Control evaluation method and system for direct current commutation safety and system stability coordination
By designing a control evaluation method for coordination between DC commutation safety and system stability, calculating dynamic sensitivity indicators and control costs, and optimizing coordination control strategies, the interaction between DC commutation failure and system stability problems is solved, and the safety and stability of the power grid is improved. Control adaptability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410863047.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-06-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology is difficult to effectively coordinate DC phase conversion failure and system stability issues, which leads to threatening the safety and stability of the power grid, and a single control strategy may cause the risk of chain failures.
A control evaluation method that coordinates DC commutation safety and system stability is designed. By designing control scenario parameters, calculating dynamic sensitivity indicators, determining optimal control measures, and evaluating control costs, the optimization of coordinated control strategies is achieved.
Through coordinated control strategies, control costs are reduced, the system security and stability level is improved, the risk of chain failure is avoided, and the adaptability to complex interaction situations is enhanced.
Smart Images

Figure CN118971102A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of power system automatic control, and in particular to a control evaluation method and system for coordination of direct current commutation safety and system stability. Background Art
[0002] With the construction of UHV DC projects, commutation failures in multi-feed DC systems will cause a power shock of tens of millions of kilowatts to the system, and continuous commutation failures may lead to DC lockout, seriously threatening the safe and stable operation of the power grid. On the other hand, the voltage problems and local power angle problems caused by the hollowing out of transient reactive support in the receiving system, as well as the frequency stability problems caused by permanent or short-circuit faults are prominent. That is, for AC systems with multiple DC feeds, DC equipment safety and system stability problems coexist. The interaction between DC commutation failure and system instability causes large fluctuations and transfers in the system's active and reactive power, which in turn affects the power angle, voltage and frequency of the nearby AC system. Existing technologies optimize control measures for single stability problems. However, for different power grids, DC commutation failures are intertwined with stability problems such as system power angle, voltage, and frequency. From a control perspective, solving a single problem may exacerbate the evolution of another problem and cause a risk of chain failures.
[0003] Therefore, it is necessary to improve the control algorithm when searching for control strategies, and design an emergency control strategy heuristic iterative search algorithm with dynamic correction of comprehensive sensitivity indicators to improve the adaptability of the emergency control algorithm to handle complex interactions between DC and the system. In addition, since the existing stability control system is often designed for a single stability problem, in order to facilitate reliable execution, there is less interaction between control systems. The control of DC commutation failure and the control of system stability will inevitably require the two stability control systems to interact. From the perspective of control effect and economic benefits, the transformation of stability control is meaningful only when the coordinated control has a superimposed average control cost greater than a certain degree compared to the traditional single set of stability control. It is necessary to intuitively characterize the effect of reducing the coordinated control cost, which is conducive to control decision-making and planning and design at the device implementation level, and reduces the risk of system blackouts. Summary of the invention
[0004] In view of the problems existing in the existing control evaluation method for DC commutation safety and system stability coordination, the present invention is proposed. Therefore, the problem to be solved by the present invention is how to provide a control evaluation method and system for DC commutation safety and system stability coordination.
[0005] In order to solve the above technical problems, the present invention provides the following technical solutions:
[0006] In the first aspect, the present invention provides a control evaluation method for the coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability, which includes designing control scenario parameters, defining fault types and durations to construct a coordinated control scenario set; formulating control strategies for DC commutation safety and system stability, calculating dynamic sensitivity indicators for each control scenario, and performing dynamic sensitivity analysis to determine optimal control measures; calculating the control cost and average reduction value of the control cost of the control strategy, and evaluating the control effects of different control strategies based on the average reduction value of the control cost.
[0007] As a preferred scheme of the control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability described in the present invention, wherein: the design control scenario parameters include adjusting the DC system operation mode, the DC near-zone startup mode, the system load level and the section classification power; the fault types include single-phase short circuit three-phase tripping fault, single-phase short circuit single-phase reclosing failure fault, line / main transformer three-phase short circuit three-phase tripping fault, line / main transformer three-phase short circuit reclosing fault, three-phase short circuit single-phase switch refusal to operate fault; the fault clearing time is set according to different levels of line main protection actions; the scenario of synchronous power grid instability or commutation failure is constructed as a coordinated control scenario set.
