This extra process step will not only increase the total
processing cost, but it will also complicate logistics as well as
weldability at the entrance of the
continuous annealing or hot dip galvanising line.
Cracks that are initiated in the weld or
heat affected zone, will easily propagate into the hard and brittle martensitic structure, leading to a high risk on complete rupture of the weld between two coils.
The second major drawback is related to the rather high Si content in these steels.
From about 0.5% Si on, these high Si contents are well known to provoke problems as to surface quality because of the presence of Si-oxides which after
pickling create a surface with irregular and very high roughness.
Moreover, in view of
corrosion protection, hot dip galvanising of such a high Si-containing substrate in general leads to insufficient surface appearance for automotive applications, with moreover a very high risk on the presence of bare spots on the surface.
The high Si content in this invention will however again impair hot dip galvanisability resulting in an insufficient surface appearance and a very high risk on bare spots.
The occurrence of red scale which is difficult to remove, on the hot strip, due to the higher Si content, is also expected to cause
processing difficulties.
However, Al, as opposed to Si, does not produce a strong
solid solution strengthening effect.
These high Al levels are however known to cause stickers during
continuous casting and impair
weldability due to the presence of Al-oxides in the welded area.
This is especially detrimental for the
crash behaviour of welded structures.
Steelmaking plants are therefore in general not willing to produce this kind of compositions because the workers have to carry masks and a lot of special precautions have to be taken.
All of them require the steel sheet to be held for 2 sec to 10 min. in an
atmosphere containing not less than 2%
ammonia in the temperature range 550-800° C. It is clear that this
nitriding step makes
processing a lot more difficult and requires complicated technical modifications to existing installations.
At the moment this process is internationally not considered to be industrially feasible.
Furthermore the very low alloying content of this steel grade, does not allow to reach tensile strength levels above 650 MPa.
However, as Al and Si are both ferrite stabilizers, their sum is limited in order to avoid over-stabilizing the retained
austenite.
The latter is considered to give rise to hot dip galvanising difficulties (bad wettability by molten Zn) and a deteriorated surface appearance (bare spots).
None of these example steels contained micro-alloying additions as in high Si-TRIP steels, these are known to markedly increase the hot strip
hardness, leading to strongly increased cold rolling forces.
A large
disadvantage of these compositions is the necessity of adding Cu and Ni, elements which are considered as impurities in bulk flat
carbon steel production.
Moreover, the use of Ni, Cu and Cr makes the alloying cost much more expensive.
Elongation values are in all cases rather low, which can be explained by the limited addition of Al and C, rendering the retained
austenite less stable.
This can lead to a non-compatibility between different galvanising lines (with e.g. different lengths of the
levelling zone around 490-460° C.) or even to strongly thickness-dependent mechanical properties.
This can be explained by the insufficient stabilisation of the retained
austenite and the shift of the optimum overageing time to noticeably longer times due to the too low Al-additions.
Furthermore the
weldability can be impaired due to the presence of Al-oxides in the welded area, a consequence of the high Al-contents.
As already explained before, the low-Al steel will suffer from mechanical properties that are very sensitive to process parameter variations such as line speed and overageing temperature.
This can lead to a non-compatibility between different galvanising lines or even to strongly thickness-dependent mechanical properties.
The high-Al steel on the other hand again requires the use of an adapted casting
powder that can give rise to
health problems.
Furthermore the weldability will be impaired due to the presence of Al-oxides in the welded area.
As no specifications were given related to the Al / Si ratio in this analysis, it is not possible to conclude about the galvanisability.
The mentioned P-content is insufficient for obtaining the desired mechanical properties (high tensile strength in combination with high elongation), whilst maintaining a good weldability (sufficient carbon content reduction).