The unconventional, oil sands and bitumen carbonate hydrocarbons are much more difficult and expensive to produce.
Mineable oil sands production is well known and successful, but environmentally is a problem.
Bitumen carbonates, located in the center of oil sands area of Alberta, are huge,
solid and impermeable deposits, and have no known economic method of production.
Oil shales, such as the Green River formation comprise
solid kerogens and likewise have no known economic method of extraction.
The
recovery methods available to date have been unsuccessful in economically recovering hydrocarbons from the vast amounts of heavy hydrocarbons contained in solid impermeable
carbonate rock formations such as the Grosmont carbonates and other bitumen carbonates of northern Alberta and the Green River formation oil shales and other
unconventional oil shales.
These methods are generally relatively expensive and are environmentally poor.
Fire flooding or in situ
combustion systems, such as
toe to
heel air injection (THAI), have also been attempted, but with limited success.
All of the three initial basic methods have several major economic and environmental drawbacks: a) large amounts of injected energy is required to power the process, which is expensive; b) large amounts of scarce water is used and polluted; and c) large quantities of
greenhouse gases are generated and released to the
atmosphere.
For unconventional oil or gas production extensive
hydraulic fracturing is required, which is expensive and generally has similar or worse environmental problems.
The cost to continuously do this is the major reason these processes are so expensive.
If they work at all it appears they may be only marginally economic.
To
attack and decompose more of the
carbonate minerals to extend the improvement in permeability requires more very expensive on-going injections of heat and / or solvents Like the bitumen carbonates, the oil shales are definitely less receptive to the methods that have been considered successful in oil sands production.
They have also created a number of problems, such as immense
fresh water usage and resulting contaminations.
Unconventional wells have very rapid decline rates and are very expensive.
Fracturing is a very expensive process that extracts a relatively small percentage of the hydrocarbons in place.
It also has been strongly criticized for its built-in
greenhouse gas and other negative environmental impacts.
To date there is no reported means of economically extracting hydrocarbons from these
kerogen deposits.
However, as is the case for the Talley process for carbonates, this process is essentially theoretical because heat must be injected continuously, thus making any in situ process prohibitively expensive.
There are currently no economic extraction solutions for the massive
oil shale deposits, such as the Green River formation in Colorado, Utah, and Wyoming.