[0008] As a preferred solution of the control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability of the present invention, wherein: the calculation of the dynamic sensitivity index of each control scenario includes calculating the dynamic sensitivity index of the control measures for emergency control search for the coordinated control scenario, and the calculation formula is:
[0009]
[0010] In the formula, σ z , η δ / V / f are the commutation safety margin of DC z and the system safety stability margin before control is applied, N is the total number of DC feeds into the receiving grid; Δσ z (h), Δη δ / V / f (h) are the changes in the commutation safety margin of DC z and the system safety stability margin after applying control measure h.
[0011] As a preferred solution of the control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability described in the present invention, the method comprises the following steps: the method of performing dynamic sensitivity analysis to determine the optimal control measure comprises the following steps: establishing a library containing all control measures according to system characteristics and control requirements; measuring the initial commutation safety margin and system stability margin of the system when no control measures are taken, and calculating the dynamic sensitivity indexes of all measures for each control scenario; sorting all control measures according to the size of the dynamic sensitivity index, and selecting the control measure with the highest dynamic sensitivity index from the sorted list as the preferred strategy; performing time domain simulation on the selected optimal control measure using power system simulation software, and adjusting the conversion coefficient based on the simulation results; performing dynamic sensitivity analysis again based on the updated system state, selecting the next optimal measure, and repeating the process until the system stability margin and the multiple DC commutation indexes are both greater than 0, that is, the system is considered to have reached the target state of coordinated control; after completing the iterative optimization, determining the control measure combination as the optimal coordinated control strategy, further solidifying and deploying it into the actual stable control system.
[0012] As a preferred solution of the control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability of the present invention, the control cost of the control strategy is calculated by clarifying all control measures, including active control and reactive control, determining the specific control amount for implementing each control measure for each specific scenario, and calculating the control cost index under the fault scenario. The calculation formula is:
[0013]
[0014] In the formula, P is the active control measures and control quantity required in the control scenario, λ is the corresponding unit control cost, Q is the reactive control measures and control quantity required, and γ is the corresponding unit control cost. The control cost after the traditional commutation failure acceleration protection and the instability of the synchronous power grid is calculated. The control cost after the traditional commutation failure acceleration protection and the instability of the synchronous power grid is superimposed as follows:
[0015]
[0016] The control cost after comprehensive coordination of multi-infeed DC commutation safety and synchronous power grid safety and stability is:
[0017]
[0018] The control cost under the coordinated control strategy is combined with the control cost before coordinated control to obtain the control cost of the control strategy.
[0019] As a preferred solution of the control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability of the present invention, the average reduction value of the control cost includes the control cost based on the traditional commutation failure acceleration section protection, the control cost after the instability of the synchronous power grid, and the control cost after the comprehensive coordination of multi-input DC commutation safety and synchronous power grid safety and stability. The calculation formula is:
[0020]
[0021] Where ΔY% is the average reduction value of the control cost; the control effects of different control strategies are evaluated based on the average reduction value of the control cost.
[0022] As a preferred solution of the control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability described in the present invention, wherein: the control effect of evaluating different control strategies includes: when the average reduction value of the control cost is greater than 10%, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be a high-efficiency level; if the coordinated control strategy shortens the system recovery time by more than 20% under specific fault conditions in the system simulation, and does not increase other stability indicators, the control strategy is sent to the stabilization control device; if the coordinated control strategy is used in actual application, the control cost reduction value is lower than the set cost reduction limit, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be a medium-efficiency level; when 5%<the average reduction value of the control cost is ≤10%, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be a medium-efficiency level. After the coordinated control strategy is implemented, if in a large If the system recovery speed cannot be improved or commutation failure occurs during the load simulation test of the load change ±10%, the coordinated control strategy is deemed to be inefficient; when the average reduction in control cost is ≤5%, the coordinated control strategy is deemed to be inefficient. If, after the implementation of the coordinated control strategy, it is verified by simulation that the control cost can be saved and the voltage stability margin can be improved, and it has a positive impact on voltage stability in the system simulation, the coordinated control strategy is deemed to be medium-efficient, and corresponding measures are linearly superimposed according to multiple instability scenarios; if the coordinated control strategy fails to achieve a cost reduction in all test scenarios, the average reduction in control cost calculation is re-entered. When the coordinated control strategy is again deemed to be inefficient, it is removed from the recommended coordinated control strategy.
