Practically, however, helicopters are operated in a wide variety of environmental conditions which negatively affect their rotor blades.
For example, rain and environments having
abrasive particulate matter such as sand negatively affects rotor blades through erosion wear and
impact forces; dramatically reducing the rotor blades operational life.
Experience has shown that rain impinging upon the leading edges of rotating rotor blades cause erosion wear of the leading edges.
Additionally,
impact forces due to the
mass of the rain drops are transferred into the rotor blades which can damage the intrinsic de-
icing system and bond lines of the blade spars.
Environmental conditions having particulate matter, such as sand, present a different set of problems for rotor blades.
Sand typically does not have as great of a
mass as rain, however, it is extremely
abrasive and quickly erodes the rotor blades leading edges.
These leading edge caps provide good
wear resistance against rain impacts encountered during helicopter
flight operations, but are subject to quick erosion as a result of particulate impacts, typically in the form of sand, and provide little benefit against
energy transfer from
large particle impacts, e.g.,
impact forces due to rain.
Moreover, as experience in Desert
Storm revealed,
nickel and
titanium leading edge caps experienced undesired erosion wear when subjected to operations in a sand particle environment such as a desert.
Not only were the leading edge caps subjected to rapid erosion wear as a result of
forward flight through sand storms, but also as a result of hover operations, e.g., take-offs and landings, due to particulate sand motion caused by rotor blade vortices, i.e., downwash.
Sand erosion wear of the
nickel leading edge caps quickly leads to the need to replace such caps to maintain desired flight characteristics of the rotor blades.
However, inasmuch as the
nickel leading edge caps comprise an integral part of the rotor blade, i.e., such caps are adhesively bonded to the composite infrastructure, replacement of the eroded nickel edge caps is not a field level repair.
Such repair is expensive and results in significant
downtime for the affected helicopter.
Further, the cost of elastomeric sacrificial tape coatings is significantly less than nickel leading edge caps.
While the use of elastomeric sacrificial tape extends the useful life of the nickel leading edge caps with respect to sand
particle erosion, the maintenance cycle for replacement of worn elastomeric sacrificial tape makes the use of such tape a less than optimal solution.
Additionally, sand particles may become embedded in the tape thereby adding
mass and
surface roughness to the leading edge which can affect rotor blade balance and flight performance.
Still another deficiency is that
hydrolysis can occur when elastomeric tape is subjected to rain impacts, ultimately causing chucks of the elastomeric tape to break-off.
Another
disadvantage is that the mass of the elastomeric tape can cause the tape to debond from the rotor blade during flight.
Furthermore, due to the mass of the elastromeric tape, its application may require time-consuming tracking and balancing of the rotors blades.
These problems may be acerbated due to inconsistent application of the tape to the rotor blade and uneven distribution of mass throughout the elastomeric tape.
Under the aforementioned conditions, the useful erosion protection lifetime of elastomeric sacrificial tape is significantly reduced.
Notwithstanding the advantages stated in the Eaton et al. patent, ceramics have inherent disadvantages.
One downside is that ceramics may be brittle whereby microfractures develop under the stress and strain due to rotor blade flexure that occurs during
flight operations.
As performance of the stress
isolator is critical to the useful life of the
ceramic member, its construction may be limited to a
narrow range of suitable fabrications which adds complexity, mass and bulk to the engineered
ceramic component.
Another
disadvantage of the Eaton et al. patent is that the
ceramic member acts as an insulator such that de-
icing must be performed by a
cartridge heater which must be repaired or replaced at the OEM level, as opposed to de-icing by resistant heating which may be repaired or replaced at the field level.
Still another
disadvantage is that the ceramic member, being rigid, must to be preformed prior to being applied to the leading edge of a rotor blade, thereby eliminating the ability to form and apply the engineered ceramic component at field level.