The present invention relates to new and useful oral tablet compositions which include an immediate release portion having an opioid analgesic and a non-opioid analgesic, providing for a rapid onset of therapeutic effect, and a sustained release portion of an opioid analgesic and a non-opioid analgesic, providing for a relatively longer duration of therapeutic effect. A multilayer oral dosage form containing a sustained release layer, which includes oxycodone and APAP, hydrocodone and APAP, or oxymorphone and APAP, and an immediate release layer containing the same active ingredients as the sustained release layer, is also disclosed. Also disclosed are oral tablet compositions, containing a sustained release core, which includes oxycodone and APAP, hydrocodone and APAP, or oxymorphone and APAP, and an immediate release coating containing the same active ingredients as the sustained release core, are also disclosed. In addition, methods of making and using such oral tablet compositions are disclosed.