage to calf starter feed increased the ADG of the entire experiment by 0.03kg / d (P<0.01), indicating that adding roughage had a significant effect on improving the ADG of calves. Moreover, the number of experimental comparisons exceeded 15, and there was significant heterogeneity (I 2 =59.8%, p<0.01). Therefore, we conducted a subgroup analysis of ADG using the roughage source as a classification factor ( Figure 3 ), roughage sources are classified into AH, OH, straw and others. Figure 3 As shown in the results, it was found that both OH (p<0.01) and straw (p<0.01) significantly increased the ADG of calves.2 All were less than 50%, p>0.05, indicating that the results were not heterogeneous and were not affected by other experimental factors.

[0056] Step 4: Regression Analysis

[0057] Based on the meta-analysis database, the ADG value of each intervention group was used as the dependent variable, the roughage level as the independent variable, and the study as the random effect to generate a database. A mixed model was used to establish a regression relationship between calf ADG and roughage level to obtain the optimal roughage supplementation level, and the mixed model in the lme4 package of the R language was used for fitting.

[0058] The roughage subgroups are OH level and straw level;

[0059] The steps are as follows: 1. Select a suitable functional regression model; 2. Use a mixed model to eliminate the random effects between studies and obtain the model prediction value; 3. Use the prediction value to establish a regression model and fit the curve;

[0060] The selected models include linear mixed models and nonlinear mixed models:

[0061] The linear mixed model function expression is as follows: ij =B 0 +B 1 X ij +s i +b i X ij +e ij ;

[0062] The nonlinear mixed model function expression is as follows: ij =B 0 +B 1 X ij +B 2 X 2 ij +s i +b i X ij +e ij ;

[0063] Among them, Y ij is the dependent variable (i-th study 1, ...m, j-th observation 1, ...n i ), B 0 is the total intercept for all studies, B 1 is the coefficient of the independent variable, B 2 is the quadratic coefficient of the independent variable, X ij is the value of the independent variable, s i is the random effect intercept of the ith study, b iis the random slope associated with the ith study, e ij is the residual;

[0064] R 2 The square root of the estimated residual variance Srrv is used to measure the goodness of the regression model fit. 2 The larger the value is, the smaller the Srrv is, indicating that the model fit is better.

[0065] Figure 4-Figure 6 It is the relationship diagram between ADG and roughage level;

[0066] like Figure 4 As shown in Figure 2, the relationship between roughage level and ADG is: y = 0.663 + 4.416 × 10 -3 X-1.72×10 -4 X 2 , and the optimum ADG is achieved at a roughage level of about 13%;

[0067] like Figure 5 As shown in Figure 2, the relationship between OH level and ADG is: y = 0.657 + 0.042 × 10 -3 X-2.826×10 -3 X 2 , the level required to reach the peak of ADG is about 7%;

[0068] like Figure 6 As shown, the relationship between straw level and ADG is: y = 0.681 + 0.018X - 9.419 × 10 -4 X 2 , the level required to reach the ADG peak was approximately 9%.

[0069] In summary, the present invention discloses an evaluation method for the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis, and a regression curve of calf growth performance and roughage level is constructed by Meta analysis combined with a mixed model to find the optimal roughage addition level; firstly, Meta analysis is adopted and Cochrane's Q test is used to estimate the statistical heterogeneity of effect size; then subgroup analysis is performed to evaluate the influence of different roughage sources and roughage supply methods on the heterogeneity of results; finally, a mixed model is used to predict the relationship between roughage level and growth performance; after analyzing the literature using this method, the results show that supplementing roughage can improve the growth performance of calves; the present invention is based on meta analysis and explores the influence of roughage on the growth performance of calves and the optimal roughage level for feeding calves, so as to accurately obtain the feeding method when feeding calves; it can provide ideas for accurate feeding of calves, so as to help calf feeding strategies, and the operation is simple and easy.

[0070] At this point, those skilled in the art recognize that, although the embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described in detail herein, many other variations or modifications that conform to the principles of the present invention can still be directly determined or derived based on the contents disclosed in the present invention without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention. Therefore, the scope of the present invention should be understood and recognized as covering all such other variations or modifications.

