Implementation of the technologies thus used requires very substantial investments and has very high transportation costs (marine liquefaction and reception facilities).
However, these opportunities are too small to justify the use of technologies intended for large-scale production (the transposition of conventional technologies is not appropriate, as they are too complex and cannot be used to support the economic viability of these technologies), hence the need to propose new technologies that can meet the two main challenges relating to liquefaction on a small scale:reducing investment costs as much as possible while keeping efficiency as high as possible in order to minimize operating costs; andincreasing the efficiency of the method so as to minimize product loss: the gas volumes to be upcycled are small, which makes every molecule important.
This
system has several drawbacks:plate heat exchangers are very sensitive to the distribution of fluids, which poses a problem of marine
adaptation for the marine applications;the coolant mixture has a significant number of components, especially heavy compounds, and these compounds crystallize in the heat exchangers under particular pressure and temperature conditions whose arrival is difficult to forecast; andthe method has limited flexibility, especially in terms of operating flow rate, and a limited production capacity per compression means.
For the CII
system the main drawbacks are that:the CII method had been developed for large-scale LNG production on land;the method is not very flexible: efficiency drops significantly with any deviation from the operating / design point;the coolant mixture contains too many constituents (hydrocarbons), making the logistics and operational aspect more complex;storage increases the weight of the facilities, critical for offshore facilities;the method has difficulties concerning the ethane supply, which poses significant difficulties for offshore facilities;the method presents risks of alteration to the equipment (exchangers) due to the risk of
crystallization of the
pentane (iC5 and nC5) contained in the coolant mixture;the efficiency of the method is limited by the dimensions of the exchanger and by manufacturing constraints; andthe method presents problems concerning the installation of equipment at sea (significant drop in the performance of the plate exchanger if the distribution is not right).
A casing can contain from eight to a maximum of ten wheels; the greater the number, the more the compressor is likely to present stability problems.
Conversely, reducing the investment leads to solutions that are less efficient and / or significantly less flexible.
Conversely, a reduction in the number of casings results in a loss of operational flexibility, sometimes accompanied by a loss of efficiency.
However, with or without a multiplication mechanism, the rotation speeds must be proportional or identical, depending on the case, which makes the compression
train inflexible when the flow rates entering each section are not identical or proportional.
In addition, a large drop in efficiency is observed in the high-pressure section, even more significant when one wishes to include both sections in a single casing.
Lastly, this configuration is not very flexible, which limits the field of opportunities that can be addressed: a drop in efficiency, which can be significant, can be observed if one deviates from the
operating point for which the equipment was sized (natural gas, and precise production conditions) and
mechanical stability problems can occur leading to more frequent maintenance.
The current CII systems present the following drawbacks:a variation in the flow rate between the low-pressure and high-pressure sections of the compression
train leading to an imbalance between these two sections, which can lead to
mechanical instability problems during the shutdown and start-up phases;a significant drop in efficiency is observed between the low-pressure section and high-pressure section; andlimited flexibility for the compression
train in terms of flow-rate range and composition.