[0023] In the second aspect, the present invention provides a control evaluation system for coordinating DC commutation safety and system stability, which includes: a construction module for designing control scenario parameters, defining fault types and durations to construct a coordinated control scenario set; an analysis module for formulating control strategies for DC commutation safety and system stability, calculating dynamic sensitivity indicators for each control scenario, and performing dynamic sensitivity analysis to determine optimal control measures; an evaluation module for calculating the control cost of the control strategy and the average reduction in the control cost, and evaluating the control effects of different control strategies based on the average reduction in the control cost.
[0024] In a third aspect, the present invention provides a computer device comprising a memory and a processor, wherein the memory stores a computer program, wherein: when the processor executes the computer program, the steps of a control evaluation method for coordinating DC commutation safety and system stability are implemented.
[0025] In a fourth aspect, the present invention provides a computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, wherein: when the computer program is executed by a processor, the steps of a control evaluation method for coordinating DC commutation safety and system stability are implemented.
[0026] The beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: by combining the cross-coupling relationship between multi-input DC commutation safety and system stability, a coordinated control strategy search method based on global optimization is formulated to avoid the risk of cascading failures caused by negative control effects, and to achieve evaluation after the control search path and control target are jointly optimized, which is conducive to the construction of system-level defense methods and improves the system safety and stability level and the adaptability of the safety and stability control strategy. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0027] In order to more clearly illustrate the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention, the following briefly introduces the drawings required for use in the description of the embodiments. Obviously, the drawings described below are only some embodiments of the present invention. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without creative work.
[0028] Figure 1 Flowchart of the control evaluation method for the coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability.
[0029] Figure 2 This is the structural diagram of the multi-DC feed receiving end.
[0030] Figure 3 This is a diagram showing the control effects of various resource control measures on commutation failure.
[0031] Figure 4 This is a diagram showing the control effects of various resource control measures on system stability. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0032] In order to make the above-mentioned purposes, features and advantages of the present invention more understandable, the specific implementation methods of the present invention are described in detail below in conjunction with the drawings of the specification. Obviously, the described embodiments are part of the embodiments of the present invention, but not all of them. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary persons in the art without creative work should fall within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0033] In the following description, many specific details are set forth to facilitate a full understanding of the present invention, but the present invention may also be implemented in other ways different from those described herein, and those skilled in the art may make similar generalizations without violating the connotation of the present invention. Therefore, the present invention is not limited to the specific embodiments disclosed below.
[0034] Secondly, the term "one embodiment" or "embodiment" as used herein refers to a specific feature, structure, or characteristic that may be included in at least one implementation of the present invention. The term "in one embodiment" that appears in different places in this specification does not necessarily refer to the same embodiment, nor does it refer to a separate or selective embodiment that is mutually exclusive with other embodiments.
[0035] Example 1
[0036] Reference Figure 1 , which is the first embodiment of the present invention, provides a control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability, comprising:
[0037] S1: Design control scenario parameters, define fault types and durations to build a coordinated control scenario set;
[0038] Specifically, we build a coordinated control scenario set, design control scenario parameters, adjust the DC system operation mode, DC near-zone startup mode, system load level, and cross-section power for the standard model, and build multiple operation modes to cover different power balance strategies and fault tolerance capabilities.
[0039] Define fault types and durations, simulate complex situations from single-phase short circuits to three-phase faults, and the corresponding protection responses, combine fault scenarios with operating modes to form a set of control scenarios, covering all critical situations that may lead to synchronous power grid instability or commutation failure.
[0040] For the standard model, the operation mode is adjusted, and a control scenario set of synchronous grid instability or multi-infeed DC commutation failure is constructed through comprehensive fault scanning, where the mode adjustment strategy steps are:
[0041] DC system operation mode: Considering different transmission powers of multi-input DC, DC control and protection methods, etc., it is represented by A, where A=1, 2…t represents different transmission powers and control schemes respectively. The unbalanced power is borne by all power supplies in the system;
[0042] DC near-zone startup mode: adjust the startup combination of DC near-zone synchronous units, represented by B, where B=1, 2…k represent different startup modes respectively, and the unbalanced power is borne by the near-zone renewable energy;
[0043] System load level: adjust the local or overall system load level, represented by C, where C = 1, 2…m represents different load levels. The unbalanced power is borne by all local or system power sources;
[0044] Section power grading: adjust the internal power supply sending section and cross-region section power grading, represented by D, D = 1, 2...n represent different power levels respectively, and the unbalanced power is borne by the power supplies on both sides of the section.
