Until recently, the significant,
observable negative consequences of
fossil fuel consumption were limited to relatively localized effects such as smog and
acid rain.
Now the majority of scientists believe that even
current consumption levels are contributing to changes in
global climate which
pose a high risk for the future stability of the biosphere.
This situation will worsen as consumption continues to grow.
However, it will be decades before such
alternative energy technologies displace fossil fuels sufficiently to tip the GHG balance.
Unfortunately, the steam cycles on which conventional
coal-fired generating plants are based run at net efficiencies below 40%.
However, most
waste heat sources are well below the temperature at which a need for energy exists elsewhere.
Consequently, the scope for application of passive heat
recovery is extremely limited.
Chemical heat pumps are limited to applications involving temperature ranges at which certain chemical reactions proceed at favourable rates.
This limits both the number of installations for which the technology is economic, and the flexibility of each installation to economically accommodate variations in operating conditions.
Because of the nature of the chemicals used, chemical heat pumps are also undesirable for some applications.
The major problems with vapour compression heat pumps lie in compressor technology (which is the heart of the vapour
compression pump) and the availability of suitable refrigerants.
More specifically, vapour compression heat pumps have historically been considered unreliable and are complex thereby requiring maintenance.
Many manufacturing companies are preoccupied with production-related equipment and therefore do not readily accept
peripheral equipment that might not work or cause operational problems to other operating
industrial systems.
Further, manufacturing companies do not want
peripheral equipment which requires specialized maintenance skills.
Another problem specifically with closed cycle vapour compression heat pumps is the necessity of handling, maintaining and using suitable working fluids (refrigerants).
Working fluids may be chemically unstable at temperatures high enough to be of interest, uneconomical or even hazardous (explosive or toxic or both).
However, there are several factors which severely limit the range of applicability for open cycle units.
For example, process liquids are sometimes corrosive or otherwise difficult to
handle, maintain and use which adds to the compressor cost.
Further, process liquids are frequently mixtures of liquids which evaporate at different temperatures and complicate the cycle.
Still further, process liquids frequently contain dissolved or
suspended solids, which complicates some installations or makes them unworkable.
Finally, open systems are not well suited to heat
recovery from waste liquids as
contamination of the working vapour with air is difficult to avoid and thereby limits
cycle efficiency and economic attractiveness.
Open cycle heat pumps at high temperatures are subject to the same compressor problems as their closed cycle counterparts.
Both open and closed cycle systems are subject to the limitation that a substantial amount of high cost electrical energy is required for vapour compression.