Claims

1. Evaluation method of roughage requirement level of calves based on meta-analysis, It is characterized in that The evaluation method comprises the following steps: Step S1: Article retrieval and inclusion Search the literature database for research papers published within a certain period of time; the main search terms include but are not limited to: calves, forage, performance; According to the PICO principle, the articles were read and the inclusion criteria were used to determine which studies could be included; review articles, survey articles, and articles that did not include randomized controlled trials were excluded; The inclusion criteria are as follows: the research subjects of the research paper must be calves; the experiment in the research paper must include a control group that is not fed any roughage and one or more intervention groups that are fed at least one type of roughage; Step S2: Data extraction Extraction of necessary data information: average daily weight gain (ADG) value of calves in the control group of each research paper, average daily weight gain (ADG) value of calves in the intervention group of each research paper, sample size n and standard deviation SD, and unify the unit of average daily weight gain (ADG) value; construct a meta-analysis database; If some research papers only disclose the standard error SE of the intervention group, it is necessary to convert the standard error SE into the standard deviation SD; the conversion formula is: Step S3: Data statistics All data in step S2 were recorded and then exported to Stata / MP 16.0 for statistical analysis and drawing. The forest plot can be used to simply and intuitively understand the effect of roughage on a certain indicator of calves. When making a forest plot, the mean difference MD and 95% confidence interval are used to describe the effect size of the variable. Due to the differences in experimental methods, animal numbers, and experimental designs in different research papers, the random effects model was selected. At the same time, I 2 The chi-square Q test was used to describe the heterogeneity of the results; the magnitude of heterogeneity was measured using I 2 The values ​​were classified into categories, less than 50% was considered low heterogeneity, and greater than 50% was considered high heterogeneity, indicating that the results of different research papers were quite different; If there are 15 or more trials comparing roughage, and the forest plot results indicate that the overall effect of the research indicator is significant and has significant heterogeneity, a roughage subgroup analysis will be performed to explore the extent of the effect of the roughage subgroup on the indicator; Step S4: Regression analysis Based on the meta-analysis database, the ADG value of each intervention group was used as the dependent variable, the roughage level as the independent variable, and the study as the random effect to generate a database. A mixed model was used to establish a regression relationship between calf ADG and roughage level to obtain the optimal roughage supplementation level, and the mixed model in the lme4 package of the R language was used for fitting. The roughage subgroups are OH level and straw level; The steps are as follows:

1. Select a suitable functional regression model; 2. Use a mixed model to eliminate the random effects between studies and obtain the model prediction value; 3. Use the prediction value to establish a regression model and fit the curve; The selected models include linear mixed models and nonlinear mixed models: The linear mixed model function expression is as follows: ij =B 0 +B 1 X ij +s i +b i X ij +e ij ; The nonlinear mixed model function expression is as follows: ij =B 0 +B 1 X ij +B 2 X 2 ij +s i +b i X ij +e ij ; Among them, Y ij is the dependent variable (i-th study 1, ...m, j-th observation 1, ...n i ), B 0 is the total intercept for all studies, B 1 is the coefficient of the independent variable, B 2 is the quadratic coefficient of the independent variable, X ij is the value of the independent variable, s i is the random effect intercept of the ith study, b i is the random slope associated with the ith study, e ij is the residual; R 2 The square root of the estimated residual variance Srrv is used to measure the goodness of the regression model fit. 2 The larger the value is, the smaller the Srrv is, indicating that the model fit is better.

2. The method for evaluating the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis as claimed in claim 1, It is characterized in that The databases in step S1 include: Google Scholar, ScienceDirect and X-Mol databases.

3. The method for evaluating the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis as claimed in claim 1, It is characterized in that The certain period in step S1 is more than 20 years, and the included literature data is at least 15 articles.

4. The method for evaluating the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis as claimed in claim 1, It is characterized in that The PICO principle in step S1 includes research subjects, intervention measures, comparison factors, and diagnosis and treatment results of intervention measures.

5. The method for evaluating the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis as claimed in claim 1, It is characterized in that The reading of the paper article in step S1 includes the title, abstract, research method and experimental results.

6. The method for evaluating the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis as claimed in claim 1, It is characterized in that The inclusion criteria in step S1 must also provide some basic data on growth performance, including the number of test animals, mean value, standard error or standard deviation.

7. The method for evaluating the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis as claimed in claim 1, It is characterized in that In step S3, all the data in step S2 are recorded using Microsoft Excel.

8. The method for evaluating the roughage requirement level of calves based on Meta analysis as claimed in claim 1, It is characterized in that In step S4: The relationship between roughage level and ADG is: y = 0.663 + 4.416 × 10 -3 X-1.72×10 -4 X 2 , and the best ADG was achieved at a roughage level of 13%; The relationship between OH level and ADG is: y = 0.657 + 0.042 × 10 -3 X-2.826×10 -3 X 2 , the level required to reach the peak ADG is 7%; The relationship between straw level and ADG is: y = 0.681 + 0.018X - 9.419 × 10 -4 X 2 , the level required to reach the peak ADG is 9%.