[0045] The steps of the fault adjustment strategy are:
[0046] Fault type: consider single-phase short circuit three-phase tripping fault, single-phase short circuit single-phase reclosing failure fault, line / main transformer three-phase short circuit three-phase tripping fault, line / main transformer three-phase short circuit with reclosing fault, three-phase short circuit single-phase switch refusal fault, represented by E, E=1,2…p represents different fault types respectively;
[0047] Fault duration: The fault clearing time setting of the main protection action of different levels of lines is as specified in the guidelines. The failure protection action time is 0.25s, and the reclosing time is 1s or 1.3s.
[0048] According to the above four factors and two fault factors, after permutation and combination, the scenarios of synchronous grid instability (system power angle / voltage / frequency stability margin is less than zero) or commutation failure (commutation safety margin is less than zero) are formed. As the scenarios that require comprehensive coordinated control, they are represented by S, where S=1,2…q represents different control scenarios. Among them, synchronous grid instability includes at least one instability form such as power angle, voltage, and frequency.
[0049] S2: Formulate control strategies for DC commutation safety and system stability, calculate dynamic sensitivity indicators for each control scenario, and perform dynamic sensitivity analysis to determine the optimal control measures;
[0050] Specifically, a dynamic control strategy is formulated and optimized. For each control scenario, the dynamic sensitivity index calculation formula is used to evaluate the effects of various emergency control measures and conduct dynamic sensitivity analysis. This index comprehensively considers the changes in the commutation safety margin and the system stability margin to determine the optimal control measures. This process involves comparing the states before and after control to ensure that the measures can effectively improve system stability without causing other side effects.
[0051] After each time the most sensitive control measure is selected, its actual effect is verified through time domain simulation, the system state is updated and the control sensitivity is recalculated, and it is continuously iterated until a control path that can restore commutation safety and maintain system stability is found. The process also involves refreshing the conversion coefficient to ensure the gradual optimization and accuracy of the control strategy.
[0052] Control strategy evaluation and cost optimization, calculate the control effect and control cost, quantify the control cost for each control strategy, including the cost of active control and reactive control, and use the control cost formula to calculate the overall control cost under specific fault scenarios.
[0053] For the scenario that requires coordinated control, the dynamic sensitivity index of a certain control measure h used for emergency control search is calculated using the following formula:
[0054]
[0055] In the formula, σ z , η δ / V / f are the commutation safety margin of DC z and the system safety stability margin before control is applied, N is the total number of DC feeds into the receiving grid; Δσ z (h), Δη δ / V / f (h) are the changes in the commutation safety margin and system safety stability margin of DC z after applying control measure h; the value range of the commutation margin and the system stability margin are both [-1, 1].
[0056] According to the system characteristics and control requirements, a library containing all control measures is established. These measures may include but are not limited to regulating DC power, starting standby units, adjusting reactive compensation equipment, adjusting load distribution, etc. Each measure corresponds to its application scope and potential effect in the system.
[0057] The initial commutation safety margin and system stability margin of the system are measured when no control measures are taken. For each control scenario, the dynamic sensitivity index of all measures is calculated. These changes are compared with the original state to evaluate the immediate improvement effect of each measure. The higher the dynamic sensitivity index of the measure, the greater its effect on improving system stability and commutation safety.
[0058] All control measures are ranked according to the size of the dynamic sensitivity index. Priority is given to those measures that can provide the greatest sensitivity gain, which means that these measures theoretically have the most significant improvement in system stability.
[0059] From the ranked list, the control measure with the highest dynamic sensitivity index is selected as the preferred strategy.
[0060] The selected optimal control measures are simulated in the time domain using power system simulation software. This step is to verify the consistency between the theoretical analysis results and the actual situation, and to check the actual effects of the selected measures under actual operating conditions, including the direct impact on the equipment safety margin and system stability margin.
[0061] Based on the simulation results, if some assumptions or coefficients are found to deviate from the actual situation, the conversion coefficients need to be adjusted accordingly to more accurately reflect the dynamic characteristics of the system. Based on the updated system status, the dynamic sensitivity analysis is performed again, the next optimal measure is selected, and the above process is repeated. This iterative process ensures the continuous optimization of the control strategy until all key stability indicators are above the safety threshold.
