Unlike other roof mounted appliances wind turbines and to a lesser degree, solar panels,
pose a problem with the sheer and compression loads that must be supported by the roof structure.
Most, use some sort of bolt on standoff approach, some are very invasive and use a pole mounted through the
attic space.
1. Fast Jack attachment system from Professional Solar Products Inc. provides a quick and strong installation solution. The patented design (U.S. Pat. No. 6,360,491) places the bolt directly under the stanchion post where it provides the most support. This feature allows standard roof flashing to lay flat on the roof
deck. The removable post allows flashing to be slipped over the base without damaging surrounding composition
shingles. The Fast Jack is an engineered and flash-able roof stanchion designed for optimum strength while using a single
lag bolt.
2. Unirac Solarmount PV Module Mounting
System works very similar to the Fast Jack
System. Whereas the Fast Jack systems uses a single
lag bolt the Unirac system uses two or more lag bolts.
3. Quick
Mount PV is an all-in-one waterproof flashing and
mount designed to anchor photovoltaic tracking systems and small wind turbines to a new or existing roof. The flashing includes an attached standoff block and stainless steel hardware to attach the system to the roof. No roof
cutting is required and again similar to the Fast Jack system is attached with a single lag bolt.
4. Sun Earth, another recommends the use of 1″
pipe nipples and floor flanges as the roof mounting system. The bottom
flange can be directly lag bolted into the rafter and the upper
flange serves the same purpose as the mounting foot to anchor photovoltaic
racking systems and small wind turbines to a new or existing roof. This system is anchored to the roof system with two or more lag bolts.
5. Windterra uses a “U” shaped channel attached to the roof rafters with lag bolts. The channel spans over several rafters giving it a larger area of distribution of forces.
6. Southwest Windpower uses a pole that you
mount through the roof and bolt directly to the roof structure in the
attic space. There system uses a special mounting puck that acts as vibration dampers. However, the system does nothing to stop or prevent
noise.
The severity of the angle and the trajectory of the
fastener's penetration into the rafter could cause the rafter to split; there by reducing the
structural integrity of the rafter itself and mounting system.
The Merrin design, as well as all similar prior art, have a common design limitation.
Also, because of the floor
flange design, it would not permit
industry standard flashing to install flat on the roof; primarily due to the base flashing circumference interfering with the height of the floor flange.
A mounting system based upon the Merrin patent, while appropriate for roof mounting of heavy objects such as air conditioners, is not practical for use with solar panels or
satellite dishes and definitely not with the load and force that are acting on wind turbines.
Further, Merrin views rafter attachment as a limitation and therefore teaches away from using rafters for structural support.
Therefore, Merrin teaches attachment to the roof decking which generally consists of only plywood or composite sheeting; either of which do not provide the strength of a bolt mounted to a rafter in an uplift condition.
There is nothing on the current market that completely addresses the needs of the wind
turbine industry.
Furthermore, none of the systems that are currently on the market have any vibration and
harmonic dampening.
None of the systems have been tested for earthquakes or high Wind sheer loads.
None of the systems have been submitted to the Department of Energy or the American Wind Energy Association for approval in the new small wind category.