[0062] During the whole process, the system stability margin and multi-DC commutation indicators are continuously monitored to ensure that they gradually converge to the safety area above 0. Once all indicators meet the predetermined safety standards, the system is considered to have reached the target state of coordinated control.
[0063] After completing the above iterative optimization, the final combination of control measures is the optimal coordinated control strategy, which can be further solidified and deployed into the actual stabilization system to automatically respond to similar unstable conditions that may occur in the future.
[0064] S3: Calculate the control cost and average reduction value of the control cost of the control strategy, and evaluate the control effects of different control strategies based on the average reduction value of the control cost.
[0065] Specifically, a coordinated control benefit evaluation is conducted, the control costs under the traditional single fault response strategy and the comprehensive coordinated control strategy are compared, the average reduction in control cost is calculated, and based on the control strategy evaluation results, the optimal control strategy is selected and sent to the system to ensure that the safety of DC commutation and the overall stability of the system can be effectively improved in actual operation, while minimizing the economic cost and social impact of control actions.
[0066] Identify all possible control measures, including active power control (such as regulating DC power P, regulating renewable energy generation, regulating hydropower output, cutting off synchronous generators or renewable energy, etc.) and reactive power control (such as switching on static reactive power compensation, emergency control of phase-shifting devices, etc.). For each specific scenario, determine the specific control quantity for implementing each control measure, such as the amplitude of DC power regulation, the capacity of generators to be cut off, etc.
[0067] Based on the control amount and unit control cost coefficient of the control measures, the total control cost of all control measures in each scenario is calculated.
[0068] The active control measures and control quantities required in a certain control scenario are represented by P, where P = 1, 2…r represents modulation of DC, regulation of renewable energy power, regulation of hydropower, removal of synchronous machines, removal of renewable energy, removal of pumped storage, etc. The corresponding unit control cost is represented by λ, λ = 1, 2…r; the reactive control measures and control quantities required are represented by Q, where Q = 1, 2…w represents switching of static reactive compensation, emergency control of phase-shifting devices, etc. The corresponding unit control cost is represented by γ, γ = 1, 2…w. The control cost index under a certain fault scenario is calculated using the following formula:
[0069]
[0070] Calculate the control cost of the traditional commutation failure acceleration section protection and the synchronous power grid instability. The control cost of the traditional commutation failure acceleration section protection and the synchronous power grid instability is superimposed as follows:
[0071]
[0072] The control cost calculation steps for traditional commutation failure acceleration protection and synchronous power grid instability are as follows:
[0073] The emergency control measures after the failure of a single commutation of traditional DC are mainly to prevent the damage of the converter valve caused by multiple continuous commutation failures of DC. The emergency control measures are mainly emergency reactive control, such as reactive control means that send commands to the phase regulator, filter, and reactive compensator through stable control, or emergency DC power reduction, etc. The sensitivity of the measures is the change in commutation margin Δσ after the implementation of measure j. s (j) characterization;
[0074] The emergency control measures for single instability of traditional systems include cutting generators, cutting loads, cutting pumped storage, and modulating DC / new energy / energy storage. The sensitivity of the measures is the change in system stability margin Δη after applying measure i. δ / V / f (i) Characterization;
[0075] The control cost after comprehensive coordination of multi-infeed DC commutation safety and synchronous power grid safety and stability is:
[0076]
[0077] Calculate the average reduction value of the control cost, the calculation formula is:
[0078]
[0079] When the average reduction value of the control cost is greater than 10%, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be at the high-efficiency level. If the coordinated control strategy reduces the system recovery time by more than 20% under specific fault conditions in the system simulation and does not increase other stability indicators, the control strategy will be sent to the stability control device; if the coordinated control strategy reduces the control cost by less than the set cost reduction limit in actual application, the coordinated control strategy will be changed to the medium-efficiency level;
[0080] When 5% < average reduction in control cost ≤ 10%, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be medium-efficiency. After the coordinated control strategy is implemented, if the system recovery speed cannot be improved or commutation failure occurs in the large load change ±10% system load simulation test, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be low-efficiency.
[0081] When the average reduction value of the control cost is ≤5%, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be inefficient. If after the coordinated control strategy is implemented, it is verified by simulation that the control cost can be saved and the voltage stability margin can be improved, and it has a positive impact on the voltage stability in the system simulation, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be medium-efficient, and corresponding measures are linearly superimposed according to multiple instability scenarios.
[0082] If the coordinated control strategy fails to achieve cost savings or system performance improvement in all test scenarios, the average reduction numerical calculation of the control cost will be re-entered. When the coordinated control strategy is again identified as inefficient, it will be removed from the recommended coordinated control strategy.
[0083] Furthermore, this embodiment also provides a control evaluation system for coordinating DC commutation safety and system stability, including: a construction module, used to design control scenario parameters, define fault types and durations to construct a coordinated control scenario set; an analysis module, used to formulate control strategies for DC commutation safety and system stability, calculate the dynamic sensitivity index of each control scenario, and perform dynamic sensitivity analysis to determine the optimal control measures; an evaluation module, used to calculate the control cost of the control strategy and the average reduction value of the control cost, and evaluate the control effects of different control strategies according to the average reduction value of the control cost.
[0084] This embodiment also provides a computer device, which is suitable for the control evaluation method of coordinating DC commutation safety and system stability, including: a memory and a processor; the memory is used to store computer executable instructions, and the processor is used to execute computer executable instructions to implement all or part of the steps of the method described in the embodiment of the present invention as proposed in the above embodiment.
[0085] This embodiment also provides a storage medium, on which a computer program is stored, and when the computer program is executed by a processor, the method in any optional implementation of the above embodiment is executed. Wherein, the storage medium can be implemented by any type of volatile or non-volatile storage device or a combination thereof, such as static random access memory (Static Random Access Memory, referred to as SRAM), electrically erasable programmable read-only memory (Electrically Erasable Programmable Read-Only Memory, referred to as EEPROM), erasable programmable read-only memory (Erasable Programmable Read-Only Memory, referred to as EPROM), programmable read-only memory (Programmable Red-Only Memory, referred to as PROM), read-only memory (Read-Only Memory, referred to as ROM), magnetic memory, flash memory, disk or optical disk.
[0086] The storage medium proposed in this embodiment and the data storage method proposed in the above embodiment belong to the same inventive concept. The technical details not fully described in this embodiment can be found in the above embodiment, and this embodiment has the same beneficial effects as the above embodiment.
[0087] From the above, it can be seen that this method combines the cross-coupling relationship between multi-input DC commutation safety and system stability, develops a coordinated control strategy search method based on global optimization, avoids the risk of cascading failures caused by negative control effects, proposes a coordinated control method effect evaluation index, and realizes the evaluation after the control search path and control target are jointly optimized, which is conducive to the construction of system-level defense methods and improves the safety and stability level of the system. Avoid using only a single problem control optimization method to represent the risk leakage problem that may exist in the entire system and key equipment, and improve the adaptability of the safety and stability control strategy.
[0088] Example 2
[0089] Reference Figure 2 - Figure 4 , which is the second embodiment of the present invention, and this embodiment provides a control evaluation method for the coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability. In order to verify the beneficial effects of the present invention, scientific demonstration is carried out through economic benefit calculation and simulation experiments.
[0090] The method of the present invention is now described with a practical example. Figure 2The multi-DC feed-in receiving-end power grid shown in the figure is based on the receiving-end system network structure of IEEE10 machines and 39 nodes with two DC feed-ins. The total system load is 1000MW, and the constant power model is adopted. The active frequency response coefficient of the load is L=2.0; there are 7 synchronous machines with an inertia time constant of 4s, 3 wind farms with rated capacities of 100MW, 50MW and 50MW respectively, and the DC is respectively placed on bus 17 and bus 26, and the DC feed-in power is 200MW. An instantaneous metallic grounding fault occurs between BUS16-BUS17, and the fault disappears after 0.2s. The simultaneous commutation failure of the two DC loops and the system frequency instability coexist.
[0091] From the perspective of single control, reactive power control of DC can reduce the risk of subsequent DC commutation failure, thereby reducing the depth of transient frequency drop. Measures include DC power reduction, emergency excitation of phase-shifting devices, emergency capacitive reactive power, and reactive power support of energy storage. For the control of transient low-frequency of the system, traditional rigid control resources only support one-way control, which is easy to cause chain high frequency after dealing with short-term transient low-frequency. Therefore, it is advisable to use flexible new energy and energy storage to release energy urgently, or to provide power support by short-term boosting of DC that has not entered commutation failure. From the perspective of control effect, there is a contradiction between short-term active frequency support and reactive voltage support. The indicators proposed in this paper are used to conduct sensitivity analysis on the adjustment direction of control measures, and then determine the coordinated control scheme.
[0092] Depend on Figure 3 It can be seen that after taking the measures of DC emergency power reduction and emergency reactive power control, the DC commutation failure has been improved, but Figure 4 It can be seen that the DC emergency power reduction needs to be strictly coordinated with the reduction time, reduction power, and callback after the reduction. If the coordination is not appropriate, the system frequency stability characteristics may be deteriorated, resulting in a negative control effect. Using the control measures shown in the table below, through three rounds of coordinated control strategy search, the system frequency is finally restored to above the first round of low-frequency load reduction action threshold [49.4Hz, 0.3s], and the control cost is less than the traditional single search commutation failure and single search system frequency stability control measures.
[0093] Table 1 Comparison of control measures
[0094]
[0095]
[0096] by Figure 2 The case study is the research object. In addition to the coexistence of system frequency stability and commutation failure in the grid, there is also the coexistence of power angle instability and DC commutation failure. By continuously increasing the proportion of new energy and load power, and adjusting the power of different DC gears, there are a total of 8 cases of DC commutation safety or system instability, which can be obtained through case search.
[0097] Table 2 Control cost
[0098] Serial number Coordination and control cost / 10,000 yuan Traditional control cost / 10,000 yuan 1 11 15 2 30 50 3 42 69 4 56 90 5 66 72 6 3 3 7 7 7 8 9 9 Total control cost 224 315
[0099] The cost of coordinated control is calculated against the cost of traditional single-problem single-solution, and the average control cost is reduced by 40%. At the same time, the coordinated control measures in the case are the same as the traditional control measures. For the system, a single control measure is effective for multiple problems at the same time. Based on the average control cost evaluation, it is necessary to integrate the emergency control of DC commutation failure and the emergency control of system stability in the same control master station, and statistically monitor the phase regulator, reactive resources, energy storage, etc. as control substations, which can reduce the control amount and improve the control efficiency.
[0100] It should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the preferred embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that the technical solutions of the present invention may be modified or replaced by equivalents without departing from the spirit and scope of the technical solutions of the present invention, which should all be included in the scope of the claims of the present invention.
Claims
1. A control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability, characterized in that: include, Design control scenario parameters, define fault types and durations to build a coordinated control scenario set; Formulate control strategies for DC commutation safety and system stability, calculate dynamic sensitivity indicators for each control scenario, and conduct dynamic sensitivity analysis to determine the optimal control measures; The control cost and the average reduction value of the control cost of the control strategy are calculated, and the control effects of different control strategies are evaluated based on the average reduction value of the control cost.
2. The control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability according to claim 1 is characterized in that: The design control scenario parameters include adjusting the DC system operation mode, DC near-zone startup mode, system load level and section power classification; the fault types include single-phase short circuit three-phase tripping fault, single-phase short circuit single-phase reclosing failure fault, line / main transformer three-phase short circuit three-phase tripping fault, line / main transformer three-phase short circuit reclosing fault, three-phase short circuit single-phase switch refusal to operate fault; the fault clearing time is set according to the main protection actions of different levels of lines; the scenario of synchronous power grid instability or phase change failure is constructed as a coordinated control scenario set.
3. The control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability according to claim 2, characterized in that: The calculation of the dynamic sensitivity index of each control scenario includes calculating the dynamic sensitivity index of the control measures used for emergency control search for the coordinated control scenario, and the calculation formula is: In the formula, σ z , η δ / V / f are the commutation safety margin of DC z and the system safety stability margin before control is applied, N is the total number of DC feeds into the receiving grid; Δσ z (h), Δη δ / V / f (h) are the changes in the commutation safety margin of DC z and the system safety stability margin after applying control measure h.
4. The control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability according to claim 3 is characterized in that: The dynamic sensitivity analysis to determine the optimal control measures comprises the following steps: Establish a library containing all control measures according to system characteristics and control requirements; Measure the initial commutation safety margin and system stability margin of the system when no control measures are taken, and calculate the dynamic sensitivity index of all measures for each control scenario; Sort all control measures according to the size of the dynamic sensitivity index, and select the control measure with the highest dynamic sensitivity index from the sorted list as the preferred strategy; Use power system simulation software to simulate the selected optimal control measures in the time domain, and adjust the conversion coefficient based on the simulation results; Based on the updated system state, dynamic sensitivity analysis is performed again to select the next optimal measure and repeat the process until the system stability margin and multi-DC commutation index are both greater than 0, which means that the system has reached the target state of coordinated control. After completing the iterative optimization, the combination of control measures is determined to be the optimal coordinated control strategy, which is further solidified and deployed into the actual stabilization control system.
5. The control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability according to claim 4 is characterized in that: The control cost of the control strategy is calculated by clarifying all control measures, including active control and reactive control, determining the specific control amount of each control measure for each specific scenario, and calculating the control cost index under the fault scenario. The calculation formula is: In the formula, P is the active control measures and control quantity required in the control scenario, λ is the corresponding unit control cost, Q is the reactive control measures and control quantity required, and γ is the corresponding unit control cost; Calculate the control cost of the traditional commutation failure acceleration section protection and the synchronous power grid instability. The control cost of the traditional commutation failure acceleration section protection and the synchronous power grid instability is superimposed as follows: The control cost after comprehensive coordination of multi-infeed DC commutation safety and synchronous power grid safety and stability is: The control cost under the coordinated control strategy is combined with the control cost before coordinated control to obtain the control cost of the control strategy.
6. The control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability according to claim 5, characterized in that: The average reduction value of the control cost includes the control cost calculated based on the traditional commutation failure acceleration stage protection, the control cost after the synchronous power grid is unstable, and the control cost after the multi-infeed DC commutation safety and the synchronous power grid safety and stability are comprehensively coordinated. The calculation formula is: Where ΔY% is the average reduction value of the control cost; The control effects of different control strategies are evaluated based on the average reduction value of the control cost.
7. The control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability according to claim 6, characterized in that: The evaluation of the control effects of different control strategies includes: When the average reduction in control cost is greater than 10%, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be highly efficient. If the coordinated control strategy reduces the system recovery time by more than 20% under specific fault conditions in system simulation and does not increase other stability indicators, the control strategy will be sent to the stabilization control device. If the coordinated control strategy reduces the control cost by less than the set cost reduction limit in actual application, the coordinated control strategy will be changed to a medium-efficiency level. When 5% < average reduction in control cost ≤ 10%, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be medium-efficiency. After the coordinated control strategy is implemented, if the system recovery speed cannot be improved or commutation failure occurs in the large load change ±10% system load simulation test, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be low-efficiency. When the average reduction value of the control cost is ≤5%, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be inefficient. If after the coordinated control strategy is implemented, it is verified by simulation that the control cost can be saved and the voltage stability margin can be improved, and it has a positive impact on the voltage stability in the system simulation, the coordinated control strategy is considered to be medium-efficient, and corresponding measures are linearly superimposed according to multiple instability scenarios. If the coordinated control strategy fails to achieve cost reduction in all test scenarios, the average reduction numerical calculation of control cost will be re-entered, and when the coordinated control strategy is identified as inefficient again, it will be removed from the recommended coordinated control strategy.
8. A control evaluation system for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability, based on the control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability according to any one of claims 1 to 7, characterized in that: include, Building module, used to design control scenario parameters, define fault types and durations to build a coordinated control scenario set; Analysis module, used to formulate control strategies for DC commutation safety and system stability, calculate dynamic sensitivity indicators for each control scenario, and perform dynamic sensitivity analysis to determine the optimal control measures; The evaluation module is used to calculate the control cost of the control strategy and the average reduction value of the control cost, and evaluate the control effects of different control strategies according to the average reduction value of the control cost.
9. A computer device comprising a memory and a processor, wherein the memory stores a computer program, wherein: When the processor executes the computer program, the steps of the control evaluation method for coordination of DC commutation safety and system stability as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 7 are implemented.
10. A computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, characterized in that: When the computer program is executed by a processor, the steps of the control evaluation method for coordinating DC commutation safety and system stability as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 7 are implemented.
